I have been following the recent comments regarding the Belongil fish kill and, as someone who was involved in the 2021 review of the Belongil Creek Entrance Opening Strategy, along with flood engineers, ecologists, Crown Lands, Fisheries, Marine Parks, local landholders and community representatives, I am concerned that some of the discussion implies there is no established strategy guiding Council’s management of the estuary.
The current strategy was developed through an extensive review process and incorporates an adaptive management framework intended to balance ecological outcomes, flood mitigation and community interests.
For me, the key question is not whether there should be an opening strategy, but whether the existing strategy is responding adequately to current conditions.
Given recent events, including the fish kill, a more constructive discussion would be whether the 2021 revision of the Belongil Creek Entrance Opening Strategy remains adequate to meet its ecological, flood management and community objectives. In particular, it may be timely to assess whether the assumptions, trigger levels, monitoring program and environmental safeguards established during the 2021 review remain fit for purpose under current conditions.
Good environmental management is not about questioning the need for a strategy whenever an issue arises. It is about regularly reviewing the available evidence and determining whether the strategy continues to achieve its intended outcomes.


For four decades The Echo has printed the stories some people loved, some people hated, and some pretended not to read. If you want us to keep telling the truth, the real truth, not the sugar-coated version. We’ll need your support to keep the presses rolling.