18.8 C
Byron Shire
November 27, 2022

Byron ‘dodges a bullet’ with Telstra site sale

Latest News

Emergency radio tower

An emergency radio tower is proposed for Teales Lookout, Koonyum Range. It is proposed by the telco authority via Catalyst...

Other News

Cinema: Black Panther: Wakanda Forever

In the sequel to Marvel’s Black Panther, starring Chadwick Boseman, who played King T’Challa, the Black Panther and the...

Star City Casino fine should go to most vulnerable: Community Foundation

The Northern Rivers Community Foundation (NRCF), has joined with seven other Community Foundations from across the state to call on the NSW Premier to use the money from the Star Sydney Casino fine to help vulnerable communities.

Killer Queen & Bowie

For the first time, two of Australia’s favourite live acts – The Killer Queen Experience, and Bowie, starring Jeff...

The need to elaborate

While we certainly share the concerns of Christopher Wright (Echo 9 Nov, 2022), as long time anti-war, peace activists,...

Linda Reynolds – it is time to resign

There ought to be a second loser from the whole Bruce Lehrmann aborted trial fiasco – Western Australian Liberal Senator, Linda Reynolds. 

Police youth assault case back to court

A naked, 16 year old boy was handcuffed and struck repeatedly by police in Lateen Lane, Byron Bay on 11 January, 2018. The case is once again back in court.

Auctioneer Colin Banks holds aloft Council general manager Pamela Westing’s hand after the succesful bid on the Mullumbimby site in 2008. Photo: Lou Beaumont/Byron Shire Echo
Auctioneer Colin Banks holds aloft Council general manager Pamela Westing’s hand after the succesful bid on the Mullumbimby site in 2008. Photo: Lou Beaumont/Byron Shire Echo

Chris Dobney

Byron Shire Council has announced the sale of the former Telstra site adjacent to Woolworths in Mullumbimby for $517,000, just $10,000 more than it was bought for in 2008, when it was promoted as a big win for the community.

The council announced the purchase with fanfare in a front page story in the Byron Shire Echo on February 26 that year, with then Byron GM Pamela Westing telling the paper, ‘I never thought I’d have so much fun at work!’

Then mayor Jan Barham was equally enthusiastic, telling the paper, ‘We considered an urgency motion at our meeting on February 14 and we acted. We didn’t want to think in future about an opportunity missed. We are thrilled we could secure an important community asset that has such great potential.

‘Lots of opportunity comes with this land purchase, it has a number of potential uses, she said.

‘Council is not a major landholder, so any acquisition of this kind will be put to good use.

‘There is a need for good land whether it is used for community infrastructure of some kind or affordable housing or whatever. It is a safe investment,’ then mayor Barham added.

But the community appetite for the property appeared to evaporate with the heady mood, and the discovery not long after purchase that the land would need expensive remediation works before any permanent building works or long-term occupation could take place.

Current Byron Shire mayor and fellow Greens councillor Simon Richardson said the council was ultimately relieved to have sold the property for a modest profit without having to fork out for expensive remediation.

‘When we bought it we found out there was serious contamination. So that straight away constrained what short-term things we could do,’ he told Echonetdaily yesterday.

‘Then we looked at what we could do short-term. We were offering leases at pretty low rent at what we could lease it for an the best offer we got was from an equipment hire place to use it for extra storage. It was still going to cost us a little bit just to mitigate,’ he added.

‘I put up different resolutions over the years looking for social service or community groups for a day drop-in centre and none of them were interested. The issues were the short-term nature of any tenancy and their capacity to provide a worthwhile service.

‘We couldn’t find an identifiable group who wanted to use it.’

Sold to the highest bidder: the ex-Telstra site in Mullumbimby, which Byron Shire Council bought with great fanfare in 2008 and sold for a $10,000 profit last week. Photo Chris Dobney
Sold to the highest bidder: the ex-Telstra site in Mullumbimby, which Byron Shire Council bought with great fanfare in 2008 and sold for a $10,000 profit last week. Photo Chris Dobney

Cr Richardson added that when council reluctantly decided to sell the property, they first looked for a buyer that would have a community use in mind.

‘I moved a few ‘creative Mullum’ proposals [supporting people] who wanted to value-add to make it a good community spot. There was a lot of talk of what we could do.

‘The last opportunity we had was to change the zoning to allow more uses to allow some of the more creative ideas that wouldn’t be permissible on the site [under the previous LEP].

‘We hoped that when someone took it over they could do more than just commercial. We then gave them notice to get back to us but we received nothing by August and the LEP was finalised – and they were the two triggers for the property to be sold,’ he said.

‘I even put a notice of motion to postpone the auction if anyone could present something. When I pushed that, all that really came back was “there a couple of people who were kind of interested”. So nothing had progressed in a year.’

Cr Richardson said he ‘tried to get a broader outcome’ but in the end the various proponents ‘had nothing to show’.

‘The developer isn’t associated with Woolies or anything like that but they are looking to onsell it but we will just have to wait and see as to what goes on at the site.

‘We thought we’d lose on it, given there was $100,000 needed to remediate the site. Most people would walk away and say we dodged a bullet.’

‘Lacking foresight’

But former mayor and Greens MLC Jan Barham disagrees and believes the council could have borrowed money or obtained government grants to build affordable housing and community facilities on the site.

‘I’m just not sure about the principal of selling property for a financial “crisis” that really isn’t evident,’ she told Echonetdaily.

‘It’s one of the best bits of property in the shire, probably in terms of being able to do commercial and residential and have an ongoing income for council for half a million, which is a bit of a disappointment.

She said the move lacked foresight.

‘We’ve done an affordable housing strategy. We probably could’ve put six little one-bedroom flats on top of a community commercial building and we would’ve had ongoing income.

‘Ms Barham said she had been trying to locate where council had done a comparison of section 94 funds against infrastructure expenditure.

‘I’ve seen reports of underfunded infrastructure, so they should be spending money that they hold already for developments.

‘I’m not a strong believer in the deficit principle, I think holding onto property that provides social and community benefit is a better long-term investment,’ she added.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. For once I agree with Jan. That property is in a strategic location and council should have invested some money in it and turned it into a useful community development that turned over money. Affordable housing, community commercial, a theatre for live performances and music. Use your imagination. And what will council do with the proceeds, small as they are? I sincerely hope they don’t go into some reduce the deficit hole. What are we getting into ? Sell a valuable asset to pay off debts, then it’s gone for good? Sounds like Liberal Party mentality.
    Bad move Council. Very short sighted of you. I’m disappointed. Where is the vision you are supposed to have?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Ballina water supply

A recent Echo article regarding Rous County Council’s plans to access Alstonville ground water through bores for its Future Water Project 2060 via an...

For the record

Since early January 2020 when the COVID-19 pandemic started, when the world population started to be informed of the new health danger facing everybody,...

From an okay Boomer

As an okay Boomer who has lived in Mullumbimby most of my life, I’ve seen many changes in town, particularly since the Great COVID...

Rally against a waste incinerator for Casino

Residents Against the Richmond Valley Incinerator (RAVI) and community members have planned a rally for tomorrow to alert the community about the issues surrounding waste incinerators and the problems they bring.