26.5 C
Byron Shire
March 27, 2023

Byron Council defeats Belongil rock wall injunction

Latest News

Helping our elders on April Falls Day

April Falls Month is an annual campaign to raise awareness about the impact of falls and to promote the latest best practice fall prevention strategies. The overall campaign goal is to get active and improve balance for fall prevention.

Other News

Dr Leon Ankersmit looks at mining, and thermal waste incinerators in the Clarence

Dr Leon Ankersmit has stated that he supports the position of no mining in the Clarence catchment but has stopped short of signing the Clarence Catchment Alliance pledge to 'ban mining in the Clarence catchment.

Mediation fails over large Suffolk Park DA

The battle over a controversial mixed-used development proposed for the main street of Suffolk Park looks set to go to a full hearing in the Land and Environment Court with Byron Shire Council, after the court-ordered conciliation process failed.

Dredging rivers: what are the Ballina candidates’ positions?

A recent Meet the Candidates evening in Ocean Shores saw discussion around how to manage local river systems, which have silted up over generations, and likely contributed to the high flood levels experienced in 2022.

Residents of Cabbage Tree Island want to go home

Anger and frustration at not being able to go home saw a group of residents reclaim their properties yesterday on Cabbage Tree Island.

Janelle Saffin holds the seat of Lismore

Janelle Saffin is in the lead for the seat of Lismore after yesterday's state election. Although preroll and postal votes are yet to be counted, it’s hard to imagine Saffin’s position changing.

Nationals and Labor didn’t sign Clarence anti-mining pledge

The Clarence Catchment Alliance (CCA) have been seeking the support of all candidates running for the seat of Clarence...

A protest agains the proposed Belongil rock wall took place on Wednesday September 8.  (picture: taojonesphotographer.com)
A protest against the proposed Belongil rock wall took place on Wednesday September 8. (picture: taojonesphotographer.com)

Hans Lovejoy

Byron Shire Council’s bulldozers are expected to start work on the contentious Belongil rock wall this week after the injunction to stop it from being built failed last Friday.

But it appears the fight is far from over.

Environmental group Positive Change for Marine Life, being represented by the Environmental Defenders Office (EDO), took council on over its lack of adequate environmental assessment.

CEO Karl Goodsell told Echonetdaily the group is disappointed with the outcome of the hearing in the Land and Environment Court.

‘The judge said that, “If rock walls can be built, rock walls can be dismantled”.’

‘We are looking forward to receiving the court’s reasons for the decision, which will be delivered in the coming days. If we are correct on the ultimate question regarding significant impacts on the environment, then the wall may be removed even if council decide to proceed with construction.

‘We would like to thank the EDO, our barristers and the community for all of their hard work and support in this matter.’

Meanwhile a Byron Shire councillor opposed to the works says that benefitting landowners have pitched in financially to help council defend itself in court, however a Council spokesperson said that the landowners were not contributing financially to council’s case.

Cr Duncan Dey (Greens) said, ‘[The] most interesting outcome is that the benefitting landholders joined with council against the injunction. The issue is moral, not legal. How moral is it to build this wall just before you discuss the issue of whether to rock or not rock[wall] your coast?’

Known rather oddly as lnterim Beach Access Stabilisation Works, the rock wall project will cost ratepayers nearly $1million and funds have even been shuffled from staff leave entitlements to make it happen. The project has seen extreme public scrutiny and criticism, firstly because it is setting a precedent and secondly because council staff do not know its legal implications .

There are many unknowns: there is no known example of rocks being removed once in place, and the project comes without mitigation in place for the expected sand loss on the iconic public beach.

Additionally, a recent freedom of information request by former Greens mayor Jan Barham revealed that the top coastal panel which advises the NSW government is not in favour of using rocks for the project.

Councillors were advised of the outcome of the recent court action by an internal memo from infrastructure services director Phil Holloway, who said that the applicant’s notice of motion was dismissed, resulting in no injunction.

‘Proceedings were stood over to 9.15 am Tuesday, September 15 for the court to make directions for the running of the final hearing sometime between October 6 and 26 2015.

‘[The] costs of the applicant’s unsuccessful motion for the interim injunction were reserved… the hearing of the matter is to be expedited.’


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. what this article fails to mention is the statement on the Byron Resident Groups page, which explains that if the council proceed to build now they do so knowing they are risking the cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars to remove the rocks again when they lose the proper hearing in October.
    So, if they proceed it demonstrates just how willing they are to dispose of ratepayers funds and how obsessed they are with persuing their own agenda no matter the cost (financial or otherwise)
    hopefully they will surprise us by delaying until the final decision in october is made

  2. Cheer up, slow down, chill out…Byron’s own 1%ers are going to get their way. Real estate agents and developers left the door open for these people years ago. There was a time long ago when Byronites were so excited to hear Byrontown mentioned in the news. What could possibly go wrong?? Byron is now Australia’s version of Hollywood. Over sexed, over priced and over here.

  3. Well there’s a balanced article by Echo. I guess the Council’s side of the story must have been accidentally left out
    Note to Editor: publishing an article where only one side of an argument is presented, to the uninvolved reader detracts from the validity of that very argument.

  4. Exactly Greg. Very one sided. The extreme greens would like to see the whole of the Belongil spit washed away. I’m not sure who that benefits? Not even the crabs. Good to see common sense from the judge supporting common sense from the majority of councillors. The sand bags were not working and most of the rocks are protecting council land and public access. Belongil is the oldest subdivision in Byrob and needs to be preserved. Not further developed – but preserved.

  5. Byron councillors are craning their necks out as Council cranes are expected to lift rocks into place on the contentious Belongil rock wall this week after the injunction by lawyers to stop construction failed last Friday.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Closing the Gap on Aboriginal health in the Byron Shire

Close the Gap aims to reduce disadvantage experienced by Indigenous peoples with respect to child mortality, childhood education, life expectancy and health.

Lismore Council wants you to have your say

Lismore City Council is inviting residents and members of the community to contribute to Your Say Lismore, an innovative online platform that creates a two-way conversation between the community and Council. 

Cartoon of the week – 15 March 2023

The letters deadline for The Echo is noon Friday. Letters longer than 200 words may be cut. The publication of letters is at the discretion of the letters editor.

NEFA welcomes the election of a new government

The North East Forest Alliance welcomes the election of the Minns Labor government with their promise to create a Great Koala National Park, and calls for a moratorium on logging within the park proposal until the promised assessment is complete.