28.2 C
Byron Shire
February 4, 2023

NSW Forestry ‘stacked’ expert panel

Latest News

Go Thistles!

Lismore Thistles Soccer Club has launched the Thistles Acceleration Program, in the process becoming the city’s only player development academy. 

Other News

Looking forward, looking back with Jeff Johnson

Long term independent Ballina Shire Councillor Jeff Johnson reflects on the challenges of the past year, and his priorities for 2023.


Warren Kennedy wrote an excellent letter last week (28 January) pointing out the deficiencies of capitalism as it exists...

We’ve had the rain bomb, is a fire bomb next?

We had the Black Summer fires and then the floods and NSW Farmers says time is running out to prevent more mass bushfires at the end of this year.

Letters – 1 February 2023

The Echo loves your letters and is proud to provide a community forum on the issues that matter most to our readers and the people of the NSW north coast. So don’t be a passive reader, send us your epistles.

Abouchar honoured with Order of Australia

The new head of the Byron Community College (BCC), Chantal Abouchar, has been awarded the Medal of the Order of Australia (OAM) for her contributions to business and the media.


What have they done to our Vinnies here in Mullum? They’ve killed it! It has reopened and it is...

The Whian Whian logging site with logs piled up for removal and the logging track at right. Photo Marie Cameron
Logging at Whian Whian in 2013. Forestry Corp staff now dominate an ‘independent’ EPA panel on threatened species, according to NCEC. Photo Marie Cameron

A freedom of information request by a north coast environment group has revealed that an ‘independent’ panel of the Environment Protection Authority (EPA) advising on threatened species is dominated by serving and former NSW Forestry Corporation staff.

A spokesperson for the group has described the move as ‘state sanctioned environmental destruction’.

The North Coast Environment Council (NCEC) made the GIPA (Government Information Public Access) application after the authority failed to make public the make-up of the panel.

The Threatened Species Expert Panel is advising the EPA on the re-writing of the logging rules for public forests.

According to NCEC, the documents show that far from being ‘independent experts’ they are government employees, dominated by current and former employees of Forestry Corp.

The EPA have refused to release any of the panel’s recommendations on the grounds that they ‘reveal or tend to reveal the position that a particular minister has taken, is taking or will take on a matter in cabinet’.

North Coast Environment Council spokesperson Susie Russell described the refusal as ‘an abuse of the exemption for cabinet documents in freedom of information law’.

‘It is difficult to see how the notes made by someone at a workshop could reveal a minister’s position, unless of course there was political interference in the process and someone said that the minister had a particular view, or wanted a particular outcome,’ Ms Russell said.

‘This confirms our impression that the EPA’s re-writing of the rules covering logging in State Forests is an overtly political process being run by the Forestry Corporation. It is no wonder they are resisting our attempts to find out what the panel’s recommendations were,’ she said.

OEH panel members withdrew

‘We know now, that the Expert Panel includes 13 people, not the 20 claimed by the EPA on their website. The claimed independent experts are ex-Forestry Corporation employees. The EPA’s representative even worked for the Forestry Corporation until recently.

According to NCEC, the EPA’s Threatened Species Expert Panel had three workshops in Sydney in March 2014.

The first consisted of ‘a Forestry Corp employee sitting down with someone else from the Department of Primary Industries, to decide the fate of koalas,’ NCEC says.

The second was ‘dominated by current and former employees of Forestry Corp’, NCEC says after ‘two zoologists from the North Coast Office of Environment and Heritage withdrew from the meeting’.

The third workshop dealt with flora.

Dailan Pugh of the North East Forest Alliance (NEFA) said it was ‘shocking that the EPA are now proposing to remove the need to do pre-logging surveys to identify and protect core habitat for koala, spotted-tailed quoll, squirrel glider, golden-tipped bat, brush-tailed phascogale, Hastings River mouse, rufous scrub-bird, Albert’s lyrebird, marbled frogmouth, giant narred frog and many other threatened species.’

‘The Forestry Corporation has long-resented having to protect threatened species because they mean less timber and now the EPA’s stacked process is set to deliver what they want. This whole sham process is driven by a desperate hunt for timber to meet unsustainable wood contracts, he added.

‘Given that the EPA are proposing zoning over 140,000 hectares of north-east NSWs forests for widespread clear-felling and to allow intensification of logging elsewhere, while at the same time reducing streamside protection buffers, they should be increasing protection for threatened species not removing it,’ Mr Pugh said.

‘These are not actions of a genuine environmental protection agency, this is state sanctioned environmental destruction,’ Ms Russell said.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Sadly it is not a surprise that the current Liberal government wants to redefine what environmental values are. I hope we can trust them to do an equally thorough job when they rewrite the rules on threatened species next year

  2. Doesn’t surprise anybody does it ?
    The Forestry Corporation has long specialised in ignoring and circumventing any rational regulations aimed at protecting the environment and protecting forestry workers jobs into the immediate future . It seems they have long understood that present methods are unsustainable and have therefore decided on the “rape and pillage” of every vestige of nature ,to the extent of logging forests that are thousands of years old and containing unknown treasures of biology, for wood-chip or possibly to burn in power-stations, in order to claim “carbon credits “.
    These are the real terrorists and are destroying more than ISIS, here in Australia.
    You can’t blame a bunch of knuckle-dragging forestry workers, it is the managers and government officials that enable this ‘crime against humanity’ and the citizens of Australia to continue. Meanwhile,the timber millers are receiving ludicrous subsidies to aid in this willful destruction of the “commonwealth”

  3. This situation does not surprise me.

    There is currently a proposal to mine ilmenite in Bundjalung National Park by NPWS and guess what?

    Objections to that proposal are being determined by OEH staff. Obviously not at arms length as NPWS and OEH are under the same Minister.

    The submission period closed over 10 months ago and still no result. Do you think it might have something to do with the depressed price of ilmenite? Or maybe they hope to slip it past when no one appears to be looking.

    This mining will go on for five years and ruin tourist and visitor experiences at Black Rocks Camping Ground.

    The Gap Road will become a nightmare of 40 tonne monsters destroying the narrow gravel road and endangering the lives of other road users.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Pothole protest gets immediate results

Psst: want to get Council staff to do something about the appalling state of roads in your neighbourhood? Organise a protest outside Mullum’s Council Chambers! By...

What’s Love Got to Do with It?

Art imitates life in What’s Love Got to Do with It? a 2022 British romantic comedy-drama film directed by Shekhar Kapur, from a screenplay by Jemima Khan.  The precis reads: ‘Set between London and Lahore, a filmmaker documents her childhood friend and neighbour’s arranged marriage to a bride from Pakistan.’

We’ve had the rain bomb, is a fire bomb next?

We had the Black Summer fires and then the floods and NSW Farmers says time is running out to prevent more mass bushfires at the end of this year.

A smorgasbord of flicks

This year’s smorgasbord of over 40 incredible short films are handpicked from a record 3,200 entries received for Flickerfest’s Academy® and BAFTA Qualifying short-film festival screened recently in Bondi, and Northern Rivers audiences are the first in Australia to experience the best of Flickerfest on tour. Highlights enjoying their Northern Rivers premiere include recent Academy® nominees and much-loved festival award winners alongside exciting, fresh, local talent.