16.5 C
Byron Shire
April 15, 2021

Statute ‘loophole’ sees NSW Forestry avoid fines

Latest News

SCU named as partner in two national drought hubs

Southern Cross University has been announced as playing a crucial partnership role in two new Drought Resilience Adoption and Innovation Hubs.

Other News

Linen SHIFT project urgently needs new home

With a vision to disrupt the cycle of women’s homelessness, the Linen SHIFT project was born to provide unique individual support and education for at-risk women in a safe residential environment, but today they they have been forced to close.

Rocky Creek Field Day coming in July

As part of the Rural Landholder Initiative, rural landholders in the Rocky Creek area are invited to an Off-stream Watering and Riparian Habitat Field Day.

$1500 council fee rebates for farmers

NSW Farmers commends the NSW Government on its delivery of a rebate scheme for NSW and local government fees and charges, following its $500 million commitment in the State Budget last year.

Where announcements masquerade as action

The great secret about government in Australia is this: no-one wants to know about government in Australia.

Rotary Downunder Baton handed over at Byron Bay

The Rotary Club of Byron Bay recently took the Rotary Downunder Baton to the most easterly point of Australia as part of its national journey. As well as being the national celebration of one hundred years of service by Rotary in Australia, the theme for the centenary is 'Rotary says no to domestic violence'.

Inspector condemns prisoner health services

In the forward to the Inspector of Custodial Services Report published last month, Fiona Rafter Inspector of Custodial Services says that the provision of health services to inmates in New South Wales custodial facilities is a complex and challenging responsibility.

Protestor on a bamboo tripod on private land being logged at Whian Whian in 2013 minutes before hew was removed by police. Photo Jeff Dawson
Protestor on a bamboo tripod on private land being logged at Whian Whian in 2013 minutes before hew was removed by police. EPA later fined NSW Forestry over breaches at the site but the government department used a loophole to avoid paying the fines. Photo Jeff Dawson

Chris Dobney

The Environment Protection Authority (EPA) took so long to investigate breaches by NSW Forestry Corp during its controversial 2013 harvesting on private land at Whian Whian that the body was able to avoid paying fines as a result of the time that had elapsed.

The gung-ho operation, which saw the death of one forestry worker and the destruction of numerous threatened habitat trees, was only investigated, the EPA admits, owing to public pressure.

In a remarkable letter to the Whian Whian Forest Alliance dated December 18, EPA forestry director Gary Whytcross admitted that the investigation ‘took an extended time to complete’ so that ‘these penalty notices were only issued just before the statute bar period’.

Then, in an extraordinary twist, NSW Forestry sat on the notices for more than the legal limit of 28 days so when it finally informed the State Debt Recovery office of its intentions to go to court the statute bar period had expired.

EPA says the incident has revealed a loophole in the legislation, which will ask the government to investigate and fix.

The authority also said it was unable to determine whether NSW Forestry had broken the law in constructing a logging track in too-close proximity to threatened Arrow Head vines as insufficient surveying of the species had taken place.

As a result of the EPA’s investigations NSW Forestry was fined $5,500 for each of two breaches: not implementing a 20 metre exclusion zone around protected koala trees and a similar failure over an endangered Slender Marsdenia plant (Marsdenia longiloba).

EPA also found the exclusion zones of four Red Bopple Nut plants (Hickbeachia pinnatifolia) were not implemented.

Despite the trees being threatened NSW Forestry was only issued with cautions over this breach.

But the real sting of the letter was in the EPA’s admissions that none of the fines would now have to be paid.

‘When a penalty notice is issued the recipient can either pay the fine or elect to have the matter determined by the court. For these penalty notices FCNSW elected to have the matters determined in court. Unfortunately, in this circumstance this court election was not effected until after the statute period had expired. Due to the timing of this decision the EPA is therefore unable to continue this matter through the courts,’ Mr Whytcross wrote.

‘The State Debt Recovery Office (SDRO) manages the penalty notice process once they are issued. The recipient of a penalty notice is required to inform the SDRO of their intentions within 28 days of receiving the notice. FCNSW did not notify the SDRO within the 28 days and by the time they did the statute period for the offences had expired,’ he continued.

Mr Whytcross said the EPA was ‘very disappointed that we are now not able to now prosecute this matter in court’.

‘These are very unusual circumstances and as a result of this the EPA is reviewing its procedures for issuing penalty notices to ensure that this situation does not occur in the future. The EPA will ensure that all matters are electronically recorded and tracked.

‘The EPA Board has been informed of the matter and has requested the EPA to examine the legislative framework, including the Fines Act, to determine if changes are required to ensure these circumstances do notoccur again.

Mr Whytcross admitted it was ‘a disappointing outcome given the time and effort that has been put into this investigation.’

But he added ‘on a positive note… the EPA and the EPA Board have been keen to see a significant increases in forestry related penalties and were pleased to see minister Speakman’s confirmation that the government will have announcements about these penalties in the new year.’


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Oh sure. All these Govt depts are corporations in business to make a profit so of course they will support other corporations raping the earth. The main thing to them is to appear to be doing something when in fact they have not the slightest intention of doing a darn thing. We should not let them get away with this!

  2. WHY, is that stupid environmentally evangelistic tree shagger. Using Green Bamboo in our native forest? does he not realise how rampant and easy to propagate it is? obviously not,., Im so glad Tasmania still has stacks of v pretty native forest after 200+ years of us idiots going hard at it, and not too many city bred imported enviro bafoons left to deal with. Its all good protecting something,, if you know what your doing.. if not, stay home and knit lama socks for your soy based gluten free vegetarian eco boyfriends, and stay the fuck out of the forest.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

ALP puts war power reform on the agenda

The Australian Labor Party will hold a public inquiry into how Australia goes to war if elected to government next year.

Help from Red Cross for flood-affected communities in NSW

With disasters coming thick and fast as the climate emergency worsens, Australian Red Cross this morning launched financial help for flood-affected communities in NSW.

Rocky Creek Field Day coming in July

As part of the Rural Landholder Initiative, rural landholders in the Rocky Creek area are invited to an Off-stream Watering and Riparian Habitat Field Day.

Professor Graham Samuel says dementia care is personal

In a moving address to the National Press Club in Canberra yesterday, Dementia Australia Chair Professor Graham Samuel AC shared his personal experience of dementia – the anguish, bewilderment, frustration and torment experienced by his mother as she descended into the abyss of the disease.