15.4 C
Byron Shire
May 25, 2022

Blackout used by friends of the coal industry to bash renewables

Latest News

Bringing learning and play together

Byron Bay High School’s new agility course recognises the importance of play for learning and has students from all years actively playing during breaks and PDHPE lessons, according to Byron Bay High’s Principal, Janine Marcus.

Other News

The floods are leaving people homeless and families split

There was a housing crisis on the Northern Rivers, then we had the floods of 2022 and the issue has left increasing numbers of people homeless and struggling to find alternative accommodation.

Interviews with Richmond candidates 2022: Liberal Democrats Party candidate Gary Biggs

Gary Biggs lives in the Tweed Shire and owns a small business. He is running as a candidate for the Liberal Democrats Party in the federal seat of Richmond.

Richmond candidates 2022: Informed Medical Options Party candidate Monica Shepherd

Monica Shepherd is an organic naturopath based in Ocean Shores. She is running as a candidate for the Informed Medical Options Party in the federal seat of Richmond.

Australian politics transformed

Following an election like no other, Australia looks set to change course on climate and corruption, with the Coalition's Scott Morrison being prised from office and Anthony Albanese about to form a new Labor government with the support of Greens and teal independents.

Richmond candidates 2022: The Greens, Mandy Nolan

Mandy Nolan needs little introduction to most readers of The Echo, where she has a weekly column. She is a comedian and journalist running as a candidate for The Greens in the federal seat of Richmond.

Suspicious house fire in Casino ends in charges

NSW Police say that man has been charged following a suspicious house fire.

High-voltage transmission lines were brought down by a freak weather event which caused the SA blackout, yet the mouthpiece for the coal industry, the coalition government, wants us to believe renewable energy is to blame.
High-voltage transmission lines were brought down by a freak weather event which caused the SA blackout, yet the mouthpiece for the coal industry, the coalition government, wants us to believe renewable energy is to blame.

By Giles Parkinson, reneweconomy.com.au

The Coalition government launched a ferocious attack against wind and solar energy after the major South Australian blackout, even though energy minister Josh Frydenberg and the grid operators admit that the source of energy had nothing to do with catastrophic outage.

Frydenberg, however, lined up with prime minister Malcolm Turnbull, deputy prime minister Barnaby Joyce, One Nation’s Malcolm Roberts, independent Senator Nick Xenophon and a host of conservative commentators, including Andrew Bolt, Alan Moran, the ABC’s Chris Ullmann, and Fairfax’ Brian Robins to exploit the blackout to question the use of renewable energy.

Frydenberg used the blackout to continue his persistent campaign against the renewable energy targets of state Labor governments in South Australia, Victoria and Queensland, saying that the blackout was proof that these targets were ‘unrealistic.’

He made clear that he wanted the states – South Australia and Queensland which are pushing for 50 per cent renewable energy, and Victoria 40 per cent – to abandon their schemes and conform to the federal target, which has target of about 23.5 per cent renewables.

The federal scheme effectively ends in 2020, while the state based schemes provide longer term investment signals by providing a 2025 and 2030 timeframes.

‘These states are pursuing these unrealistic targets ,’ Frydenberg told ABC’s AM program. ‘My job is to try and get these states to the table … only the Commonwealth, with 23.5%, is a realistic target.’

His comments were later repeated by Turnbull, who accused state Labor governments for imposing ‘ideological’ renewable energy targets, describing the South Australian blackout as a ‘wake-up call’ to focus on energy security.

(It should be noted that South Australia’s wind fleet was built via the federal target, which is a bipartisan policy between the Coalition and Labor. It has a state target, but it is aspirational only, it has no particular state measures).

Turnbull said there was ‘no doubt’ that the ‘extremely aggressive’ shift to renewables had strained the electricity network.

hornsdale-squareThe attacks on renewables by Turnbull and Frydenberg were the most dogmatic since Tony Abbott and Joe Hockey said they found wind turbines to be ‘offensive’ and expressed a wish that they could all be brought down.

Electranet, which runs the grid in South Australia, and other grid authorities have made clear that the blackout – which is unprecedented in Australia and led to its first ever ‘black start’ – would have happened whatever the fuel source at the time.

Bruce Mountain goes into detail on what was happening in this analysis here. But it is now clear that 23 high voltage power poles were lost in five different locations, bringing down three of the big four transmission lines that carry electricity to and from the north of the state, sparking a state-wide outage and its isolation from Victoria.

‘South Australia gets more of its energy from renewables, more than 40% from wind,’ Frydenberg said. ‘There are questions with renewable energy, particularly because it is intermittent.’

His Coalition partner, agriculture minister and deputy prime minister Joyce, reprised his long crusade against wind energy, saying wind power ‘doesn’t work when their is excessive wind and it wasn’t working too well last night because there was a blackout.’ Neither were the gas generators, minister.

His views were echoed by the likes of Roberts, Xenophon, the fossil fuel lobby, the South Australian opposition, and even ABC commentator Chris Uhlmann, who agreed with Joyce that the wind farms were not working because the wind was blowing too hard. A column by Fairfax’s Brian Robins, also blaming renewables, was dismissed as ‘absolute garbage’ by the head of the Clean Energy Council.

The Coalition’s attacks were predictable. They occurred last November when a smaller blackout was caused by another transmission fault but was again blamed on wind, and are part of an ongoing campaign against renewables that has now turned its focus to state based initiatives.

Curiously, no such allegations were raised when West Australia experienced a major black out last week, when 130,000 customers lost power for more than an hour when a gas fired generator tripped, or when more than 200,000 people were left without power for more than a week in coal-reliant New South Wales last year after more storm damage to poles and wires.

‘South Australia gets more of its energy from renewables, more than 40 per cent from wind,’ Frydenberg said. ‘There are questions with renewable energy, particularly because it is intermittent.’

He then had the hide, like Turnbull, to say: ‘We have to put aside partisanship and ideologocial approach to emission reductions.’ This from a party that has scrapped the carbon price, tried to demolish the Climate Change Authority, the Clean Energy Finance Corporation, and the Australian Renewable Energy Agency, and still has no policies to meet its Paris climate targets.

Frydenberg then also questioned the cost of wind and solar, saying they could cost up to $100/MWh, while coal fired generation only cost $50/MWh and gas fired generation was $80/MWh.

His comments appear to ignore the falling cost of renewable technologies, and the rising cost of gas. The latest wind farms in South Australia will be built at a cost of $77/MWh, and that price is fixed for 20 years. (It translates into a current price in the high $50/MWh).

Solar is also coming down in cost. Contracts were written in the recent ARENA action for around $90/MWh, and as the supply chain grows and module costs come down quickly, they will soon be much cheaper than gas-fired generation.

It is also stunning that Frydenberg is making such comparisons when he knows that these are assets that last 25-30 years, and that much of Australia’s existing generation will need to replaced in coming decades.

And it is not clear that gas plants are cheaper than wind and solar. The rising cost of gas means that many gas fired plants won’t switch on for less than $100/MWh, and some peaking plants won’t be bid at less than $200/MWh. South Australia’s long term reliance on gas has long been the cause of its high prices.

It could be that the unprecedented  nature of the outage, combined with similar storm outages in NSW and Queensland during the 2011 floods, could lead to a focus on a more ‘climate resilient’ grid, which would mean more local generation and micro-grids. This has been the main focus of policy in the US, for instance, after Hurricane Sandy.

There was applause, however, about the ability of the grid operator to restore power so quickly. ‘Black starts’ – where the grid has to start all over – have never been attempted before, energy sources said, and are tricky because as each generator comes back into production, it has to be matched to demand to avoid another trip.

Within 12 hours, almost all of the state was back on line, although the worst affected, including the Eyre Peninsula, may be without power for days because of the huge scale of the infrastructure damage.

The renewable energy industry said it was disappointed that conservative politicians were using the blackout to further their ideological agendas.

Tom Butler, the policy manager at the Clean Energy Council, said no connection has been established to the state’s renewable energy generation.

‘It is important to remember that this is a once-in-50-year storm, and no power system can fully prepare for the savage winds, lightning and hail that pounded the state today. It is a freak event.’

The secretary of the Communication Electrical and Plumbing Union of South Australia John Adley said critics of wind energy did not know what they were talking about.

‘The outage is simply being used by friends of the coal industry to bash renewables,’ he said. ’It doesn’t matter how you generate your electricity, when 22 transmission towers blow over in an extreme weather event, the power goes off.’

And just to illustrate the point, this tweet appeared overnight, with a paid promotion, from a coal astro-turfing group.

‘If anything, renewable energy sources had the potential to create a more secure electricity supply system,’ Adley said.

‘When you have widespread use of distributed generation technologies like PV solar in homes, the network is actually less vulnerable to events like this, because your supply is not purely linear.’



Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Big Coal and “their” governments, are guilty of climate change, which probably resulted in the storm’s catastrophic damage to the transmission lines in the first place.

    Now they’re blaming Renewables !!!

    The 50Hz signal may need to be underground, instead of in the hurricane winds, to ensure interstate switching is optimised during load imbalances.
    Supply smoothing should be mostly via local battery facilities.

    This is a wake-up call to governments to engineer for 100% renewables.

    Renewables sourcing is an entirely separate undertaking and must not be hindered by politicking.

  2. Well come on !
    These are professional politicians (lying scum-bags), they are just doing their jobs !
    Some body has to push the barrow for the privatised ‘energy distribution industry’ and the remnant fossil fuel industry and that’s what these political low-lives are for . These industries are not going to take progress, lying down and they have bought these politicians and they better perform ther little dance .
    Look at Barnaby do those high-kicks , Wow !
    Cheers ,G”)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Race action at the TVSC Mother’s Day meet

A dedicated fleet of 13 boats took to the water for the Tweed Valley Sailing Club’s (TVSC) Winter series on Mother’s Day earlier this month.

Entertainment in the Byron Shire for the week beginning 25 May, 2022

The Jezabels The Jezabels are on a national tour to celebrate the 10th Anniversary of their multi-award winning Gold Album Prisoner. For the first time, the band will be playing their...

Comment: Bridging the flooded divide

In the sodden floodplains the divide among those affected has never been clearer – those who were insured, and those who weren’t, renters and owners, Lismore LGA and everywhere else.

Grants to support arts and culture flood recovery

Nearly 50 arts and cultural organisations, screen practitioners, individual artists and collaborative groups impacted by recent floods will have access to $500,000 in funding.