16.9 C
Byron Shire
May 17, 2021

Police failure to understand strip search laws leads to illegal searches

Latest News

All fired up: former magistrate fumes at news of the world

How does one react to news of environmental vandalism, rampant domestic violence and mutilation of women without anger or distress?

Other News

How to exercise more voting rights in council elections

Being a property owner in NSW isn’t just a financial advantage, it also means you have more rights to vote than non-property owners.

Ageism alive and well

Margaret Boshier, St Ives I have been spending time in the ocean since before I could walk; I grew up...

School Strike for Climate next Friday

Next Friday from 10am Byron Shire students will be demanding political action on the climate emergency in what they and their supporters say is our present, future and reality. 

Locavores out and about

The sun is out, the sky is blue, it’s beautiful, and so is the barbeque… or picnic, at this...

Free mental health workshop for Byron businesses

Business owners in Byron Shire are invited to attend a free 'Healthy Mindset' workshop aimed at providing them with resources and tools to improve mental health and wellbeing, as well as the opportunity to connect with other business owners.

Govt’s new housing plan fails to impress local reps

Local government representatives on the Northern Rivers have expressed doubts over the state government’s new Housing 2041 Strategy.

Some 340 police officers were reportedly at Splendour in the Grass 2018. Photo Pedestrian.TV.

Mia Armitage and Aslan Shand

The misuse of strip search powers by police is being investigated by the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC). Last week evidence was heard specifically in regard to strip searches on children between 10 and 17 years old, at Splendour in the Grass 2018.

According to a statement read to the commission, a sniffer dog came and sat next to a 16 year-old girl, which then led to a strip search. She was told to strip and squat and was not provided with parent, guardian or trusted person as required by law. No drugs were were found in either this strip search of a minor, or 90 per cent of other searches conducted at Splendour. Seven of the searches involved minors.

Sam Lee from the Redfern Legal Centre was at the inquiry and spoke to Echonetdaily saying that, at the hearing, it was clear that the police didn’t have a clear understanding of the laws around strip searches. 

‘It really summed up that police are in a legal vacuum with little to no guidance to know the law of strip searches that should be applied on the ground,’ said Ms Lee.

‘2019 was the first time a procedural manual was supplied that touched on strip searches. It is clear that police don’t understand what “serious and urgent” means, and that they don’t understand what “reasonable grounds” actually means and how they can be met.

‘A sniffer dog by itself is not reasonable grounds for a search. Across the board, sniffer dogs appeared to have been used as the sole grounds for a search.’

Ms Lee went on to say that the police were potentially breaching the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act (LEPR) by directing action – including coughing, squatting and parting of the buttocks. 

Not paying off

According to local Byron Youth Service (BYS) worker, Deb Pearse, who was interviewed on Bay FM’s Community Newsroom last week, the inquiry has revealed that an ‘enormous amount of police resources were not paying off’.

However, Ms Pearce, who also co-ordinates the Mullum Cottage, as well as Byron Street Crews, said her work with youth had taught her drug dealers sometimes persuaded young women to carry illegal drugs into festivals in return for free drugs.

‘That places them at enormous risk on all kinds of levels, so how we go about stopping those kind of activities I’m not sure,’ she told Bay FM listeners.

‘What we’re doing doesn’t seem to be working, so we need a new approach.’

However, having worked closely with local police she had seen first-hand some of the challenges they are met with when dealing with young people.

‘That’s one night a week where, really, I see the worst of humanity,’ she said of her weekly Street Crew works.

‘Police see that all day, every day, year after year and from what I hear, they don’t get a lot of support,’ she said, ‘like everyone else, they’re overworked’. 

Byron Bay Chief Inspector Matt Kehoe had been ‘great over the years’, she said.

But not all the police at the Splendour festival were local, with the LECC hearing that approximately 340 police officers were hired to work at the festival, along with drug-sniffer dogs.

Strip search program failing

Greens MP David Shoebridge has pointed out that the NSW police’s personal search program is fundamentally failing. Fresh data provided by the Police Minister to the Greens in the NSW Parliament, shows that 76 per cent of personal searches following a sniffer dog indication find no drugs and that 66 per cent of all strip searches also turn up empty. He says that police have advised that 99.5 per cent of sniffer dog indicated searches failed to find sufficient drugs to bring either a supply or ‘deemed supply’ charge.  

‘The NSW Police are routinely humiliating people with their aggressive searches and their own data proves that these searches are fundamentally failing to reduce drug supply,’ said Mr Shoebridge.

‘If any other part of the government had a program that failed three-quarters or two-thirds of the time, then it would be scrapped, but somehow the police’s drug dog and strip search programs are in a special class.

‘Strip searches are often highly traumatising and, as the evidence before the ongoing LECC inquiry proves, regularly carried out illegally by police who don’t understand the law.

‘Of the 11,533 strip searches conducted after a police drug dog detection only 2,757 produced any illegal drugs, and the amounts found were overwhelmingly tiny, leading only to cautions or minor possession charges. In just 59 cases were police able to justify a supply or “deemed supply” charge.’

Cultural issue for police

The hearing is supposed to be reporting by the end of the year but according to Ms Lee they are still gathering information on strip searching.

‘Police are not well educated or informed of the laws around the strip search of a child between the ages of 10 and 17,’ said Ms Lee.

‘The hearing left the impression that there was no acknowledgement by the police that these strip searches are upsetting and traumatic and should only happen in exceptional circumstances. 

‘It can’t just be blamed on individual officers, without looking at the overall culture of the police force, the legislation and guidance to police,’ she emphasised. ‘This situation has been impacted by these factors and led to the current failure and wrongful practice that is currently in this system. 

‘The best outcome would be a review of the legislation, and changes that require police to obtain a court order before a strip search of a child. Also, they should gain a court order before being able to request someone to squat, as we see that as a forensic examination.’ 

Ms Lee said that there needs to be a policy change in the police force in regards to strip searches and a reduction in the number of sniffer dogs at festivals in general.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

12 COMMENTS

  1. An utter disgrace. If my daughter (or son) was treated like that, I’d be suing the establishment for every penny.

    A class action would be a useful tool to help stop these mindless drones from behaving this way.

    • No. You won’t not be suing any “establishment” for any penny, but I suspect you know that.
      Try to control yourself.
      Think before you post.

  2. Instead of worrying about some self indulgent brats getting strip searched for life-threatening chemicals, why don’t you addres the affordable housing shortage for the unemployed and pensioners in Byron shire with the same vigour?

  3. It would help if festival organisers put up a prominent sign warning festival goers not to carry drugs and that they may be searched. It should also inform festival goers precisely what their rights are if targeted by police, especially if they’re underage. This would also have the additional affect of reminding ‘forgetful’ or ill-informed police what their targets’ right are.

  4. It has been made quite clear that the greatest threat to these kids is not the the injestion of some basically harmless recreational drugs,….but rather the interactions with ignorant, fascist, illeducated, perverted criminal ruffians who are determined to abuse these children in some pathetic attempt to placate their, Totally justified ,
    sense of inadequacy.
    It is time to get these scum out of the festival environment and send them rehabilitation , then if they can be trained in useful pursuits ,such as community support or traffic control, they could possibly become useful members of our society

    Till then , keep them away from our children, who don’t benefit from being traumatised and abused !

    G”)

  5. Four or five years ago The Echo ran a story (maybe even front page?) advising the best way to invalidate the “probable cause” for a search as indicated by a police dog was to directly approach and pat the dog first. Is this still valid or has that loophole been closed?

  6. but, on the positive side, young people are being conditioned to feel like demoralised and worthless second-rate scum in the local version of Gilead, and surely that’s what it’s all really about

  7. Why have the police officers NOT been trained. And…
    even without training a grown man knows that to ‘strip
    search anyone’ the way it was & is being done is more
    than illegal & can be seen as – you got it – “Rape”. And
    don’t blame the dog.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Business calls for Tweed train tracks to be kept ignored

More than 800 people had signed a petition calling for a new rail trail to be built next to, rather than in place of, the existing disused railway line running through the shire.

Resilient communities training on offer

‘Resilience’ has become a buzzword in Australia over the past few years, as communities across the country struggle to cope with fire, floods, and a pandemic.

Independent councillor fact-checks housing supply in the Byron Shire

Independent Byron Shire Councillor Cate Coorey won approval from fellow councillors last week for a new reporting regime she says will offer clarification on dwellings approved in the shire.

How to exercise more voting rights in council elections

Being a property owner in NSW isn’t just a financial advantage, it also means you have more rights to vote than non-property owners.