Scarrabelottis restaurant plan put on hold

Paul Bibby

Plans for a 40-seat restaurant and carpark at Scarrabelottis Lookout in Coorabell remain on the table, after Byron Council voted to defer the matter at its March 19 planning meeting.

The Scarraboletti’s lookout is the site of a proposed cafe. Image supplied.

The decision was made after a somewhat bizarre voting stalemate, which saw two separate motions to refuse the application voted down by different councillors, even though refusing the application was the majority view.

The proposal is for an ‘intimate high-end restaurant’, which would be open during daytime hours five days a week.

It includes water harvesting, solar power and battery storage and onsite effluent disposal.

However, there have been multiple points of objection from nearby residents and other locals, in particular to using part of the lookout site for car parking.

The lookout was donated to the community by the Scarrabelotti family, long-term residents of the Byron Shire.


Many have objected to the idea of Council effectively gifting this land to the proponent, though it promised to undertake some upgrading works in return.

Independent councillor Basil Cameron told the meeting that building the restaurant would have a significant negative impact on the site.

Special spot 

‘I’ve lived here since the mid ’80s, and ever since then it has been one of the Shire’s really special spots,’ Cr Cameron said.

‘I was taken there to see the view, and many residents have taken their visitors there – friends and family.

‘A key aspect is its low-key nature, and I can’t overestimate the values. 

‘I believe that would be lost if the proposal goes ahead in its current form.’

Cr Cameron put forward a motion refusing permission for the restaurant on multiple grounds, including the car parking issue and the inappropriateness of the location.

However, this motion was opposed by Greens mayor Simon Richardson and fellow Greens councillor Sarah Ndiaye, who argued that some of the refusal grounds were unfair.

Cr Richardson put forward an alternative motion that involved refusing the proposal based on the car parking issue alone.

‘I don’t oppose the restaurant… I don’t think it’s crassly commercialising the hinterland,’ Cr Richardson said.

‘My issue is using a public space for a carpark.’

At the same time, Cr Alan Hunter argued that the DA should be approved in its current form. This resulted in a somewhat bizarre stalemate in which both motions for refusal were voted down because agreement could not be reached on the terms of refusal.

Absent councillors

Contributing to this was the fact that three councillors were absent from the meeting.

Eventually, after discussions behind closed doors over the lunch break, Crs Richardson, Ndiaye and Hunter formed an alliance, agreeing to defer the matter to the next planning meeting

Support the The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

3 responses to “Scarrabelottis restaurant plan put on hold”

  1. Delamay says:

    Please keep this look out for the community and visitors to our local area. We don’t need a high end or any restaurant there let alone the extra cars and people on the roads.

  2. Craig Starr says:

    Leave it alone.Leave it as it is. Hasn,t Byron got enough restaurants already.? Never ending development.

  3. maria says:

    How typical . What’s this ‘High End Cafe’ are you kidding me for more of your egotistical city dwellers to think they have the rights over everyone to spoil this beautiful view from locals old and new and future generations. How typical for greedmongers . This was GIVEN by a generational local family in good faith for the community as a whole and future generations. It doesn’t surprise me . A family can have it for generations this is what the North Coast is about. NURTURING not USING . Just seeing what greed has done to this place in a couple of decades. Will you ever learn. Be responsible Byron Shire ! We DO NOT need another cafe or HIGH END crappy ugly place built where there should be nothing but peace and tranquility. But even you don’t understand that or the value of it. I pray you make the right decision and leave it the way you found it or was kindly given 🙏🌈🐳❤️

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers, and is brought to you by this week's sponsor, Hepatitis Australia, Test Cure Live.