16.1 C
Byron Shire
August 3, 2021

Federal Environment Minister has a duty to avoid causing children harm

Latest News

Be CaféSmart about a cuppa donation for homelessness charities

Most people would be shocked to know how close to homelessness some people in the community are – some people might be very shocked to know how close they themselves are to homelessness. It doesn’t take much.

Other News

Editorial – Let’s all acquiesce!

On July 12, it became mandatory for all businesses and workplaces in NSW to use the Service NSW Check-in tool (QR code).

Pennings and Adani to continue court battle

The Supreme Court has formalised orders agreed out of court by both Adani and Ben Pennings in relation to a decision handed down on 25 June 2021.

Open-air art walk by the river at Murwillumbah completed

The Ages of the Tweed mural that accompanies the open-air riverside art walk has now been completed.

Joyride tears up Chinderah golf course fairway

Police say that three youths were caught joyriding on golf club vehicles at Chinderah late last Friday evening.

Bruns North Arm

Jillian Spring, BillinudgelRegarding your article ‘A positive change to bring back the Bruns’, (Echo, 14 July). Since 2013/14 submissions to Council,...

To kill all Jews? No…

Subhi Awad, Mullumbimby With respect to Wakil and Macklin (Letters, 21 July) the assertion that the Palestinian resistance wants to kill...

Eight high school students have welcomed final orders in their historic court case that found the Federal Environment Minister has a duty to avoid causing children harm when approving a new coal project.

In his initial Sharma v Minister for the Environment Federal Court judgement on May 27, Justice Bromberg found that carbon emissions released from mining and burning fossil fuels will exacerbate climate change causing personal injury and death to Australian children.

Following additional submissions from both parties, as requested by Justice Bromberg, Friday’s ruling entrenches the duty of care into Australian law.

At the hearing, the court made a declaration that the Minister has a duty to take reasonable care to avoid causing personal injury or death to Australian children when exercising her powers to approve the Vickery extension project under national environment law.

Minister ordered to pay students’ legal costs

The Minister was further ordered to pay the students’ legal costs in bringing the claim.

School student Anjali Sharma who is one of the eight, sayd it’s heartbreaking that young people even have to take to the courts to fight for basic protection against the climate crisis, when we’re so obviously facing its impacts right now, with temperatures increasing year upon year and natural disasters taking lives all around the globe.

‘But after too many years of politicians turning a blind eye, today’s historic ruling will make it harder for them to continue to approve large-scale fossil fuel projects that will only fast track the climate crisis.

‘We are delighted that the law of the land now states that the government has a duty to avoid causing harm to young people.

Whitehaven Coal’s Vickery coal mine extension project

At the centre of the legal case is the pending approval of Whitehaven Coal’s Vickery coal mine extension project in NSW. The Court’s ruling in May found that emissions from the expansion would foreseeably expose the children to a risk of injury and death. Any approval would therefore risk breaching the ‘duty of care.’ However, it is now incumbent on Environment Minister Sussan Ley to decide how to proceed with the approval process.

Another of the now famous eight Ava Princi, says that throughout the world, countries such as Canada and Ireland have promised no new coal projects. ‘However, Australia remains a global outlier, with no firm plan other than continuing to encourage new fossil fuel projects.

‘We hope this ruling will be an important step to getting Australia – and the world – on the right path to a safer future for us all.’

Historical outcome

Lawyer for the students, David Barnden, said that the historical outcome provides a safe harbour for the Environment Minister to act sensibly to not only protect the environment, but to ensure that she does not increase the risk of death and injury to children by approving new coal mines.

‘It is now law in Australia that people in power have a responsibility to not harm children. We hope this breaks the political deadlock that is condemning young people to a treacherous future.’

The judgement will be published here and is available now here.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. More power to these kids !
    Of course we ALL have a duty to leave this planet in an habitable condition for the next,and subsequent, generation.
    But it is now set in stone and when the actions of this government exterminates the future for eternity, there will be serious legal legal implications.
    The law IS an ass !
    …… as we have seen in the Royal Commission into child abuse, nothing can be done until the crimes are committed and then….. as the catholic church so volubly protests “these are historic cases” so no-one can be held responsible, least of all George (with friends in high places ) Pell.
    Sussan Ley sleeps comfortably in the knowledge that neither her, nor the rest of this criminal cabal will ever be held responsible for their crimes against life on Earth.
    Cheerio, G”)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Railway and rail trail working together

Chris Abraham, Mullumbimby Creek The rail service between Casino and Murwillumbah was suspended by the NSW Government without any public consultation. A contract was issued...

Fifteen arrested in Brisbane protest

Police say they have arrested fifteen people following protest activity in Brisbane CBD this morning.

South East Queensland lockdown continues for another five days

Queensland Health has issued a statement that says the current lockdown in South East Queensland will continue for another five days as a precaution following new cases in the state.

Pennings and Adani to continue court battle

The Supreme Court has formalised orders agreed out of court by both Adani and Ben Pennings in relation to a decision handed down on 25 June 2021.