27.6 C
Byron Shire
February 5, 2023

Refusal recommended for North Lismore Plateau DA

Latest News

Natural history

While I have not the informed authority to confirm John Bradley’s musings on the birds that seem to be...

Other News

Edjamakashun pledges from NSW election candidates

NSW election candidates make their case for improving poor education standards  With Labor think tank, The McKell Institute, outlining a...

A play that puzzles and delights

The multi-award-winning play is a puzzle of scenes that are slowly put together by the audience to tell the...

Go Thistles!

Lismore Thistles Soccer Club has launched the Thistles Acceleration Program, in the process becoming the city’s only player development academy. 

Witches in the Starcourt

A new year is here! It’s a time for women all over the region to pick up their brooms and set their witchy intentions for 2023. There is no finer time and place to do it than with your Country Witches, comedian Mandy Nolan and singer/songwriter Áine Tyrrell. 

Environment law fails to protect threatened species

A University of Queensland finding says that the federal environmental laws are failing to mitigate against Australia’s extinction crisis.

TELSTRA – The end of the line?

I live in a valley that was ravaged by flood last year. Telegraph poles were swept out of the...

A view of the North Lismore Plateau. Photo Darren Coyne.

The development of 742 residential lots, two neighbourhood business lots (super lots), one residue lot (future residential) and 45 new roads on the North Lismore Plateau (NLP) has been recommended for refusal by the Lismore City Council (LCC) assessment. There is no affordable or social housing component within the development.

The decision on the development application (DA) will be made by the Northern Rivers Planning Panel (NRPP) on 15 December as the proposal has a capital investment value of more than $30 million.

North Lismore Plateau development. Image development assessment report

‘The NLP development proposed by a coalition of land owners is the single biggest DA in Lismore since the subdivision of Goonellabah,’ said Al Oshlack who has been working with Bundjalung man Mickey Ryan on the impact of development on the NLP for over ten years. 

The Council development assessment report highlights the failure of the developer to respond to a number of issues raised at the formal pre-lodgement meetings with Council on 11 December 2018 and 25 March 2021. 

‘Formal minutes of the meeting were provided to the applicant that provided an outline of the technical reports required and matters to be addressed in any future development application to be lodged with Council. Many of the issues initially raised in the pre-lodgement meeting(s) remain outstanding,’ states the assessment. 

The site for development sits in the drinking water catchment the Rous County Council (RCC) ‘recommended that the stormwater treatment regime be designed with consideration the development is located within a water supply catchment and that a neutral or beneficial effect on water quality test be applied to any proposed stormwater management approach’. However, the developers failed to provide the required information and ‘[T]his aspect of the application remains outstanding,’ stated the report.

North Lismore Plateau development. Image development assessment report

Filling in a watercourse

The proposal to completely remove and fill and pipe a second-order watercourse was a key issue for the NSW Natural Resources Access Regulator (NRAR) NRAR. They stated that ‘[T]he removal of a 2nd order watercourse is not consistent with NRAR guidelines and is not supported by NRAR. NRAR has requested that the subdivision layout be amended so as to maintain this 2nd order watercourse and associated riparian zone in accordance with NRAR guidelines’.

While only a small area of the site is affected by the 1 per cent AEP flood event with a level of 12.9m AHD the report concludes that ‘additional commentary considering the February 2022 floods is still required to afford whether matters need to be redressed and or any significant variances arise out of reviewing the context of that flood to those previous.

Mr Oshlack told The Echo that ‘parts of the development on the Dunoon Road floodplain was inundated in the 2022 February/March floods’.

North Lismore Plateau development. Image development assessment report

Aboriginal heritage

The impact on Aboriginal Cultural Heritage was a ‘significant shortfall with the application’. The independent review of documentation provided for the DA was done by Mr Neville Baker of Baker Archaeology who summarised that the ‘material fails to meet Council’s statutory requirements in fulfilling due diligence’. The DA also failed to address the impact on Aboriginal cultural heritage under the local environment plan (LEP) in relation to areas of ‘high ecological, scientific, cultural or aesthetic values’ and to ‘ to conserve archaeological sites.. [and] places of heritage significance’ among others. 

Lack of service supply

For any new development, the supply of water and sewer facilities are essential. However, the site currently has no infrastructure for these in place. The report states that there ‘is insufficient information in regard to the provision of the supply of water and reticulated sewer for Council to be satisfied that the proposed development complies’. 

A development application (DA) for ‘742 Residential Lots, 2 Neighbourhood Business Lots, 14 Public Reserves, and 1 Residual Residential Lot for future development has been proposed for the North Lismore Plateau.

Significant earthworks

To achieve the development significant earthworks are required and issues of the impact on neighbours, the local environment and water catchment were raised. 

‘There is insufficient information provided to determine whether the application will not have a detrimental impact on environmental functions… It its current form, it is likely that the proposed development will have: a detrimental effect on, drainage patterns and soil stability in the locality of the development adverse impacts on waterways, Wilson River drinking water catchment and environmentally sensitive areas,’ it states. 

An Engineering/Traffic/Stormwater Drainage review by council’s development engineer states that ‘given the significance of the outstanding engineering issues that remain to satisfy them, a substantial redesign of the development is required’. 

Fire

The developer has sought to have the proposed perimeter for fire risk managed by ‘individual management of a perimeter fire access track’. However, ‘The NSW RFS was unable to support this notion stating that the individual management of a perimeter fire access tracks will not provide a consistent on-going management but rather an ad-hoc haphazard management regime that will render the perimeter fire trails in-accessible.’

Issues were also raised with the impact on increased traffic on Dunoon Road with council stating that they are ‘not satisfied that the safety, efficiency and ongoing operation of the classified road will not be adversely affected’. 

The Biodiversity Conservation Act (BAM) 2016 requires a Biodiversity Development Assessment Report (BDAR) if a development is ‘likely to significantly affect threatened species’. They said that the BDAR was no longer available therefore ‘the BAM Credit calculations cannot be assessed’ and that ‘Issues pertaining to Part 7.8 of the BC Act remain outstanding.’

North Lismore Aboriginal man Michael Ryan. Photo Darren Coyne.

‘Council raised serious grounds which campaigners have been representing for years such as biodiversity, flooding and cultural heritage not to say the 10,000 plus car movements per day predicted for Dunoon Road,’ explained Mr Oshlack. 

‘Mickey Ryan who steadfastly  opposed over the last 10 years, Council’s support for the development, should be recognised for his courageous  foresight to shoulder, not only protection of his Wiyabal cultural identity but relieving our community of a potential multi-million dollar blackhole debt.’


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

4 COMMENTS

  1. OK – so it is unlikely to ever go ahead as an intensive residential subdivision now, but perhaps possible as a rural-residential one on acreage blocks? It may be simpler as regards planning permission to re-develop good 1(a) agricultural land for new villages on the Alstonville Plateau.
    Sad but true.

  2. Classic Echo hyperbole in terms of the subheading “ filling in a river”. A second order watercourse is not a river , it’s a minor stream . If the author troubled them selves to go and look at an aerial photograph of the site they would see this is a fairly crapped out farm drain.

  3. How much multi million dollar black hole debt?

    A small fraction of the financial black hole created by continually rebuilding in the floodplain

  4. Appalling journalism here from the Echo, yes the current DA is poorly done and should not be approved, but that does not mean that area should not be developed for housing. We need flood free housing in Lismore, we should be dedicating a large area of this north lismore area to relocating houses from north and south lismore.

    The conversation presented in this article is so biased and they have not considered strategically what this kind of presentation of the potential development of the site could be in terms of positive social and economic impacts on flood impacted Lismore.

    Aslan, what do you propose to do with the housing crisis and the flood impacted dwelling in Lismore, please write an article with your solution, I would love to hear it. Should we all live in illegal or temporary dwellings in the hills with no approvals and who knows what wastewater solutions ? seems to be what the Echo supports.

    Mickey Ryan and Al Oshlack have no alternative but to try and stop all development , but what are their solutions for the flood affected houses in Lismore? They offer no hope to residents or the town, but are injecting dark energy into the community, and people follow along thinking its positive and all green and we are saving the indigenous culture which is absolute nonsense.

    This article is just part of the circus, creating fear and not providing a reasoned well written statement. I believe state government should buy this land or work with a developer and then allocate 20% to relocating dwellings from North and South Lismore, also including a large area dedicated to ecological enhancement and this can include parks with indigenous themes and knowledge, that is how we bring the cultures together, not by blocking all development.

    The whole indigenous values thing in this location is completely blown out of proportion, has the echo even read the indigenous heritage assessment done on the site? its comprehensively stating there are minimal indigenous values in that site, its all a cook up, and the people impacted are the poor souls flooded out in north and south lismore.

    sometime I wonder if we really are a first world country…and I wonder how the Echo chooses their journalists, because its a sad state of affairs when our local news paper is digging in against those flood affected houses in Lismore and could be writing positive articles about how we could do things better.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Community advocacy

I am a small business owner of Byron Central Apartments. Tamara Smith MP has recently supported us on two separate occasions advocating effectively with...

Swivel by name, drivel by nature

The lack of authenticity of Byron Councillor, Mark Swivel, does not come as a surprise from this side of the fence. A well-to-do lawyer...

Land values rise

Your cover story on 25 January claims that land valuation rises could herald increases in Council rates. This is potentially misleading. A council’s total...

Go Thistles!

Lismore Thistles Soccer Club has launched the Thistles Acceleration Program, in the process becoming the city’s only player development academy.