15.4 C
Byron Shire
May 28, 2024

New Acland coal mine assessment ‘deeply flawed’

Latest News

MP Saffin clarifies claims around flood recovery

The office of Lismore Labor MP, Janelle Saffin, has made the claim that ‘No government, state or federal, has cut the funding promised for Resilient Homes and Resilient Land programs’ for 2022 flood recovery – see letters page 11.

Other News

The Darling Muffs of May need your help to reach fundraising target

Raising money to support frontline services for women who are homeless or at risk of homelessness has been the driving force behind the Darling Muffs of May’s fundraising this year.

Live animal export

For well over 20 years, the government has been promising to stamp out the horrendous cruelty and abuses fundamental...

Housing: too important to leave to private market

It saddens me every time I get to the back of The Echo and see all the real estate...

Five hours spent at last Thursday’s Byron Council

If you need a fix of local government decision-making, you could dip into the odd five-hour online recording of what occurred at last Thursday’s Council meeting.

Legal system fails to keep kids safe

Fifteen years ago, Karen Bell’s three children – Bon 18 months, Maddie 5, and Jack 7, were found with their dead father Gary Bell in a vehicle at Perico – a collapsed hippy colony on the NSW far south coast.

Eight days in and search parties continue to search bush for Mullum man Gage Wilson

Local Byron Shire man Gage Wilson has now been missing for eight days and his family and friends have been organising search parties to look for him.  

Queensland’s New Acland Mine proposal uses flawed economic modelling designed to overstate potential benefits of the expansion and neglects to mention impacts on air quality and health for surrounding residents, according to the Australia Institute.

The New Acland coal mine is applying to expand its operations in one of Australia’s most productive agricultural regions, the Darling Downs.

The mine has been controversial since it began, in its impact on the agricultural economy, and in clearing out the town of Acland where now only one resident remains.

Local complaints about air quality, noise, and impacts on agriculture are regularly brushed off by the proponents who claim these impacts are offset by the mine’s economic benefits.

However, analysis submitted to the Queensland government on Monday by The Australia Institute has found that these economic claims are overstated.

‘Rather than simply working out the costs and benefits of this project, New Hope Coal try to justify their claims with economic modelling described as “biased” and “abused” by the Australian Bureau of Statistics and the Productivity Commission,’ said economist and submission author Rod Campbell.

‘Claims that this project could inject $17 billion into the Queensland economy are completely untrue. These estimates assume there is infinite labour and arable land in Queensland,’ Mr Campbell said.

‘The Queensland Planning Department’s own guidelines recommend against this sort of assessment,’ he added.

‘The New Acland project is portrayed as the “major employer”, but the assessment points out that while mining employs just 2.5 per cent of the Darling Downs workforce, agriculture employs 10 per cent, five times the Queensland average. Negative impacts on agricultural employment are downplayed, while the mine’s impacts are overstated.

‘Air quality and health issues are not factored into the economic assessment at all.

‘Particulate pollution from coal mining and transport has an impact on human health, its cost is carried through to the economy in increased health costs and reduced worker productivity. There is no consideration of this in the New Acland economic assessment, although the issue has been well documented,’ Mr Campbell said

‘The Queensland government needs to get serious about assessing the merit of coal projects before waving them through.

‘Until the New Acland project can show that the royalties it would generate outweigh the damage that it will cause to agriculture in the Darling Downs, the project should be rejected,’ Mr Campbell said.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. It is not transparent what royalties will flow from this mine expansion. Part of the mine are on old titles where the royalties flow back to the owners, New Hope.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Ballina council to send damning Richmond River report to ministers

A majority of Ballina Shire Councillors has voted to send a damning report on the Richmond River catchment to relevant state and federal ministers.

Who is responsible?

Teenage (stabbing) crime. Here I go again! Why are these kids allowed out of the house before their parents take stock of their kitchen...

Live animal export

For well over 20 years, the government has been promising to stamp out the horrendous cruelty and abuses fundamental to the live export of...

Reconstruction Authority review submissions deadline extended

The closing date for submissions to a statutory review into the NSW Reconstruction Authority Act 2022 has been extended until Monday, 17 June.