20 C
Byron Shire
April 12, 2021

Abandoned CSG waste is cement, says EPA

Latest News

My own pandemic imaginations

Robert Podhajsky, Ocean Shores Imagination is a powerful mechanism; I must admit I get unsettled with my own pandemic imaginations...

Other News

Take a ticket

Council’s Draft Complaint Handling Policy is on exhibition! It’s a document that, if drafted carefully, could provide the public with confidence that Council take complaints seriously and accountability will apply when a complaint is found to be true.

Kyogle unveils writers fest program

Billed as 'a small-town festival with big ideas', Kyogle Writers Festival is shaping up to be a great celebration of writing. 

Policy not ‘housekeeping’

Heather Martin, Mullumbimby According to a report in The Echo (24 March), the planning staff’s proposed amendments to LEP 2014...

New food donation campaign launched

A new campaign is set to make a big difference in helping to reduce waste and provide more food security for our region.

Character test for PM without much

Over Easter I visited a friend who’s spent decades doing her best to protect old growth forests, preserve human connection with nature in the raw and help save our planet from the climate emergency.

The importance of talking about ovaries

Brother and sister clothing designers Camilla Freeman-Topper and Marc Freeman are, were 11 and 13 respectively when their mother died of ovarian cancer.

The overturned tank at Metgasco's decomissioned Corella  well at Dobies Bight with a geiger counter checking radiation levels. Photo Alan Roberts
The overturned tank at Metgasco’s decomissioned Corella well at Dobies Bight with a geiger counter checking radiation levels. Photo Alan Roberts

Chris Dobney

The Environment Protection Authority (EPA) has announced the results into its investigation into the contents of an overturned tank at Metgasco’s former Corella CSG test well at Dobies Bight, concluding the spilled contents was mostly cement.

But the scientist who called the EPA to the site last month disputes the agency’s claims that radiation emitted by the substance is comparable to ‘background’ levels.

On May 25 north coast scientists and environmentalist Alan Roberts reported what he considered to be a serious pollution incident at the site, potentially including radioactivity.

EPA officers inspected the site the following day.

‘The incident related to a tank, containing an unknown substance, being tipped over on a private property,’ the EPA’s chief environmental regulator Mr Gifford said.

Tipped over a year ago

During the investigation the landowner told the EPA that the tank was tipped over 12 months some ago.

But the incident was never reported to the authority until it was notified by Mr Roberts in May.

The property was previously leased by Metgasco for CSG exploration and the owner officially accepted the company’s rehabilitation of the in November 2013 after completion of the plug and abandonment of Metgasco’s Corella E17 well.

Mr Gifford said the EPA collected samples at the site, ‘including upslope and downslope of the tank, from a nearby dam, and from within the tank.’

He said the samples were analysed at the Office of Environment and Heritage’s Environmental Forensics Laboratory for radioactivity, salt and metals.

‘The results indicate that the material in the tank is consistent with cement,’ Mr Gifford said.

‘The testing of the samples did not detect radiation at levels beyond those found naturally occurring in the environment,’ he added.

‘The results for salts and metals indicate that materials from the tank did discharge at the time the tank was tipped over, however, these pose no risk to the environment.’

Mr Gifford said that based on the results of the EPA’s investigation ‘the EPA is satisfied that the cement material, which is contained within the tank, does not pose a risk to human health or the environment.’

‘The EPA has determined that due to elevated pH, potassium and sodium levels detected, the material in the tank should be disposed of at a licensed waste facility. The EPA has requested that the landholder does this by July 31.

Quick response

Mr Roberts said he was impressed with the fast response of the EPA to his complaint.

But he was less enthusiastic about the agency’s conclusions, particularly with regards to the radiation levels.

‘The Geiger counter used by us counted twice as fast in the tank, when compared to other areas around the drill site (our statistics were provided to the EPA), Mr Roberts said.

‘The EPA used rate meters which are too noisy to discriminate against background nuclear radiation and hence (possibly) dismissed the radiation as ‘background’. If you are familiar with working with the random nature of nuclear radiation, you know that you need to count – and the longer you count the more accurate your data,’ he added.

Metgasco’s responsibility?

‘Now we have the entirely unsatisfactory situation whereby Metgasco has possibly evaded their responsibility under the REF to remove waste from, and not to bury any waste on the drill site.

‘The EPA claims that landowner, Mark McCaughey has taken over the responsibility to clean up the site. Someone has drained most of the tank’s contents onto the drill site and into the dam and now the landowner is being told (by the EPA and for reasons unknown) that the contents of the tank aren’t radioactive and can simply be treated in the same way that one would consider handling cement,’ Mr Roberts said.

‘Anyone working near the waste tank could be unwittingly exposed to up to 2.6 times the normal rate of DNA damage and should be forewarned.

‘We are not at all comfortable that the material in the tank is being passed off as “cement-like” and find this an inadequate and simplified analysis,’ he said.

‘Only a fraction of the tank’s contents have formed the cement hydrate and even that has black material in it which is 2.1 times background nuclear radiation,’ he added.

‘There is also something in the tank that corrodes stainless steel. We’re thankful that the EPA is working to ensure the material is disposed of in a licensed waste facility.

‘Clearly the system that supposedly protects the environment from mining waste is a failure. We are thankful that the EPA acted promptly, lessening the risk of this messy situation worsening.

‘This breach was only discovered by chance, which raises the BIG question: ” how many more breaches are lurking on the decaying Northern Rivers CSG trail?” pondered Alan.,’ Mr Roberts said

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Twice background radiation is not a cause for alarm. Many heavily populated areas in the world have background radiation levels over twice the 1.5 – 2.0 mSv/yr in Australia. Cornwall in the UK has 7.8 mSv/yr. A beach in Brazil has background radiation levels over 100 mSv/yr with no statistical increase in cancers.

  2. Come on give the EPA a fair go !
    These people have had a hectic time lately, facilitating illegal logging, covering up for gross incompetence in RTA plans to destroy the coastal plain from
    Woolgoolga to Maclean, destroying the habitat of most of what,s left of the Koala population on the North Coast ,and on top of that it has to justify the contamination wrought by CSG. Under the circumstances they’ve done well to survive at all, with Baird and Tony praying for any excuse to send them the way of non sectarian, free education.

  3. The guy should be charged with trespass. He calls himself a scientist? Claims radioactive material and then does not accept the expert findings of the EPA. You guys are just as bad for publishing this nonsense.
    What tossers.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Inspector condemns prisoner health services

In the forward to the Inspector of Custodial Services Report published last month, Fiona Rafter Inspector of Custodial Services says that the provision of health services to inmates in New South Wales custodial facilities is a complex and challenging responsibility.

The importance of talking about ovaries

Brother and sister clothing designers Camilla Freeman-Topper and Marc Freeman are, were 11 and 13 respectively when their mother died of ovarian cancer.

Dead rats in the Byron bubble?

Poppa Veet Mayo, Main Arm Am I the only one who can smell a dead rat in this bubble called the Byron Shire? Hear it happened...

Linen SHIFT project urgently needs new home

With a vision to disrupt the cycle of women’s homelessness, the Linen SHIFT project was born to provide unique individual support and education for at-risk women in a safe residential environment, but today they they have been forced to close.