19.5 C
Byron Shire
August 2, 2021

Focus on illicit drugs puts Australia’s drinking problem on ice

Latest News

SE Queensland’s lockdown and local schools

The South East Queensland three day lockdown, from 4pm Saturday 31 July to 4pm  Tuesday 3 August 2021 will...

Other News

Break and Enter at Cinemas in Byron Bay

Police say that shortly after 4.20am, yesterday, Sunday August 1 a youth forced open one of the steel gates of the Palace Cinemas Byron Bay.

Why the rush?

Jason Beaumont, Suffolk Park I wanted to respond the brain aneurysm-causing letter by one Sara Rath (21 July). The letter writer...


Andrew Macklin, Mullumbimby Creek Gareth Smith (July 14), I can see you like the selective use of historical facts and statistics...

Cartoon of the week – 28 July, 2021

We love to receive letters, but not every letter will be published; the publication of letters is at the discretion of the online and print letters editors.

Vehicle access to Unicorn Falls to close

President of the recently formed Byron Hikers Club says a ‘controversy is brewing’ around National Parks’ recently announced plans to close vehicle access to Unicorn Falls, located on South Chowan Road behind Upper Main Arm.

A day of ‘thank you’

Alison Drover, Broken Head How about a day of ‘thank you’ to our health workers and ‘sorry’ from our prime minister...

We do need to address the harms of illicit drugs, but, in doing so, we mustn’t overlook the greater social impact of excessive alcohol consumption.
We do need to address the harms of illicit drugs, but, in doing so, we mustn’t overlook the greater social impact of excessive alcohol consumption.


Recent discussions of Australia’s ‘ice epidemic’ have culminated in a A$9 million government-funded media campaign to raise community awareness of the drug’s harms, particularly in rural areas.

We do need to address the harms of illicit drugs, but, in doing so, we mustn’t overlook the greater social impact of excessive alcohol consumption.

A number of commentators have cautioned about the possible negative effects of government fear-mongering on parents, families and communities.

Experts have also highlighted the substantial evidence that drug education campaigns are, at best, ineffective and, at worst, encourage experimentation.

But another – largely unremarked on – negative outcome of the strong focus on ice is that it takes the spotlight away from the harms of excessive alcohol use, which is actually a bigger problem in Australia.

A reported 2.1 per cent of Australians have used some form of methamphetamine in the last 12 months while 15.6 per cent of people aged 12 or older have consumed 11 or more standard drinks on a single drinking occasion in the same period.

In what appears to have become a battle between those concerned about the different substances, we are increasingly seeing a debate polarised around which drug is worse, illustrated well by this article in the Herald Sun, arguing that ice is a bigger problem than alcohol:

Yes, there are those who are addicted to alcohol and the consequences of that addiction can ruin lives. But when was the last time an alcoholic shot his girlfriend in the head in a fit of rage?

The thing is, drunk people do kill their spouses, and they appear to do so in droves.

Of the 1,565 solved homicides in Australia between 2000 and 2006, 729 (47 per cent) were classified as alcohol-related.

Both people had consumed alcohol in 60 per cent of these cases, only the offender in 21 per cent, and only the victim in 19 per cent.

Of the homicides involving an intimate partner relationship, between 2000 and 2006, 44 per cent were related to alcohol.

In 2011 alone, there were 29,684 police-reported incidents of alcohol-related domestic violence in the four states and territories where this data is available (NSW, Victoria, WA and NT). When you add to that the other states, and the many cases of domestic violence that go unreported, the scale of the problem becomes enormous.

People who consume the same news have similar perceptions of risk even if they live in different areas.

What’s more, data from the 2005 Personal Safety Survey suggests that alcohol contributes to 50.3 per cent of all partner violence, and 73 per cent of physical partner assaults.

So why do we think ice kills and alcohol doesn’t?

The wrong shortcut

The answer lies in a mental shortcut known as the availability heuristic, which helps us make decisions. It helps determine the likelihood of an event by how easily examples of that event come to mind.

The process works really well when we’re deciding what to wear in the morning (how many people can I remember seeing in the office this week in thongs?) but can lead to important biases in the way we make decisions.

Studies show media coverage has a significant impact on what we perceive as risky.

Consider this example: a survey of people living in France and Burkina Faso conducted 20 years ago found they shared similar perceptions of the risks in their community – despite their fundamentally different geography, climates, environments and economies.

The common factor was that both groups read magazines and newspapers originating in France.

The media have an enormous impact on how ‘available’ a cause of death is in our minds, and may create a false sense of reality.

An analysis of the proportion of news coverage of different causes of death in the United States, for instance, found tobacco-related deaths were under-represented (less than a quarter of the expected coverage) but illicit drug use deaths were over-represented (more than 17 times the expected coverage).

This positioning of illicit drugs – in this instance, ice – as a great and immediate risk to young people confuses parents and leads to the oft-heard lament ‘at least they are only drinking’.

The media have a role to play in creating – and correcting – the effects on communities, including politicians, of the availability heuristic.

Perhaps we need to remind people that the reason ice-related homicides are on the front page of the newspaper is because they are rare; the reason alcohol-related homicides aren’t is because there are too many of them to report.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Prohibition has not ,will not and and never could stop people pursuing what ever makes them feel good !
    The obvious answer to this dilemma it to make all drugs freely available, but to educate all to the effects ,positive and negative and short and long term . I don’t mean the historic stance of scaremongering, as these lies become obvious and invite extreme experimentation as the authorities have lost all credibility.
    The truth of foetal alcohol syndrome has yet to sink into the public awareness, one drink during pregnancy can debilitate a child for life, and the effect applies to fathers as well as the mother.

  2. I’ve noticed that the anti-alcohol lobby groups are even trying to argue unsuccessfully that ice is not as damaging as alcohol, neither in driver impairment, anti-social activities or mental health. That’s clearly untrue as most cops and medical people will attest.

    Must be a bugger when you see your own carefully nurtured area of influence being whittled away by the new guys on the block.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The great Ballina Library book sale

This Friday and Saturday will see book lovers dreams materialise in Ballina when the library holds their Library Collection Overhaul and Book Sale.

Break and Enter at Cinemas in Byron Bay

Police say that shortly after 4.20am, yesterday, Sunday August 1 a youth forced open one of the steel gates of the Palace Cinemas Byron Bay.


Sarah Smith, Byron Shire Finally, our premier is speaking a language that the business community of Sydney should comprehend – a $10,000 fine for forcing their...

Read all about it…

Rick Molloy, Federal If recent letters in The Echo have left you confused about the Israel/Palestine conflict, then help is at hand. Our local library has...