24.2 C
Byron Shire
April 21, 2021

Thus Spake Mungo: Above suspicion

Latest News

Local youth among those hardest hit by housing affordability crisis

A 20 per cent spike in rents is driving an increase in youth homelessness across the North Coast, the organisers of a national campaign to end homelessness say.

Other News

Rocky Creek Field Day coming in July

As part of the Rural Landholder Initiative, rural landholders in the Rocky Creek area are invited to an Off-stream Watering and Riparian Habitat Field Day.

Eungella: Alleged domestic-related stabbing suspect charged with attempted murder

Police say a man will face court today charged with attempted murder following an alleged domestic-related stabbing earlier this year.

Coalition ‘hellbent’

Mat Morris, Bangalow The NSW coalition seems to be hellbent on outdoing their federal counterparts when it comes to the denigration...

Head-on crash car traveling in wrong direction

Police say that two men are in hospital after an accident on the M1 overnight, when emergency services responded to reports of a crash involving two cars near Clothiers Creek

Interview with Toni Childs

Internationally celebrated musician, Emmy winner and three times Grammy nominee Toni Childs is bringing her show to The Brunswick Picture House. With two acts, Childs is promising a special two hour performance as she celebrates her vast catalogue of music, which also saw her celebrate the 30th anniversary of her critically acclaimed album Union in 2019.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Byron’s Back

‘Byron’s dead’. That’s the statement that I often hear. Or ‘I never go there anymore it’s lost’ or ‘Byron died years ago’. It always makes me feel a bit sad and defensive. I have such a love for this place, although I curse it when I get stuck in snaking traffic at 8am on a weekday morning or I can’t find a park near where I am going.

By Mungo MacCallum

Caesar’s wife must be above suspicion.

The proverb has a long and venerable lineage: in 62 BC Julius Caesar divorced his second wife Pompeia. There was no trial, no hearing, not even a formal charge – only innuendo and scuttlebutt.

Pompeia was, or might have been, the target of attention from an ardent young admirer, and that was all. But it was enough: Caesar’s wife, declared the Roman ruler, must be above suspicion. So the hapless Pompeia had to go.

In the case of the Royal Commissioner Dyson Heydon, the evidence is rather more substantial: there is a paper trail. A leaflet was promulgated with the Liberal Party logo inviting the faithful for a shindig in honour of another Liberal Party icon, Sir Garfield Barwick (the former Chief Justice and covert adviser in the dismissal of Gough Whitlam) and the featured speaker was to be Dyson Heydon.

Apparently the idea had been mooted some two years ago; he accepted the invitation as a Liberal Party event in 2014, but apparently overlooked the party connection when it was confirmed twice this year. He, or his associate. only declined the forthcoming celebration last week.

We were told that the refusal had been sent before any media queries had emerged, but the Fairfax press had published the text of the leaflet the previous night, so Heydon’s office had presumably been alerted. And in the event the refusal was not a blanket rejection, but a rain check; it only applied to the duration of the Royal Commission. When it came to addressing official Liberal Party functions, Heydon wanted to keep his options open.

So it seems a clear breach of the Caesar’s wife principle, and also of the words of both Barwick and Heydon himself: judges must not only be impartial, but they must be seen to be impartial.

And if that applies to members of the judicial arm of government, how much more must it apply to the executive arm, in which Heydon has been personally selected to preside over a highly charged, very political, inquiry into the trade union movement that has included two living Labor leaders? Heydon has added to the controversy by criticising the credibility of the current one – gratuitously and provocatively, say his opponents.

From the beginning Bill Shorten and his colleagues branded it a witch hunt, a political stitch-up; they now claim to have uncovered the smoking gun. The government has no choice but to support their own appointee, insisting that he had always been fair, impartial and honourable, which may well be the case, but is not the point. He has been tainted, if that is the right term, with direct involvement with the organisation of the party that gave him his brief.

Pedalling furiously, his defenders argue about whether the dinner is or is not a fundraiser: some admit it is, others insist it is not, Tony Abbott says it is both. Well, the admission fee is certainly not exorbitant by the standards of major events, but donations are solicited in the handout and are payable to the NSW campaign fund. If it isn’t an official fundraiser, it will do until one comes along.

There were also protestations that it was really a public function, so it didn’t really count. But the gathering was by invitation, the media was excluded and it’s a fair bet that if someone like Zaky Mallah arrived at the door he would be turned away. The occasion was to be by the Liberal Party, for the Liberal Party and of the Liberal Party, and that meant that Dyson Heydon must be a sympathiser, if not an active supporter.

But again, the nit-picking is not the point. Heydon’s standing was compromised, and it was not the first time – some years ago he spoke at a meeting convened by the right wing magazine Quadrant, with an address which was designated as a job application for John Howard. His judicial expertise is not in question, but his judgement – even his common sense – most definitely is, and the damage is considerable.

The stuff up is, for once, not entirely Tony Abbott’s fault; Heydon was certainly his Prime Minister’s captain’s pick to launch the crusade against the unions, but he was hardly to know that his royal commissioner would be so rash. He cannot and will not sack Heydon, and it is most unlikely that Heydon will step down even if the unions make a formal submission for him to do so later this week. So this means that the rest of the proceedings, up till and into the final findings and their dissection, will lack a measure of credibility unacceptable in the context of a forthcoming election campaign.

Abbott was relying on his commission as another weapon to belt Bill Shorten and all his works; now he has lost that battle before it has properly started. And so the arsenal is looking a bit bare; the climate change argument is at least contestable, gay marriage has been a fiasco, tax reform is on hold, cutting expenditure is a no show. National security will presumably be ramped up yet further, but even that must have its limits.

And most importantly, the trashing of the previous Labor regime, although still an article of faith for Abbott’s zealots, is ringing increasingly hollow: the constant gaffes, divisions and general incompetence of the current administration has made a mockery of the promise of good government for grown ups, open for business and getting on with pursuing the unexceptionable aims of spruiking for jobs and growth.

And, as always, the buck stops at the top – stops dead, very nearly. Time is running out if there is to be a serious change – either from Abbott finally reviving his serially impaired leadership, or relinquishing it, willingly or not. The impasse is awkward, uncomfortable, and definitely unpalatable for the party, and particularly the vulnerable backbenchers; but there are signs that they are reluctantly moving to confront it.

Caesar’s wife is one principle, and that has been declared inoperable… Now the great leader’s own supremacy, his very survival, is once more under scrutiny. The Ides of March may have come and gone, but the ravens are still croaking.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. The Proverb “Caesar’s wife must be above suspicion.” has a long and venerable lineage when we go fishing back in the channels for dirt. In 62 BC Julius Caesar divorced his second wife Pompeia with no trial, no hearing, not even a formal charge – only innuendo and scuttlebutt. Such was the life of the aristocracy of those times of loaves and little fishes.

  2. Never has a better spin has been put on an important issue, Dr. Mungo. Now, what is the real issue here?…hmmm, oh, that’s right, graft and corruption within the Labor Party and unions. Maybe a bit about that in your next column, Mungo? Not holding my breath there.

  3. And Mungo. Are you going to comment on the revelations of union corruption, the charging of a number of union officials? Heydon must be doing what royal commissioners do. Unearthing wrong doings without fear or favour.
    I will bet you $10 the barristers for Labor and ACTU will not push for Heydons removal or high court challenges. Labor want this to go away ( which ain’t going to happen) and a high court challenge and/or a new commissioner will ensure this investigation into Union corruption will very much stay on the boil until the next election…….
    What a gift the unions are to TA. Especially the CFMEU.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Fresh faces for Council elections

A very distinct, black flat-cap has just been thrown into the ring for the upcoming Byron Council elections, pegged for September 4.

Follow the buck$

JK Mckenna, Burringbar Give Fast Buck$ his own column in the paper. Let him speak. Let him be heard. Let’s also see some accountability from councils...

A bouquet for Lilac House

L Jenkins, Byron Bay Nicole Habrecht should receive free paint and brushes and a pat on the back from Council for maintaining her house in a...

Bruns boarding house showdown Thursday

The stage is set for a crucial debate over the Brunswick Heads ‘Corso’ development in Byron Council this week, with staff recommending that the developer’s revised plans be approved.