15.5 C
Byron Shire
June 27, 2022

IPART not fit, say Greens

Latest News

Honours shared in premiership football derby

Byron Bay FC were fourth placed on the Football Far North Coast premiership ladder after a 3-3 draw playing away against Mullumbimby Brunswick Valley FC in round seven of the competition.

Other News

Drains, floods, creeks

I was thankful for Duncan Dey’s input at the last Council meeting where two representatives spoke in public access...

Committee to examine teacher shortages

The NSW Upper House’s Education Committee say they have commenced an inquiry into teacher shortages in NSW.

People with peace in their hearts?

In reference to the full page advertisement (it clearly states that it is an advertisement, and really is nothing...

Govt to rebuild Northern Rivers from July 1

The Northern Rivers Reconstruction Corporation (NRRC) will come into existence from July 1. So what is it, and how will it assist flood-affected residents across the region?

Hydro cannabis bust in Tweed

Police have confiscated equipment they say was being used for a hydroponic cannabis station set up in a Tweed Heads garage.

New laws to tackle crime profits and encryption

The premier has announced new police powers and ‘tougher penalties’ for money laundering and unexplained wealth in NSW.

Greens MP David Shoebridge.
Greens MP David Shoebridge.

With the state government set to make decisions about the future of local government based on decisions reached by the Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal, the Greens say IPART itself is not fit to make the call.

Last week local councils including Kyogle, Clarence Valley and Tweed were declared to have failed the government’s test, as applied by IPART, and told to come up with alternative plans within the month to stave off possible amalgamation.

But Greens local government spokesperson David Shoebridge says the body itself had been saddled with a task it lacked the capacity to perform.

‘IPART is really a financial accounting organisation. Its skillset is to work out the cost of electricity or… cold water. [It doesn’t] have any at all in assessing the fitness of democratic organisations like councils,’ he told ABC radio this morning.

And he has called on the body to show how it went about its assessment.

Mr Shoebridge earlier told media the government had ‘undertaken a bloody-minded political campaign against local democracy and local communities.’

‘IPART’s report found that almost every submission they received from communities and resident groups supported their local council and opposed amalgamations. This democratic feedback was ignored by IPART,’ he said in a media release

‘The entire IPART assessment process was designed as little more than a rubber stamp for the government’s ‘bigger is better’ ideological agenda to bully local councils into amalgamations.

‘IPART did not look at the democratic responsibility of councils and failed undertake any proper engagement with the residents of communities impacted by proposed amalgamations.

‘The fact that the government took less than two business days to ‘consider’ IPART’s report shows just how perfunctory the entire assessment process was.

‘IPART was put in a strait-jacket that forced them to fail almost every financially sustainable council because they refused to merge. They refused to merge because they listened to their residents.

‘Councils didn’t fail IPART’s ridiculous test because of financial reasons, they failed to meet government’s ill-defined and discretionary test of ‘scale and capacity.’

‘With more than 50 regional and rural councils facing the chopping block, there are many smaller towns and communities across the State who will be rightly concerned at the loss of essential and steady local council jobs.

‘In much of regional and rural NSW, keeping council jobs can mean all the difference between keeping teachers, banks and other essential services in local communities.

Mr Shoebridge said the government would have a difficult time getting its bill through the upper house.

The premier can abuse and bully councils all he likes but at the end of the day he doesn’t have the numbers to forced unpopular amalgamations through the NSW Parliament.

‘The Greens will continue to stand with local councils in their campaign to strengthen local democracy and keep local government genuinely local,’ Mr Shoebridge said.

*An earlier version of this story said Richmond Valley was not found Fit for the Future. That comment was incorrect and has been removed.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. No surprises here, given the power grabs already pulled off by the State Government with regard to development proposals & local planning (and much else – the list of interference in local issues & the concurrent off-loading of costly responsibilities onto the Local Government sector is quite appalling). Just another example of city-centric/ urban based planning values (with a view to an easy income stream) and the concentration of power into the hands of a disinterested few. I am frequently gob-smacked by the ridiculous directives from Sydney – ranging from 100km speed zones on winding single lane roads connecting ridge to valley, to environmental assessments that seem to reflect computer modelling (with most relevant variables excluded or wildly inaccurate) not actual landscape. CSG mining looms large as an area where the ease of giving the green light to industrial landscapes being imposed upon prime agricultural land & tourism destinations is breath-taking in it’s nonchalance (city chappie goes “I didn’t know – I couldn’t see it” – not how they respond when a city suburb rises up in anger). There has been a definite move toward disenfranchising voters. Larger Local Government Areas means the numbers can be more easily rigged (what does it matter that they are placing eggs & potatoes in the same basket? – all care no responsibility for breakages it seems). Out bush & out of mind. Thank heavens for the Upper House & the Greens.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

You may have missed… mangroves’ carbon storage potential, smart implants, and twitter misinformation

Mangrove forests are massive carbon sinks, capable of storing over 1,000 tonnes of carbon per hectare.

Local triathletes claim another title

The Byron Bay Breakers Triathlon Club has won the North Coast Interclub series for the second time after finishing on top of the table ahead of the Clarence Valley Stingrays and Hat Head Hammerheads.

Lismore City Council votes against land-swaps and buybacks

The Lismore City Council has voted against asking the federal government and NSW Northern Rivers Reconstruction Commission [NRRC] for prioritised land buybacks and swaps after devastating floods earlier this year.

Casino teenager charged with murder

An 18-year-old Casino man is to face Lismore Local Court today charged with murder.