27.1 C
Byron Shire
March 4, 2024

Regional Forest Agreements consultation a ‘sham’

Latest News

Government convenes Coastal Water Safety Roundtable today

NSW Minister for Emergency Services Jihad Dib will lead an expert roundtable looking at how more lives can be saved on NSW beaches after more than a dozen coastal drownings this summer.

Other News

Damning 2022 flood housing audit released for Northern NSW

A performance audit of how effectively, or not, the NSW government provided emergency accommodation and temporary housing in response to the 2022 floods has been released by the NSW Audit Office. 

Floodplain fury

With the two-year flood anniversary being recognised this week, Council appears to be pushing on with its plans to seek approval from the state government for floodplain development in Mullumbimby. 

Investment fraud charges – Gold Coast

Detectives from the Financial and Cyber Crime Group have arrested and charged five people in relation to an alleged ‘boiler room’ investment fraud operating on the Gold Coast.

Smith MP urges planning minister to call in Wallum

Yesterday the media gathered at the proposed Wallum development at Brunswick Heads as Tamara Smith, Member for Ballina, held a conference to urge the NSW planning minister to refer the development the federal environment minister.

Defacing artworks

Mullumbimby is a colourful place. We love all the events, workshops, activities and markets – it all adds to...

Mullumbimby men’s team well placed to defend local water polo championship

The Mullumbimby men’s water polo team sit on top of the Far North Coast competition table after beating their major rivals, the Alstonville Rattle Snakes 8–4, earlier this week.

Opponents of Regional Forest Agreements have been protesting outside ‘sham’ consultation sessions. Photo NCEC

The NSW and Federal governments are coming under increasing pressure to scrap Regional Forest Agreements from the Greens and environmental groups which say the current review process is a sham.

North Coast Environment Centre coordinator Susie Russell said both governments were asking people to ‘drop-in’ and comment on whether the RFAs should be extended for another 20 years.

‘Our answer is a resounding no,’ Ms Russell said.

‘Both Governments have failed to complete the reviews that were required to occur every 5 years. They have belatedly cobbled together a ‘review’, also out on public exhibition, but they aren’t waiting for the results, which is typical.

‘The main function of the RFA is to exempt logging from Commonwealth Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation law. This has been a disaster around the country. Logging is like a law unto itself, with minimal State Government oversight and community groups banned from taking legal actions when breaches of the law are identified.

‘We know both Governments are promoting intensification of logging, the introduction of clearfelling across most of the Mid North Coast, and weakening environmental protections for threatened species and headwater streams. They are also touting wood-fired power stations as ‘renewable’ energy. Locations identified for such smokestacks are Bulahdelah, Kempsey and Grafton..

‘At a time when Australia and the world are looking down the barrel of a climate change cannon, we should be building resilience into our natural ecosystems, not carving them up and burning them. We should be protecting our catchments to maximise water yield, not trashing them. We should be protecting and repairing the habitat of threatened species, to give them a fighting chance, not destroying it. We should be investing in genuine renewable energy technologies, not propping up unsustainable and uneconomic industries.

‘If we are to have a future, we will need to stop repeating the errors of the past. There really is no time to lose, global temperatures are rising. Unfortunately political stupidity seems to be rising as well.’

RFAs a ‘failure

Meanwhile, NSW Greens MP Dawn Walker has branded the Regional Forest Agreements (RFAs) a ‘failure’ and called for them to be scrapped as part of the current review process.

‘The RFAs have been a manifest failure by allowing over-logging in our precious forests, polluting waterways and destroying vital habitat for threatened species,’ Ms Walker said.

‘The RFAs were supposed to end the ‘forest wars’ between communities, Governments and loggers when they were signed approximately 20 years ago, but they have resulted in intensified logging and an alarming crash in koala populations by 50 per cent in parts of NSW.

‘Part of the problem is that the current RFAs only value of forests in a very narrow way and there have been continued breaches of regulations that were supposed to protect native species, often with zero consequence for loggers. Many of these breaches have only been documented and uncovered because of the work of conservationists.

‘It is time to move away from this outdated model of forest management and recognise our forests as more than a timber resource to log.

‘We are concerned that the Government intends to automatically renew the RFAs for a further 20 years without the rigorous studies required to underpin such an extension, and are calling for the community to make submissions against the RFAs via the submission template on my website (www.dawnwalker.org.au/regional_forest_agreements).

‘Put simply, the RFAs are a failed model of forest management and the Greens want them scrapped so we can move our wood products industries to sustainably managed plantation sources.

Opponents of the RFAs have held protests at Lismore and Coffs Harbour this week and this morning will be gathering outside the consultation session at Buladelah.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. It’s incredible that the EPA have recently released the 10 and 15 year compulsory reviews due in 2009 and 2014 for comment and failed to even mention over 4,000 instances of breaches of environment and threatened species legislation by Forests NSW and the 3 times they successfully sued them in the Land and Environment Court. I had to compile these breaches from the EPA annual Implementation Reports (https://www.epa.nsw.gov.au/your-environment/native-forestry/integrated-forestry-operations-approvals/annual-reports).
    Surely any assessment of the success or failure of the RFAs must include details of these endemic failures to follow the law. 4,000 breaches from 187 audits of between 5,000 and 6,000 native forest operations give some indication of the probable level of actual non-compliance out there in our forests. With insignificant penalties for these breaches, there has been no reduction in their occurrences over the 10 years of the review and they certainly continue to this day.
    This 384 page, 152,000 word report is a mere propaganda exercise designed to pull the wool over the public’s eyes. It’s absolute garbage that can’t be used to justify rolling over the RFAs.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

People becoming severely ill at home due to heat

People experiencing financial and social disadvantage are struggling to keep their homes cool in summer and becoming seriously unwell from the heat, new ACOSS research has found.

Firefighters called to Bruns Bakery yesterday

Fire and Rescue NSW say they attended commercial premises in Fingal Street in Brunswick Heads after reports of an electrical fire at 4pm yesterday afternoon.

Rifle Range Road upgrade about to start

It’s a project that has endured many delays, but Byron Shire Council says the upgrade of Rifle Range Road at Bangalow is finally due to start in early April.

Invasive Species Council gives evidence to federal fire ant inquiry

A Senate Committee inquiry will hear evidence today that changes are needed in Australia’s fire ant response – including the creation of an independent eradication authority.