14.3 C
Byron Shire
June 22, 2021

Shark nets continue to kill harmless marine life

Latest News

Appeal to locate elderly missing woman – Ballina

Police are appealing for public assistance to locate an elderly woman missing on the state's North Coast area.

Other News

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Climate Change, Coal and the Flushing Toilet

Sometimes I wonder why people seem to have stopped caring about climate change. Is it because it’s too big? Is it because we have a Prime Minister who is in a dirty love triangle with coal and gas? Or is it the convenience of the flushing toilet?

Locals to fight back with a series about the REAL Byron Bay

News that Netflix was planning to film a vacuous docudrama in Byron Bay brought a collective snort of derision across the Shire.

Port blame game

Dee Taminau, Ballina Early May 2021, Scott Morrison stated that Labor sold the Port of Darwin to China, giving China a...

‘Influencers’ – just another advertising platform…

The question being asked by many consumers is 'are influencers genuinely promoting products that they like and believe in, or is it just more advertising?

Frida’s Field winter menu

  If you’re thinking of a long lunch on Friday, Saturday or Sunday, out in the country with a beautiful...

Man missing from Cudgen

Police are appealing for public assistance to locate a man missing from the Far North Coast.

One of two rays found caught in shark nets off Ballina beaches. Photo Sea Shepherd

Only one of 56 animals caught in shark nets along the north coast was a target shark species, according to new data.

Humane Society International marine scientist Jessica Morris said the data proved the nets do not work and continue to kill harmless and threatened marine life.

‘Figures from January and February show out of 56 caught animals 15 were killed, including dolphins, rays, and hammerhead sharks – which are harmless to humans. Only one of the animals captured was a target shark species,’ Ms Morris said.

Last season’s shark net trial on the North Coast caught 9 target sharks making up only 3 per cent of the total catch, with the remaining 97 per cent comprising harmless marine animals, including a critically endangered grey nurse shark, four dolphins and 11 threatened marine turtles.

The NSW North Coast net exemption allows shark net trials to continue until 31 October 2019, despite the shocking marine animal death statistics and negative community feedback after the first trial concluded last year.

‘How many more months of damning data will it take for government to finally realise this experiment is an utter failure, and shut it down?’

‘Non-lethal alternatives to nets are available and we cannot afford to keep killing harmless and protected species for the next 18 months or more.’.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

9 COMMENTS

  1. Absolutely disgusting that nets are still in use. While staying at Kirra last year I watched a whales swim close to the waves so obviously if they can get in, so can sharks. Humans need to get over themselves and leave nature to do it’s thing.

  2. Absolutely appalled by the lack of action by the local governments to stop this despite community outcry. We feel completely voiceless when it comes to these issues that matter. Embarrassed to call Ballina home

    • This is the human centered view. We are the most important species. All other species may be able to fit in with our needs but they are just not really on the agenda. The fact that our numbers are now in plague proportions and we continue to make a massive environment footprint, and we have caused mass extinctions is probably rarely thought about. The notion that all things are related is not acknowledged – probably.

    • Jon my man, humans don’t need to be in the ocean, we can swim in a pool. Sharks on the other hand actually live in the ocean, they have no where else to go. By your logic every animal species is expendable because humans are MORE important. To swim in the ocean is a privilege and not a right. Humans enter the ocean at own risk. Nets are a waste of time and effort. Marine creatures, including sharks, can swim around and under nets. More sharks snagged on the ‘beachside’ of nets than on the ‘open ocean side’ of nets. That alone tells you the failure that nets are.

  3. Do the sums, that is less than half an animal dying , per net, per week over 2 months. Recreational fishing will kill more than that. The DPI are doing an amazing job of continuing to reduce the by-catch and keep people safe. Prior to the meshing program, negative shark encounters were the norm along this stretch of coast> and since, people have seen sharks, but I have not heard of one person being chased, stalked, bumped, bitten or killed, all of this which happening with astonishing regularity prior to the meshing program.
    Jessica Morris says they don’t protect people, but the statistics tell otherwise. Since meshing was introduced in 1936, there has been a single recorded fatality at a beach with meshing installed. That is a very big coincidence.

  4. Jon Whoeveryouare?
    A bit worrying Jon that you seem to think that the killing of harmless humans by sharks is more important than a few species of fish! Mmm! Interesting perspective indeed!

  5. This is a tired old argument when I would suggest most readers and commenters here are most likely not Vegan! In other words, if you eat fish you are responsible for 5 x that amount in Bi Kill- 60 to 70 million Sharks are killed each year by the Fisheries free license supported by you guys eating your fish and chips- Jumping up and down in a small-minded parochial manner -arguing against against the insanity of collateral damage is a good thing as long as you are Vegan otherwise that would make you a myopic hypocrite!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Climate Change, Coal and the Flushing Toilet

Sometimes I wonder why people seem to have stopped caring about climate change. Is it because it’s too big? Is it because we have a Prime Minister who is in a dirty love triangle with coal and gas? Or is it the convenience of the flushing toilet?

Entertainment in the Byron Shire for the Week Begining 23 June, 2021

A dazzling array of talent to be seen live, in and around the Byron Shire

The Sourdough Chick rises to the occasion!

When you talk to Susann Wiedermann, her passion for sourdough is clearly evident. She describes the world of sourdough as like ‘falling down a...

Frida’s Field winter menu

  If you’re thinking of a long lunch on Friday, Saturday or Sunday, out in the country with a beautiful outlook across the fields, then...