Thus Spake Mungo: Is Bill Shorten the new Bill Hayden?

At last the fateful day is looming – the interminable campaign for the five by elections no-one wanted (except, of course, the media) is finally coming to a climax.

Or, in the case of at least two of them, an anti-climax: the ritual re-election of Labor in Perth and Fremantle is not in contention, given that the Libs declined to take part.

And unless the polls are way off the mark, Georgina Downer’s quest to regain her hereditary seat of Mayo will mark a humiliating defeat for both her and for Malcolm Turnbull, who has heroically but vainly defended the countess’s right to rule.

But pragmatically, Turnbull and his troops have put their money and resources into the other two, Longman and Braddon, and here they have a real chance. Braddon, in fact, looked like a shoo-in; Labor is on the nose in the apple island and with the relative smallness of the electorate, and the early numbers favoured the Liberal candidate Brett Whitely comfortably,

But as time and attrition took over, Labor’s Justine Keay clawed her way back, and is now well and truly back in the race after a somewhat unpleasant and negative campaign which was at least as much about the leaders as the candidates Turnbull has been targeted for being a millionaire banker, a banker just like Whitely once was, while Shorten has been attacked for just about everything. If Keay gets up, it may require tweaking to the Kill Bill strategy as we move towards the real election.

Longman may be even more problematic: Queensland is, as always, different. Trevor Ruthenberg (‘Big Kev,’ as Turnbull perhaps enviously calls him) was looking good until it appeared that he had misspoken about a military decoration. He may well be forgiven, but the slew of somewhat odd people on the ballot paper (one of whom is a convicted neo-Nazi, to go with One Nation, the Liberal Democrats and the DLP – no shortage of choice on the far right) may easily push him over the line, with a little help from Pauline Hanson and Mark Latham.

The mood is little similar to the feeling at the start of 1983. After eight years of Malcolm Fraser, the electorate was just about ready for change and Bill Hayden was poised to lead Labor back to government. But there were many in the party still very nervous.

Or more rational preferences could yet favour Labor’s Susan Lamb. None of the results will change the government – not immediately. But there could well be major consequences, which is why people are starting to talk seriously about Bill Shorten.

The mood is little similar to the feeling at the start of 1983. After eight years of Malcolm Fraser, the electorate was just about ready for change and Bill Hayden was poised to lead Labor back to government. But there were many in the party still very nervous. Hayden should have won in 1980, but didn’t; and perhaps more significantly Labor fell short of the Flinders by-election at a time when Hayden needed to maintain his momentum.

There was confidence; the polls still showed the ALP ahead, but perhaps not quite enough. And, crucially, there was the obvious alternative: Bob Hawke. This, of course, is the big difference. Anthony Albanese is a popular and in some ways a charismatic figure, but he is no Bob Hawke. And you can bet the Libs have compiled an extensive dirt file on him, so the existing Kill Bill strategy can be seamlessly morphed into Obliterate Albo as soon as needed.

So quite apart from the political cost in switching leaders at all, there is no guarantee that Albanese would get Labor automatically over the line. But having said that, Shorten is in some ways more vulnerable than Hayden ever was.

The previous Labor leader (and subsequently Governor-General) was regarded as a touch unpredictable, even unstable. But no one doubted his decency and sincerity, and these are the qualities that Shorten is seen to lack. This has been the case for most of his career: Faction Man, as David Marr perceptively christened him, has generally been in wheeling and dealing, nurturing his own ambition.

He had been forgiven for it to date because he has also been delivering a record number of Newspoll leads, in spite of everything that has been thrown at him. But on a personal level he has been going backwards, a drag on the party, and this is where he needs to perform.

This should be a doddle: the government has not won an opposition seat in a by-election for almost a century. But the fact that not one but two are now on the edge is concentrating minds wonderfully.

Shorten has lost two earlier dual citizenship by-elections in Bennelong and New England. Although both are regarded as reasonably safe coalition seats, they have both fallen in recent memory, and Shorten’s failure to make a decent dint in them was a matter of concern. But now, partly through his own bravado over the whole constitutional mess, he has to defend Labor seats.

This should be a doddle: the government has not won an opposition seat in a by-election for almost a century. But the fact that not one but two are now on the edge is concentrating minds wonderfully. After all, Labor needs to win Liberal and National seats to gain office – not very many of them, but a decent handful are definitely needed, and more to make things safe from the vagaries of crossbenchers.

Obviously if a couple of its own seats fall in all but unprecedented circumstances, not only does it make things harder in a general election – it suggests that if Shorten cannot even hang on to his own seats, he may be effectively unelectable. People whose judgement I respect have always thought so, in spite of the polling. However badly Turnbull stuffs up — and it has been both long term and spectacular – the feeling is that when it comes to crunch in a one-on-one confrontation, Shorten will fall short.

Albanese has advantages Shorten does not – he is seen as honest, loyal and unfailingly affable – hell, he even has a beer named after him. Making him leader would be a popular move; after all, he won the people’s vote over Shorten in 2013, and Shorten had to rely on his factional parliamentary allies. But there is a huge caveat: in 1983 Hayden, seeing the mood against him, submitted peacefully for the good of the party. Shorten is hardly known for such altruism.

Perhaps it won’t come to this – perhaps Labor will win both Braddon and Longman and it will be Turnbull making excuses and demanding that everybody moves on. But after many months of apprehension and procrastination, the crisis has to be faced. For Bill Shorten, next Saturday night may wll be the loneliest night of the week.

7 responses to “Thus Spake Mungo: Is Bill Shorten the new Bill Hayden?”

  1. Len Heggarty says:

    Time is short and Bill Shorten’s fateful day is looming, or should that be blooming. We’ll see on the other side. The campaign by five that people figured and fingered, except for the media is finally coming to crescendo at the party.

  2. Chris condon says:

    Hayden got the ” Govenorgeneralship PRIZE ” for his gracious gesture. Surely we live in a different era, BUT one truism remains the SAME .
    GOVERNMENTS LOSE Elections , Oppositions ,STUMBLE into Power.

  3. robot says:

    Well well well we have the fascist right and the fascist left, things not boding well for the country. Thank god for the reasoning Greens who have it all worked out for 100 years. We will just have to stop with our Tim Tams next, all that packaging, the only clear solution to all our vicissitudes … or should that be rectitudes.

  4. robot says:

    Ages ago the Left was about social welfare and wages and conditions. The Right was about a free market and independant responsibility. The divisions were not so deep because there was sense on both sides. Pushed, we would admit that. Now we have a hundred and one fringe issues. The divisions cut deep.

  5. Markie Linhart says:

    Sounding a bit like the Oz like this week Mungo. Labor didn’t “lose” the recent by-elections (in Bennelong and New England) rather they didn’t win them. And as for failing to make a dint; they didn’t run in New England and in Bennelong Kristina Keneally reduced the Tories advantage from 10% to 5%.
    Bill Shorten is no Bill Hayden either. I don’t we’ll be seeing any drovers dogs any time soon…

  6. Dan says:

    Incumbent defeated in a BY-Election only happens once in Blue Moon

  7. YoYo says:

    Mungo might like to ponder the adage ‘a week is a long time in politics’.

    All of us were sucked in by the Murdoch propaganda machine and believed Labor and Bill Shorten were going to lose Super Saturday.

    I’ll look forward to the next column from my life long favourite political commentator.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Become a supporter of The Echo

A note from the editorial team

Some of The Echo’s editorial team: journalists Paul Bibby and Aslan Shand, editor Hans Lovejoy, photographer Jeff Dawson and Mandy Nolan

The Echo has never underestimated the intelligence and passion of its readers. In a world of corporate banality and predictability, The Echo has worked hard for more than 30 years to help keep Byron and the north coast unique with quality local journalism and creative ideas. We think this area needs more voices, reasoned analysis and ideas than just those provided by News Corp, lifestyle mags, Facebook groups and corporate newsletters.

The Echo is one hundred per cent locally owned and one hundred per cent independent. As you have probably gathered from what is happening in the media industry, it is not cheap to produce a weekly newspaper and a daily online news service of any quality.

We have always relied entirely on advertising to fund our operations, but often loyal readers who value our local, independent journalism have asked how they could help ensure our survival.

Any support you can provide to The Echo will make an enormous difference. You can make a one-off contribution or a monthly one. With your help, we can continue to support a better informed local community and a healthier democracy for another 30 years.”

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers and is brought to you by this week's sponsors Vast Furniture & Homewares Ballina and Falls Festival Byron Bay.