17.6 C
Byron Shire
October 22, 2021

Correcting Dr Tim Devine

Latest News

Diadem Street, Lismore

Around 2,000 residents in Lismore lost their electricity connection on Wednesday night after a large gum tree took out power lines.

Other News

Lake Ainsworth Cyanobacteria Update – RED ALERT

Ballina Shire Council has just issued a Red Alert for Lake Ainsworth. Water should NOT be used for primary recreation. Users should obey all signage erected by Council.

Locals gathering to object to burning forests, plastic, foils, and tyres for energy at Condong sugar mill

A public protest is taking place this Friday meet near the Condong sugar mill, north of Murwillumbah, at the big fig tree on Tweed Valley Way on Friday, 22 October at 10am to object to the burning of trees and ‘forest waste’ by Cape Byron Power to generate electricity at the Condong sugar mill.

Iona Herbs

Pam Morrow from Iona Herbs is a one-woman-show. She has spent her whole life growing herbs and produce on...

After a long, arduous and uninformed debate… Saddle Road DA approved

Councillors finally ‘got there in the end’, interim Mayor, Michael Lyon, told an exhausted audience after many hours of confused meandering at last Thursday’s Council meeting.

Northern Rivers Mud Trail this weekend

Local ceramic artists will be opening their studios across the Byron, Ballina and Tweed Shires over the weekend, as part of the Northern Rivers Mud Trail.

Slanted and bulldozed

Thanks to Paul Bibby for his (22 September) story, which addresses the outcome of the Council meeting on 16...

Dr Tim Devine makes several impassioned statements in his letter (September 8) about COVID-19 lockdowns and vaccinating children.

I am certain that his arguments are well intended and heartfelt. But they contain substantial inaccuracies. He is writing with the authority of a medical practitioner, so it is important to correct the record. 

There is no doubt that lockdowns, border closures and other restrictions have substantial adverse mental health and economic effects. But compared to what? Doing nothing?

Serious research has found that countries with early border closures and lockdowns (including Australia) suffered fewer deaths, less economic damage, and less curtailment of freedoms than countries with a laxer approach.

In Australia, around 1,100 people have died from COVID-19. The UK with 2.7 times the population has experienced 120 times as many deaths.

My clinical colleagues in Toronto, Canada worked in a tent hospital for months, and American hospitals rented refrigerated trucks to hold the extra bodies. Cemeteries ran out of space. People don’t need to be told to stay home during an out-of-control epidemic. Fear will keep them there. 

Dr Devine calls the protection from COVID-19 vaccines ‘weak and short-lived’. That is untrue. The protection against serious illness from the Delta variant after full vaccination is 80–90 per cent and declines by around three per cent each month. Some people will need booster doses. That is far superior to any influenza vaccine.

If a pill provided this protection against serious illness the queues would be very long. The largest study of COVID-19 vaccine safety was published on August 27 in the UK. The Pfizer and AstraZeneca vaccines appear roughly equivalent in terms of serious adverse effects (including very rare blood clots) and both are far safer for you than infection by the virus.

But Dr Devine is right to question the morality of vaccinating young children to protect adults. If it were that clear cut, I would agree with him. But it is too early to make a judgment about the benefits and harms of COVID-19 vaccines in children. It may well be that, with evolving coronavirus variants, we will vaccinate children to protect children.    

David Henry, Professor of Evidence Based Practice, Bond University and Gold Coast University Hospital

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Professor of Evidence and Bond University – how do they manage financial resourcing ?

    ‘Serious research’ is whatever happens to be the chosen narrative.

    • If you have anything specific to comment or to disagree about the facts that Professor Henry quotes, please inform us and give us sources that prove the opposite.

      Challenging his authority and indeed the authority of scientific learning and university research, comparing it to the ‘general hunch’ of self-declared believers, who find their ‘truth’ in crystals, websites and coffee-clubs, that is indeed what is wrong with our times.

      Everyone has an opinion about how to fly a plane, yet who would you entrust your life with when sitting in that plane – the internet researched, self-taught ‘pilot’ or the pilot that actually was trained by an airline in a program that has checks and balances and that has responsibility for what she is doing?

    • Rudy’s it’s actually professor of “evidence-based practice”. Sounds like a good idea to me. You might be sceptical of private universities but you won’t find very different observations coming from the major sources of epidemiology.

  2. Hi Stefanie,
    Doctors don’t usually publish their home address unless they work from home. I had no trouble finding his practice address out of all paces in the physical phone book!

  3. Naturally they don’t give out home addresses… not even Dr. StrangeLove did that
    since he didn’t exist. I’ll try the movie again.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Black bellied whale sighted at Ballina dubbed ‘Liquorice’

For years southern waters whale watchers have been keeping their eyes keen for Migaloo and his offspring, but just how many local cetacean enthusiasts...

A history of ‘freedom’ and the Northern Rivers vaccine divide

Among the many myths about the COVID-19 vaccines is a belief they contain live virus that a vaccinated person will shed in social and intimate circumstances. Along with many other vaccine myths, this belief is contributing to a significant divide in the Northern Rivers community.

No means no, say traditional owners

As Water Week draws to a close, with a theme of 'Caring for Water and Country', a group of Widjabul Wia-bal elders have emphatically said they do not want the Dunoon Dam proposal to be put back on the table by pro-dam councillors.

Staff cuts at Murwillumbah mega school

The NSW Teacher's Federations says that the proposed merger of four schools in Murwillumbah will result in the loss of at least 19 teaching positions.