22.8 C
Byron Shire
January 21, 2022

Which values are important for the region?

Latest News

Reform needed to deliver electric trucks in Australia

With the aim of getting more electric-powered trucks on Australian roads, the Electric Vehicle Council and the Australian Trucking Association have collaborated to develop the policies necessary to drive Australian trucking into an electric future.

Other News

Localisation shines as supply chains weaken

While Coles and Woolworths struggle with supply chain issues caused by the Omicron outbreak, local farmer’s markets and independent food retailers appear to be coming into their own.

Lismore Women’s Festival cancelled

Due to the ongoing COVID-19 crisis that is sweeping NSW and other states in Australia the Lismore Women’s Festival has been cancelled.

Astrological gravitas

The Mullum Aeronautics and Space Administration (MASA) will soon launch the Spiders Webb telescope, which will break through to...

Lismore’s Australia Day Ambassadors

Ahead of the Australia Day celebrations Olympians Kaarle McCulloch and Kevin Chavez have been announced as Lismore’s 2022 Australia Day Ambassadors.

Eva Ramsey says she will be her own woman on Ballina Council

One of Ballina's new councillors in B Ward is independent Eva Ramsey, who was elected as part of Sharon Cadwallader's team and is joining council for the first time. So why now, and what does she stand for?

The earliest unequivocally modern human remains in Africa

There may be earlier remains of modern humans – but science is certain about these ones.

Public opinion sure is divided about the Dunoon Dam (the DuD). Clearly it does not have sufficient social licence to convince decision makers that it should proceed.

The issue has become one of values. For those who cherish Indigenous heritage, rainforest ecosystems, and endangered species such as koalas, then a project that destroys these things is never going to be acceptable, and will be resisted.

Social and environmental assets cannot just be ignored. They are part of triple bottom line accounting precisely because they are crucial to our society’s wellbeing, and even survival.

When it is apparent that the DuD is not only the most expensive but also the most insecure water option then the unnecessary destruction of irreplaceable assets becomes very difficult to justify.

Creative accounting methods, involving whole-of-life estimates and the total volume of the DuD (instead of the actual volume used), have been used to conceal the huge upfront cost of the DuD. With the usual blowouts this could amount to $400 million. This cost, and the loan repayments, would be borne by current ratepayers but would primarily benefit developers on the coast (where 75 per cent of the water would go). State government subsidies might cover a small proportion but the amount that ratepayers would have to carry is still very substantial.

Pro-dam advocates have vociferously claimed that the only acceptable water option is a second dam on the same creek (remember the 10,000 signatures? – that is what they demanded). No water authority in the world agrees with this idiotic concept.

Those in favour of the DuD consistently deny that intangible values even exist, let alone that they are important. The only values of consequence seem to be those that involve business opportunities and development.

On 4 December I hope that voters can stay true to their values and make sure that the business-trumps-all mentality will not prevail.

The candidates who have stated their opposition to the dam are making a strong statement that people and nature matter. They should be supported.

Nan Nicholson, The Channon

Previous articleCorruption and waste
Next articleDogs need control

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Well said Nan. Our water security will be compromised by using the DuD instead of using multiple strategies that can be built on as necessary. A dam below the existing dam is a nonsense. There will be the additional benefit of saving a wonderful environment and local indigenous heritage.
    My experience is that people who want the DuD usually haven’t read the Futures Plan or consulted expert advise.
    Look carefully who you vote for tomorrow.

  2. The majority of people have clearly voted “yes” for the dam in the local government elections.

    It will definitely be constructed now, thanks to democracy.

    • There was no such question on my ballot paper; I don’t see how you could come anywhere near that sort of conclusion.

      Some coastal developers may think a dam in ‘their’ hinterlands to be a quick fix for something that wouldn’t be a problem with less profligate water usage, or demands for ever more growth when growth is the problem.

      However, rest assured that there is no way that Terania Shire folk will permit any such dam to proceed, any more than destruction of the Terania Creek and Mount Nardi rainforests or GSG mining at Bentley were allowed to proceed.

      Democracy has to be practiced day by day. What happens once every few years can only cause real change by working within ongoing social licence. Better we should seek peaceable solutions.

      • It was not a referendum so of course there were no questions there about the dam or any other specific matter; it was a local government election based on the policies presented by each of the candidates, which means you vote for those policies, people are not stupid the greens have been awful the last few years, absolutely negative and taking us backwards, I used to vote greens every year but not this time. There are actually a lot of people out in the hills who support the dam but are quiet about it, as shown up in the voting polls.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Biz step up to feed frontline staff

Local paramedics will be able to get free coffee and snacks at selected local cafes, as part of a major community effort to support frontline health workers during the ongoing and increasing COVID-19 outbreak.

Casino’s winning tap water ways

Yesterday Casino was announced as the winner of the Water Industry Operators Association of Australia’s Ixom 2021 Best Tasting Tap Water in Australia competition.

Astrological gravitas

The Mullum Aeronautics and Space Administration (MASA) will soon launch the Spiders Webb telescope, which will break through to deeper levels of Advanced Astrological...

SES issues Minor Flood warning for Lismore

Moderate rainfall across the Wilsons River catchment since Wednesday has caused significant river level rises along the Wilsons River and its tributaries, which has the potential to cause minor flooding along the Wilsons River at Lismore late Friday morning.