22.6 C
Byron Shire
November 14, 2026

Comment: Wealthy, clever nation needs more than luck

Latest News

Shoebridge’s forked tongue

Senator Shoebridge tells us that Ukraine has his full support – but is ruling out arms transfers to Ukraine...

Other News

Help get Mullum High junior debaters to state finals

After a stint as an English curriculum advisor, Mr Clarke is back as head of the English department at Mullumbimby High School, and debating is back with the junior debate team going to state finals in early December.

Let us be different

Here, here to Mike Balson’s letter in The Echo of 2 October. I agree wholeheartedly with what Mike Balson...

Koalas on the move – stay alert on the roads

Over spring and summer koalas are on the move as they search for food, territory and mates.

Get into the Christmas spirit with Tweed Coast Band

The Tweed Coast Band is inviting the community to its Christmas Concert at South Tweed Sports Club on Sunday 13 December at 2pm: an afternoon of traditional Christmas music from one of the Tweed’s hidden gems.

‘Dancing against violence’ in Lismore

A sold-out gala in Lismore has raised more than $200,000 for Women Up North (WUN) and its Bugalma Bihyn Aboriginal Women’s Refuge, which can accommodate up to five families.

Cadwallader says Ballina hospital infrastructure plans ‘a shambles’

Ballina is trapped in a health planning paradox, with no hospital site, no construction funding and no clear investment pathway, according to independent candidate for Ballina and local mayor Sharon Cadwallader.

The images coming from the floods were devastating.

Scenes of entire regions washed away, of drowned livestock washing up on far-away beaches, and of shivering people huddled together on rooftops struck Australia with a horror not seen since the Black Summer bushfires.

And that brutal reality check was nothing compared with the experience of local communities who continue to pick through the debris.

Andrew P Street. Photo Daniel Boud.

It’s not exactly controversial to say that we’re now beyond the ‘If we don’t do anything’ point of warnings about the future consequences of a warming planet and are well into the early stages of ‘How do we slow this down and mitigate the effects that are already pouring under our doors?’

The heroes of the floods were the brave folks who went out in tinnies and on surfboards to rescue those who were trapped, and the folks with houses still standing who’ve opened them to those who’d lost everything.

That big-hearted community spirit of looking out for one another: that’s what saved lives in the moment, and that’s what will save even more lives going forward.

And I’m no disaster expert, but one thing I can say with confidence is that individual solutions aren’t going to cut it.

I’ll go further: getting Centrelink to approve conditional one-off payments to individuals in specific zones (but not others) is a good deal closer to an insult than a leg-up.

It’s important to have this in mind because all the signs are that the current federal government will be focused upon putting the onus back on individuals – exhausted, traumatised individuals who, in a lot of cases, aren’t going to have rescued the sorts of records and paperwork required to access whatever insufficient dribbles of money are theoretically available.

With so many of the bushfire affected regions still yet to be rebuilt years on, we know there’s a long road ahead; one with precious few amenities along the way.

Victim-blaming 

And tut-tutting headlines telling people they shouldn’t have built on floodplains, from the same columnists who’ve spent years sneering that people just need to give up their lattes and move to the regions if they can’t afford a house in Sydney, need to be called out for their unhelpful victim-blaming rhetoric.

What we need now are big, collective strategies, because the alternative of leaving people to sort things out for themselves can only go so far.

And yes, all solutions are going to be expensive as hell and governments have to accept and prepare for that.

But, as we’ve been told on multiple occasions, there are 4.7 billion public dollars, supposedly, sitting in a federal Emergency Response Fund, which remains mysteriously untouched – a choice that seems inhumane at best and, with an election right around the corner, rather like a personal insult to the voters of NSW and Qld at worst.

Also, as Lismore can attest, not doing anything is also expensive as hell, and comes with a massive bonus cost in human suffering.

Like the government’s ‘individual responsibility’ mandate for dealing with a global pandemic of a contagious virus, ‘letting things happen’ because it’s too much effort to prevent is immeasurably more expensive than just doing the work.

We’re rich, we’re clever, and the floods have shown that we are ready to help one another in times of need.

This won’t be the last time we’ll need to draw on our stores of resilience and strength, which is too much to ask of individuals in the thick of a crisis, but boundless when spread out among entire communities, states and nations.

It’s time that we let the neoliberalist fantasy world of ‘individual responsibility’ be washed away like a thousand unsecured wheelie bins.

It’s the only way we’re going to keep our heads above water.



For four decades The Echo has printed the stories some people loved, some people hated, and some pretended not to read. If you want us to keep telling the truth, the real truth, not the sugar-coated version. We’ll need your support to keep the presses rolling.

If you are a local business owner help us and in turn we help you. All The Echo asks for is advertising, not a free ride. It is every advert in The Echo and on www.echo.net.au, which creates the space for all the stories and coverage of community events, happenings and concerns.

If you are a reader you can become a sponsor of The Echo. Your support keeps the us independent.

Even a small one-off or regular donation from you will help keep the echo’s independent voice alive and strong.

Support Us

Become one of the supporters who helps keep independent, local journalism alive in the Byron Shire by contributing anything from as little as the cost of a coffee each month.

You're Wonderful, Thank you for supporting independent journalism in the Byron Shire

You’re supporting The Echo, thank you

Your contribution is keeping independent, local journalism alive in the Northern Rivers.

Because of supporters like you, we can keep every story free for everyone — no paywall, no exceptions. Your money goes directly to funding our newsroom of 40-odd local workers covering the stories that matter to this community.

Tell us what you think, give us your opinion

The Echo loves your letters and comments and is proud to provide a community forum on the issues that matter most to our readers and the people of the NSW north coast. So don’t be a passive reader, email us your epistles at editor@echo.net.au.

The letters deadline for The Echo is noon Friday. Letters longer than 200 words may be cut. The publication of letters is at the discretion of the letters editor. Please remember to include your full name, address and telephone number.

Online comments are no longer available.

Students strike to reclaim their future

On Friday 20 November, students in the Byron Shire and surrounds will close their books and laptops to meet at Apex Park, Byron Bay in another strike for climate action.

Cadwallader says Ballina hospital infrastructure plans ‘a shambles’

Ballina is trapped in a health planning paradox, with no hospital site, no construction funding and no clear investment pathway, according to independent candidate for Ballina and local mayor Sharon Cadwallader.

The fastest climate solution has two wheels and no tailpipe

As the climate negotiations start in earnest at COP31, major Australian cities are backing a global citizens initiative calling for targets for cycling to be included in Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs).

Stretched to the limit – Stolen Generations orgs say time is running out

Stolen Generations organisations from across Australia have issued an urgent challenge, just months out from the 30th anniversary of the landmark Bringing Them Home report, for governments and the nation to ensure the experiences, truths and recommendations of the report are not forgotten and commit to change for survivors and descendants.