19.9 C
Byron Shire
September 28, 2023

Concerns raised over federal Labor’s disinformation bill

Latest News

Families consider class action against Intrapac over cancelled Banyan Hill house and land contracts

Nearly fifty local Intrapac house and land buyers on the Northern Rivers may need to take Supreme Court action to avoid being short-changed and priced out of the region.

Other News

Legend Pizza

If you go back in time 32 years, Byron was very different, but Legend Pizza was already a massive favourite of locals. You’d have to be a bit of a legend to have a successful business that’s been right in the middle of Jonson St for 30 of those years; that’s been locally owned and operated the whole time.

Heat the biggest climate change killer – Tweed Council takes action

Since 1890, heat and heat waves have killed more Australians than bushfires, cyclones, earthquakes, floods, and severe storms combined and Tweed Shire Council are looking at ways to future proof the shire through their DCP.

Urban increase blueprint unveiled for Byron Shire

meeting that, if eventually adopted, could see upscaled urban development across the Shire via ‘infill, new release, existing zoned vacant land and living differently’.

Misanthropic disGrace

Hannah Grace’s recent letter ‘Benefits of microplastic’ might be considered a sick joke, but over the years misanthropy has...

Already in ‘No’

When asked about the Voice referendum, Aboriginal performance artist and blogger, Briggs, summed it up pretty concisely: ‘Why would...

Running the NY Marathon for type-1 diabetes research

Southern Cross University student Georgie Collis has type-1 diabetes but this won't stop her running in the New York Marathon in November to raise funds for research.

A legal advocacy group has raised concerns over a proposed bill by federal Labor, that if it were to become law, would arm a government department with ‘extraordinary coercive powers’ to monitor and enforce an ‘industry standard’ of misinformation and disinformation on digital platforms.

The Communications Legislation Amendment (Combatting Misinformation and Disinformation) Bill 2023 is on public exhibition until August 6.

According to federal Labor, the proposed powers would ‘enable the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) to gather information from digital platform providers, or require them to keep certain records about matters regarding misinformation and disinformation’. 

And ‘should an [enforceble] code of practice be deemed ineffective in combatting misinformation and disinformation on digital platforms’, the proposed law would ‘allow the ACMA to create and enforce an industry standard (a stronger form of regulation)’.

Within the Victorian Bar’s submission to the Law Council regarding the bill, they write, ‘The Bill arms the ACMA with extraordinary coercive powers that can be exercised against any person who might have information or documents “relevant” to the existence of, among other things, “misinformation or disinformation on a digital platform service”.’ 

‘Suspected authors or disseminators of alleged “misinformation” are obvious targets for the exercise of such powers. That makes this part of the Bill somewhat unique within its overall scheme – here the Bill is concerned with the responsibilities of individuals, rather than services providers’. 

Unlevel playing field 

Additionally, the Victorian Bar says the law would create ‘an unlevel playing field between governments and other speakers’. 

They write: ‘Any view authorised by the government is, by statutory definition, not “misinformation”, however false or misleading it might be. Only information that is not authorised by government is capable of being “misinformation” as defined. 

‘That double standard is illiberal, and disadvantages critics of government in comparison with a government’s supporters’. 

Additionally, they say the definition of ‘misinformation’ is over-broad and unworkable; the concept of ‘excluded content’ is insufficiently protective of free speech, and places excessive interpretative power in an executive agency; the Bill wrongly assumes that ‘misinformation’ and ‘disinformation’ can readily be identified, and that the ACMA is capable of doing so within the limits of its resources and expertise and the imposition of regulatory burdens and other concerns.

The Victorian Bar concludes such a law ‘will have a chilling effect’. 

They write, ‘It is also likely to be ineffective and unworkable in responding to the harms to which it is purportedly directed’. 

Federal Communications Minister, Michelle Rowland, outlined in a June 25 press release: ‘It does not empower the ACMA to determine what is true or false, or to remove individual content or posts.’

‘The code and standard-making powers will not apply to professional news content or authorised electoral content,’ the minister said.

Paul Gregoire, from www.sydneycriminallawyers.com.au, writes that it ‘raises the question as to just who does determine the truth and who the targeted entities are, since the mainstream media and government are absolved’.

For more info visit www.infrastructure.gov.au/have-your-say/new-acma-powers-combat-misinformation-and-disinformation.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Who wouldn’t be concerned about a lefty socialist government wanting to sensor the population?. I urge everyone to speak up and reject this ridiculous draconian piece of lunacy. How stupid does this incompetent inept government think we are?. It just demonstrates their contempt for everyone. Don’t let them get away with this travesty.

  2. The Tiananmen Square Massacre is still classified as misinformation by the Chinese government. Simply mentioning the massacre online carries a jail term to protect the Chinese people from dangerous mis and dis information.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Heat the biggest climate change killer – Tweed Council takes action

Since 1890, heat and heat waves have killed more Australians than bushfires, cyclones, earthquakes, floods, and severe storms combined and Tweed Shire Council are looking at ways to future proof the shire through their DCP.

Former NSW Premier Bob Carr backs end to land clearing in NSW

Recognising the impacts of logging and clearing native forests former NSW Premier Bob Carr has backed ongoing calls to halt land clearing in NSW.

Crash following alleged pursuit – Murwillumbah

A vehicle has crashed following an alleged pursuit at Murwillumbah yesterday. About 9.30am (Wednesday, 27 September, 2023), officers attached to Tweed/Byron Police District attempted to...

Byron homeless hub forced to cut vital services

Byron’s only homeless hub says it has to reduce services owing to an increase in demand and a lack of government funding.