Ballina Shire Councillor Jeff Johnson has strongly criticised Mayor Sharon Cadwallader’s use of her casting vote on the issues of conservation zones and electoral boundaries.
He says that at the last Ballina Council meeting the mayor used her casting vote to ‘kill off new land management initiatives aimed at improving conservation outcomes in the Ballina Shire’. This includes over 2300 hectares of wetlands, coastal areas, endangered ecological communities, forested areas, scenic escarpments and rural farming properties.
‘The council vote was 5-5 with all four Team Cadwallader Councillors supporting the radical decision to allow property owners to determine their own property zone through an “opt-in” concept that goes against the advice of senior council staff and the NSW Department of Planning and Environment (DPE),’ said Cr Johnson.
‘As a former deputy mayor and a Ballina Shire Councillor for over 15 years it is my opinion that using a casting vote in this way is totally inappropriate. It shows contempt for council staff and a total disregard for the health of our local environment.
‘It also undermines many of Ballina Council’s long-established environmental initiatives such as our Biodiversity Strategy, Koala Management Plan and our Healthy Waterways program.’
Dominant group
Cr Johnson says the decision highlights how easily poor decisions are made when there is a dominant group on council.
‘Team Cadwallader currently has 4 out of 10 councillors so they only need the support of one other councillor to make unilateral decisions,’ he said.
‘This isn’t the first time the mayor has used the casting vote to go against the advice of the professional staff. This approach to decision-making tarnishes Ballina Council’s reputation and brings the organisation into disrepute.’
According to Cr Johnson, ‘The advice provided by the Department of Planning and the Environment (DPE) was clear and confirmed that zoning decisions are “required to be consistent with the methodology contained within the North Coast E Zones Final Recommendations Report” (NCEZR), i.e. based on the environmental attributes of the land or the Primary Land Use (PLU).
‘The DPE’s advice was highly critical of Team Cadwallader’s proposed approach of only applying “a conservation zone where a written request from a landholder was submitted to Council”.
Cr Johnson said, ‘The DPE letter goes further to highlight that “an undesirable precedent could be established if certain rezonings are not being based on site attributes and planning merits, but instead on landowner agreement”.
Reverse decision?
Jeff Johnson says the NSW state government should be reversing Ballina Council’s decision on conservation zones. ‘If councillors don’t want to make major planning decisions based on the legislation and the clearly established planning framework then they shouldn’t be on council,’ he said.
‘The other recent decision where the casting vote was used was to support Cr Bruem’s (Team Cadwallader) electoral boundary change which again went against the staff recommendation and also 97 per cent of public submissions. One has to ask why?
‘I believe it’s politically motivated and an attempt to gain an extra Team Cadwallader councillor at the next election and therefore gain total control of the council for the next four years,’ he said.
Accoring to Cr Johnson, ‘This would be bad news for good governance and the environment. Clearly Mayor Cadwallader doesn’t respect the public submissions, which was highlighted by her use of the casting vote against the clear feedback from the public (97 per cent).
‘I don’t think there has been a consultation process that was so against a councillor initiative.
‘These decisions highlight the poor leadership being shown that in my opinion (and many others) reflects poorly on all councillors,’ concluded Cr Johnson.
More stories about Ballina Shire Council:
Ballina Salvage Shed’s recycled art competition now open
Are you ready to let your imagination run wild? Ballina's Salvage Shed is once again running their Recycled Art Competition, offering a fun way to keep trash out of landfill while supporting local not-for-profit organisation Momentum Collective.
Cadwallader reclaims Ballina mayoral title but likely outnumbered on council
Sharon Cadwallader is poised to take on her second term as Ballina Shire Mayor after Saturday’s Election Day official vote-counting showed the independent had a clear lead.
Free bike safety and maintenance workshops
Ballina Shire Council will be running two free bike safety workshops during the school holidays on Wednesday 2 October and Wednesday 9 October 2024.
What’s likely to happen with Ballina Shire Council?
On 14 September the people of Ballina will elect nine councillors plus a mayor. Unlike some parts of NSW, where there are more councillor positions than candidates, a large field of applicants are vying for the chance to represent their diverse communities across Ballina Shire, from Newrybar in the north to Cabbage Tree Island in the south, and from Wollongbar in the west to fast-growing Lennox Head in the east.
Big Q&A with Ballina’s local government candidates
Council elections are rapidly approaching, but many of those seeking election in Ballina are still a mystery to potential voters. The Echo has been trying to find out what makes the latest batch of candidates tick, beyond the statements in their PR material.
isn’t the echo meant to be a neutral, local news source, instead of a greens political notebook?
Why would you think that?
Neutral?
Sure more neutral than the Murdoch press.
Like it or lump it, that is democracy at work.
and some politicians are appalled by it.
Gerrymandering okay then?
There are certain factions within our local councils that preset themselves as “independent” when in fact they are Nats. Obviously, there is no law against being a Nat, but if that’s who and what you are and that’s how you will vote on issues, then surely that’s how you should be presented when you put your name on a Ballot sheet. Love or hate Jeff Johnson, at least you know what party he belongs to.
Ballina Council is certainly looking bad with questionable process re use of the mayor’s casting vote + the decisions this has enabled. Best practice for the casting vote is that it should be exercised – (i) trying to use it to enable further discussion, (ii) where no further discussion is possible, decisions should only be made by a majority vote, and (iii) should be used to maintain the status quo. (You can check this on the APH web).
Boundary changes for Council wards and allowing rubbery environmental protections are both critical issues and it’s good that Jeff has raised them as well as the casting vote problem.
We should not have to endure poor procedural practices by decision makers, nor the problematic decisions that flow from them.
K. Lavender.
Lennox Head.
Increasingly we see Councils dominated by ‘Teams’ of counsellors with a specific agenda, often supported by relevant industry groups. Such as developers. Money speaks. The only way to stop this is only to vote for independent candidates with a proven, community minded track record, not for those who can spend the most bucks during electioneering.
Mike, we voted for “Independent” candidates last LG election and look at the mob of National party hacks we ended up with, what a “well organized” con job that was.
In response to Lavendar. I used my casting vote to keep the status quo. It was a rescission motion that was voted down.
For the record I am not a National Party member. Yes I was once but am not and have not been a member for the past 9 years!
Yes Sharon we already know that you were a member of the National Party, but please forgive us for thinking that old habits do die hard.