15.3 C
Byron Shire
June 21, 2021

Meditation retreat refusal ‘a win for wildlife’

Latest News

Travel declaration required for travellers entering Queensland

Queensland Health says that all travellers from a state or territory with a declared COVID-19 hotspot (currently Victoria and from 1am Saturday, June 19 also New South Wales) are required to complete a Queensland Border Declaration Pass prior to entry.

Other News

Morning Tea

Susan Tsicalas, President, BVCAG The Brunswick Valley Cancer Action Group (BVCAG) recently held a raffle, a couple of bucket shakes and...


Tom Tabart, Former Byron Greens councillor It seems that I may have touched a nerve in my attempt to give...

Connor just wants to finish his HSC in 2021

On March 23 2019 Connor Meldrum’s life changed forever and he has spent much of the last two years trying to regain normality – that is, as much normality as you can with only half a skull.

Mental health workshop for girls in Lennox

The mental health organisation Beautiful Minds is holding a one day workshop for pre-teen girls in Lennox Head on Sunday 27 June 2021.

Anatomy is destiny

Gareth W R Smith, Palestine Liberation Centre Five members of Byron Friends of Palestine visited Justine Elliot to discuss whether the...

COVID-19 vaccination clinic opens at Tweed Mall

Northern NSW Local Health District (NNSWLHD) has announced that a new location for getting the COVID -19 vaccination has opened today in Tweed Heads.

Melissa Hargraves

It has taken 18 months but the controversial Rosebank Buddhist Retreat and adjoining rural landsharing community development applications (DAs) were unanimously rejected by Lismore City Council (LCC) at last night’s meeting.

In recommending rejection, council staff noted that: the proposed removal of trees is likely to have a significant adverse impact on flora and fauna in an identified wildlife corridor; adequate road access has not been provided to service the development; sewage disposal arrangements are inadequate; and the site requires an Aboriginal cultural heritage report.

They also acknowledged the substantial opposition of Rosebank residents to the proposal.

Damian Chapelle of Newton Denny Chapelle, representing the retreat developers, sought deferment of the application to address the issues raised by Council in a letter received only this month. He questioned ‘how Council could determine an outcome when his clients have not had sufficient time to substantiate the recommendations’.

‘Why would Council request further information addressing each reason for refusal if they did not believe these could not be resolved?’ Mr Chapelle asked.

He added that his clients were only ‘made aware of the Aboriginal cultural heritage at a site meeting on 6 June. Since this time, Ainsworth Heritage have been engaged and have prepared the due diligence report to the satisfaction of the Office of Environment & Heritage guidelines.’

Cr Simon Clough asked Mr Chapelle to explain ‘why the longstanding wastewater management issue has still not been resolved’.

‘In relation to the landsharing community development, the second report adhered to council recommendations for buffering and clustering of the housing… there was a pump system, which has been previously approved by Council in other applications,’ Mr Chapelle responded.

‘We are acutely aware now that council’s technical staff isn’t in favour of using pump systems. They have requested us to illustrate a density on the site that could be achieved in accordance with the policy. That came out in a letter, dated July, that we will adhere to should Council issue a deferment tonight.’

Mr Chapelle disputed the number of trees council staff considered needed to be removed in the upgrade of Fox Road. He told Council, ‘less than half of what council estimated would be removed and more importantly there is no removal of any threatened species… and koala food trees will be retained’.

Rehabilitation of wildlife habitat on Fox Road has been carried out over 20 years.

Local resident Alicia Carter celebrated Council’s decision and told Echonetdaily,WIRES Northern Rivers has five wildlife carers living on Fox Road. For at least five years solidly, we have set up large endangered-species aviaries for all species. We have been releasing into this special area which is why it is so critical that it is preserved.’

Ms Carter watched on throughout Council’s decision-making process. Pictures of koalas were held in front of a few members of the gallery.

‘That koala picture I was holding,’ Ms Carter explained, ‘is a koala that has been raised across the road from the development and still visits, so it would be one of the first to be jeopardised.

‘It is also the small unseen animals that are impacted on the most. The habitat is too critical to tamper with.’

Mal Fox, another neighbour who opposes the development told Council, ‘If a bushfire were to start in this development it has the real risk of cutting Fox Road residents off from their only escape route. As a firefighter living above these developments I find this a very real and concerning threat. The previous dwelling on my property was lost to fire.’

Cr Clough shares the concerns about fire and believes there should be more significant consultation with the community.

After reading in the reports that the Rural Fire Service (RFS) didn’t believe there was a problem, Cr Clough said he investigated them more closely to discover that ‘the consultants were in the city and did not consult the community or the local bush fire brigade’.

Mr Fox believes that locals have lost faith in the proponents showing any future compliance because of existing ‘illegal building and dodgy earthworks’.

He also said that Council should ‘enforce the removal of seven buildings that have been constructed without approval as well as stabilising and replanting the northern access of Fox Road’.

Cr Meineke confirmed that Council had witnessed the illegal dwellings.

Jan Upton’s property also neighbours the development. She told Council, ‘I have cattle and there is no buffer zone to repair or replace the fence… ‘

‘In previous DAs it has been quoted incorrectly that I have not harvested for several years. I regularly harvest my macadamia nuts and have only not harvested over the last two years because of wet weather,’ she said.

Eric Kinchin has been a resident of Fox Road, Rosebank for more than 20 years. He told Council, ‘This size [of] development in Rosebank is without precedent and this outcome will set one… This has created disunity amongst our community.’

Cr Clough admitted that the issue was difficult for him as he did a Vipassana retreat (similar to those proposed to be held at the venue) more than 30 years ago, which ‘changed [his] life’.

Submissions received in favour of the retreat shared his sympathies but, Cr Clough said, ‘they did not address the issue of planning and that is where, unfortunately, the problem lies’.

India Fox, also of Fox Road, told Echonetdaily that her opposition ‘is not against the people who practise Vipassana. When I first heard they were coming in I actually emailed them and said I was aware of how peaceful they are and welcomed them. I did not realise the sheer size of this development or the clearing that they have already done.’

Julia Hanson lives on Fox Road and wanted to congratulate Council on their decision because of its importance to wildlife.

‘Fox Road is a wildlife corridor and there are threatened species living here. This is a win for wildlife.’


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. ‘Flora and fauna’ again! How often do these two ‘females’ get trotted out to hamper any and every proposed development in the country? If it’s not protecting the hairy-nosed wombats and skinks, it’s protecting some other genus, real or supposed.

    • Why is it that this site for the peaceful evolutionary practice of vipassana gets denied, yet the wildlife corridor to tyalgum is compromised to provide a festival site? It doesn’t make sense.
      Cattle farming is close by… a massive waste of fertile land, useful for native habitat. Housing would have also contributed to the degradation of the area for native wildlife.
      Everything is energy, and with the energy produced from mass meditations, imagine the vibration of the area. It would thrive.
      How wonderful when old thinking has a paradigm shift. It will happen eventually. Congratulations in advance!

    • Thousands and thousands of dollars and hours have already been put into the endangered species project that already exists on Fox Rd. It would be counter productive to then use the space for more human habitation when there are already so many places for the human species. There is a reason they are called endangered species, its because there are not very many left. So inline with Federal Legislation we must not futher degrade their homes. Put the shoe on the other foot. You are an owl, human comes along, chops down your tree killing your family, how would you feel, honestly ask yourself what would you do if someone bulldozed your house. They are not just animals, we are all blooming breathing creatures and the retreats no kill policy should take into consideration that a bulldozer, chainsaw and car traffice will kill thus not suitable. Commiserations however they were duly warned about the site, the terrible access road and the high biodiversity status of the area, yet they chose to ignore the facts of the situation. Great idea wrong location.

  2. There are literally hundreds of these retreats all over the world, and all have been very carefully developed to minimise impact to local wildlife and residents. It seems odd that in a region such as the Northern Rivers they face the most violent opposition. Surely this will cost them thousands (all funded by donations from peaceful participants of this non sectarian practice) to have started building and developing a site only to be kicked out when they have complied with everything that has been asked of them. I think its both an embarrassment and a real shame.

  3. Its, just it was a good idea in the wrong place. a lack of clear thought maybe? it will give the Visspassna crew something to meditate on. Hopefully they will choose a path of least resistance and relocate to somewhere more suitable in the nthn rivers or even the gold coast?

  4. If this parcel of land is available to be developed I could not think of anyone more suitable, in terms of protection of wildlife, than Buddhists.

    It’s unthinkable that they would be dishonourable in their transactions, with ethics so highly prominent in the teachings. Unthinkable too that they would harm wildlife or any living thing including their habitat.

    Let’s hope that a good outcome results. Ideally that land should be locked up for wildlife in perpetuity.

    It’s wonderful that so many people are so concerned about protecting fauna and flora in the area. Already humans have done way too much damage – I am particularly upset about the festival site at Yelgun, a million times worse for koalas and many threatened species! At least the Buddhist development will be quiet, have no wild parties and no alcohol or drugs, surely the best developer one could hope for?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

‘Technically no longer human’ – can mRNA COVID-19 vaccines meld with your DNA?

It’s becoming increasingly common to see social media posts claiming that the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines, which include those made by Pfizer and Moderna, could alter a person’s DNA.

Lantern parade and fiery finish a blast

With just under 5,000 people including performers, workers, schools and volunteers, the 2021 Lismore Lantern Parade and accompanying festival was a sold-out event celebrating light.

Art headed for the bin after Lismore competition

Making rubbish look great is the outcome of a resent art competition in Lismore – Indigenous art, koalas, rainbows, bats and lorikeets all feature in artwork that will soon be printed onto new bins in Carrington Street.

Locals to fight back with a series about the REAL Byron Bay

News that Netflix was planning to film a vacuous docudrama in Byron Bay brought a collective snort of derision across the Shire.