23.8 C
Byron Shire
May 18, 2022

Coalition hypocrisy? Abbott and Hockey in their own words

Latest News

Tripling water harvesting may leave local communities dry

The NSW government was looking to do catchment by catchment analysis to determine the risk to local water supply and rivers from the new rules on water harvesting rights.

Other News

Knitting Nannas say ‘Vote 1 our Planet!’

The Knitting Nannas Against Gas and Greed visited the Lismore pre-poll yesterday at Southern Cross University to spread a very important message.

Lennox Longboard ‘One Dayer’ going ahead

The organisers of the 2022 Rip Curl Lennox Longboard 'One Dayer' are hoping it will be third time lucky after their event was postponed due to COVID and then catastrophic flooding. The event is now scheduled for this Sunday, 15 May.

SCU to house temporary accommodation for flood-affected residents

Temporary homes will be located at Southern Cross University (SCU) Lismore Campus as part of the NSW government's program to provide 800 temporary housing options for flood-affected people.

‘Unprecedented’ but not unpredicted – we are now suffering from our failure to listen to scientists’ predictions of the impacts of climate change 30...

As Australians head into another election season just as many parts of the east coast are recovering from ‘unprecedented’ flooding since February, and the national psyche is still reeling from the trauma of the ‘unprecedented’ Black Summer bushfires before that, it is critical now more than ever to vote according to your environmental conscience and fear for the future.

First residents move in to Wollongbar housing pods

The first residents displaced by the flooding disaster have now received the keys to their temporary housing pods at Wollongbar, Ballina Council says.

Interviews with Richmond candidates 2022: Independent Terry Sharples

Terry Sharples is a retired accountant living in the Tweed Shire and running as an Independent for the federal...

Question time: PM Tony Abbott and Treasurer Joe Hockey in parliament. Photo AAP Image/Daniel Munoz
Question time: PM Tony Abbott and treasurer Joe Hockey in Parliament. Photo AAP Image/Daniel Munoz

Cathy Alexander, Crikey deputy editor

As Tony Abbott’s government prepares to hand down its first budget next month, there are surprise plans for a new ‘deficit tax’ or levy, plus cuts to welfare payments for families earning over $100,000. Neither plan was mentioned before last year’s election. We compare what coalition leaders are saying now with what they said before getting elected. Will there be some ‘nasty surprises and lame excuses’ from Abbott after all?

On increasing taxation …

Then-shadow treasurer Joe Hockey in a media interview, June 29, 2010:

‘Because under us, let me tell you, Tim, I say it with absolute, absolute conviction and with no qualifications, we will always spend less than Labor, and we will always tax less than Labor.’

Then-opposition leader Tony Abbott, February 10, 2011, in a speech to Parliament on Labor’s temporary levy after the Queensland floods:

‘Why should the Australian people be hit with a levy to meet expenses which a competent, adult, prudent government should be able to cover from the ordinary revenues of government? … The one thing [people] will never have to suffer under a coalition government is an unnecessary new tax, a tax that could easily be replaced by savings found from the budget.’

Then-opposition Treasury spokesman Joe Hockey, January 25, 2011, on the flood levy:

‘This is a dumb idea … It will indirectly affect everyone because there will be less money and less spending in the community …’

Hockey on the flood levy, January 26, 2011:

‘It’s just plain stupid, dumb stuff.’

Abbott to a No Carbon Tax rally, August 16, 2011:

‘No tax collection before an election.’

Abbott speech to Parliament, September 14, 2011:

‘I say to this prime minister there should be no new tax collection without an election.’

Abbott, media conference, March 12, 2012:

‘What you’ll get under us are tax cuts without new taxes.’

Abbott media conference, November 20, 2012:

Abbott: ‘We are about reducing taxes, not increasing taxes. We are about getting rid of taxes, not imposing new taxes.’

Journalist: ‘Is that a promise?’

Abbott: ‘This is my whole reason for being in politics, in the parliament.’

Liberal election policy, 2013:

‘But only the coalition can be trusted to actually deliver tax cuts and genuine tax reform that will boost the economy and ease cost‑of‑living pressures for Australian families.’

In April 2014 it was revealed the coalition plans to bring in a new ‘deficit tax’ to get the budget closer to surplus. According to media reports, the tax would likely take the form of a direct levy or an increase in income tax rates, which would kick in for people earning $80,000–100,000.

Abbott in a radio interview, April 29, 2014:

‘I think if there was a permanent increase in taxation that would certainly be inconsistent with the sort of things said before the election … I am committed to lower, simpler, fairer taxes. Do I say that no charges will rise? No, I don’t.’

On whether families on $150,000 should get social security …

Abbott, May 2011, on Labor’s move to freeze the indexation of welfare payments to families earning $150,000:

‘These are class-war cuts that the government is inflicting on people.’

Hockey on Labor’s move, 2011:

‘… the politics of envy.’

Abbott in his budget reply speech, May 10, 2012:

‘The fundamental problem with this budget is that it deliberately, coldly, calculatedly plays the class-war card … families on $150,000 a year are not rich, especially if they’re paying mortgages in our big cities.’

This week, Abbott said families earning over $100,000 should no longer get welfare payments, a surprise announcement that experts say probably means cuts to the Family Tax Benefit system and the paid parental leave scheme.

Abbott in a speech on April 28, 2014:

‘But the best way to help families on $100,000 a year is long-term tax relief and more business and job opportunities, not social security.’

On keeping election promises …

Abbott at the coalition’s election campaign launch, August 25, 2013:

‘We will be a no-surprises, no-excuses government, because you are sick of nasty surprises and lame excuses from people that you have trusted with your future.’

This article was first published on crikey.com.au.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. This government is an absolute disgrace. I am ashamed of their greedy tactics and their inability to deliver democracy to the people of Australia and I have never felt so underwhelmed by our leaders. They work for me, they are not fulfilling their job descriptions. They are relieved of their duties as of now, They are dismissed. I did not vote for a pack of lying, cheating, greedy, selfish sycophants who care nothing for families or communities. They make me sick!

  2. Why don’t they set by example by cutting some of the government perks like cut down on their travel expenses , maybe take a pay cut or perhaps cutting down on staff that are not need like half the senate who fall asleep awhile in session. Maybe then we would not be so angry.

  3. ‘We will be a no-surprises, no-excuses government, because you are sick of nasty surprises and lame excuses from people that you have trusted with your future.’

    Yep! No surprises there! Where is all the Ju-liar stuff that accompanied the previous PM??? I don’t understand why PM rAbbott isn’t similarly denigrated.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

SCU to house temporary accommodation for flood-affected residents

Temporary homes will be located at Southern Cross University (SCU) Lismore Campus as part of the NSW government's program to provide 800 temporary housing options for flood-affected people.

Secret agreements and done deals

Government and Byron Council refuse to explain details around temporary accommodation plans

Sue Higginson MLC: a woman on a mission

Local mother, grandmother, partner, activist, farmer, and lawyer, Sue Higginson, can now add NSW MLC Senator to her list of hyphenates.

One Nation ‘ghost’ haunting Richmond

Less than a week out from the election, mystery surrounds the One Nation candidate and her connection to the electorate.