17 C
Byron Shire
April 11, 2021

Is food chain collapse behind shark attacks?

Latest News

Exactly how was the ship stuck?

Peter Olson, Goonengerry It is well known that The Echo does not publish fake news, so since the Australian media...

Other News

Local teams head north under new set-up for women’s AFL 

Local women’s AFL will have a shake-up this year as the Lismore Swans join the Northern Rivers league...

Vehicle sanitisation stations roll out

Enhanced safety measures for point to point transport such as taxis, hire and rideshare vehicles are being rolled out in Byron Bay, Ballina and Lismore with the opening of three free temporary vehicle sanitisation stations.

Poor Pauline

Bob Vinnicombe, Sefton A lot of hypocrisy from Labor and The Greens about respect for women. Look at the treatment...

Women’s rights focus at Renew Fest

Two further headlining guests have been announced for Renew Fest, which describes itself as a ‘festival of full system...

Shearwater almost perfect with 99kW solar

Shearwater, the Mullumbimby Steiner School, has made the switch to solar, installing a 99 kW system to power the school into the future.

New food donation campaign launched

A new campaign is set to make a big difference in helping to reduce waste and provide more food security for our region.

I believe that current policies and practices regarding the management of shark populations is putting ocean goers lives at risk.

Those of us that choose to surf, swim and dive in the ocean are a stoic community – we’ve decided to accept the risk of a shark attack when in the ocean because it’s a habitat that belongs more to the shark than it does to us. However, the recent increased incidents of attacks is perhaps no longer a random event that is to be accepted along with our own mortality but a symptom of a larger man made imbalance in our oceans that is putting lives at risk.

There’s a strong logic to suggest that there’s a dangerous double standard being enforced by current laws that’s cause for an increased risk of shark attacks in Australian waters. The double standard I’m referring to is one that deems one species of marine organism to be more important than another. As a consequence of this mindset, marine food chains continue to be reduced in population by commercial fishing practices and in doing so diminish the natural prey and food supply for predator sharks. While this is occurring the protected status of large sharks maintain their numbers and create an imbalance in the predator / prey populations and as a consequence, an increasingly desperate predator that is forced to target humans that are not its natural prey.

I believe that the only fair and safe practice is to either ‘protect all species or protect none at all’. This would involve either protecting all marine creatures and putting an end to the commercial fishing of wild life to allow a natural food chain to re-establish or we alternatively, introduce a policy that allows for the carefully regulated controlled culling of large dangerous sized sharks that are big enough to pose a threat to humans and are found to be frequently visiting our beaches. I believe these measures are necessary to correct a man made unnatural imbalance that is being created in our oceans.

As an aside to this issue, at the very least we need an immediate response to shark attack incidents. I believe it is an application of simple common sense to lobby for a policy that allows for the immediate destruction of a large shark that is found to be in close proximity to and likely responsible for an attack. This is an important alternative to merely herding away the animal from the scene using jet skis or tracking its departure from the area using aircraft as happened in recent serious attacks in the Byron / Ballina area. There is little argument to support that an entire species will be endangered by eradicating a single large dangerous animal – the removal of what could be a rogue animal would prevent the risk of further unnecessary fatalities.

I acknowledge there is divisive opinion on this issue and the one I’m sharing is only one perspective. Perhaps wider community consultation is required to achieve an outcome that reflects a broader opinion. However, I do believe that change is required to limit further injury and loss of life in the future.

Nick Mercer, East Ballina

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. The shark is the scavenger of the ocean, just as the hyena and the vulture cleans the land of blood and bones in Africa as Africa has a lot of animals.
    The ocean has a lot of fish life and many are sick and injured and dying.
    The shark cleans the ocean of these alive and kicking bodies. So please don’t kick in the ocean as the shark hears a splash many kilometres away and smells blood in the water up to 5kilometres away from where a fisherman may be cleaning his fish where it was caught. That blood is an impurity and must be devoured. If anyone has an open cut please cover it before entering the water or you could be giving the shark a hand and you my have to go to hospital.

  2. All good food for thought, but one aspect many seem not to consider is the overall increase in whale populations. These mighty humpbacks live for many years, and when one finally dies, it feeds dozens of hungry sharks for a week or more. But what do they feast on for the other 50 weeks of the year? The increase in whales could be artificially increasing the number of sharks in the short-term without providing long-term sustenance, thus pushing the sharks increasingly into our popular areas where marine sanctuaries are providing an abundance of natural prey.. and more limbs in water. Short answer, don’t make yourself look like a dead turtle.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

A win for the roughy

The battle for the 'roughy had been a tough road for conservationists and hopefully this win will be the last fight.

Maybe Canberra needs a bit of distraction biff

Mick breathed in but his Cronulla Sharks football jersey struggled to contain his well-insulated six-pack and he held up his hand as he approached Bazza in the front bar of the Top Pub.

Council crews working hard to repair potholes

Tweed Shire Council road maintenance crews are out across the Tweed's road network repairing potholes and other damage caused by the recent prolonged rainfall and previous flood events.

Poor Pauline

Bob Vinnicombe, Sefton A lot of hypocrisy from Labor and The Greens about respect for women. Look at the treatment they dished out to Pauline...