Could residents have caused Tallow Creek fish kill?

Stingray caught in sudden lowering of Tallow Creek estuary, later seen dead. Photo Dailan Pugh

Stingray caught in sudden lowering of Tallow Creek estuary, later seen dead. Photo Dailan Pugh

Chris Dobney

Byron Shire Council says it is ‘possible’ that the opening of Tallow Creek on Wednesday night (November 22), which resulted in a massive fish kill, might have been a natural occurrence. But an ecologist who visits the site regularly doesn’t think so.

Several homes that back onto Tallow Creek experience backyard flooding when the creek level rises beyond a certain point.

A council spokesperson said in a media release on Friday (November 24) that in recent weeks the water levels in the creek estuary, which is intermittently closed and open, had been rising and ‘residents had been asking the council to open it to the ocean’.

But because the level had been hovering below that at which the council is licensed to open it, officers had instead been keeping a watching brief.

It’s claimed some residents took it upon themselves to open the estuary, resulting in a dramatic outflow of water and a drop of the water level by more than a metre.

Fish were stranded, flapping about on dry land or in deoxygenated water from upstream, leading to almost the entire population of fish in the creek being killed, according to ecologist Dailan Pugh, who visits the creek regularly.

Opened at midnight

The disaster that followed the illegal opening of Tallow Creek estuary. Photos Dailan Pugh

Mr Pugh told Echonetdaily that people had been trying to open the Tallow Creek estuary ‘for the past two weeks,’ adding, ‘their efforts bore fruit late on Wednesday night’.

‘The data for Tallow Creek (at the bridge) show the opening starting at midnight,’ he said.

A regular visitor to Byron, Falco, who visited the estuary for a swim around midday Thursday told Echonetdaily he found water ‘rushing like a river incredibly fast’ into the sea.

‘The water was brown and churned up and sand was caving in around the edges.

‘It was nothing like the placid lake I remember,’ said Falco, adding a council staffer on the scene told him neighbours had dug a trench ‘because water was running into their backyards’.

Disaster unfolds

Mr Pugh said that by sunset ‘the developing disaster was apparent’.

His earlier comments about the declining state of the estuary over Thursday can be found here.

He said that by Friday afternoon the NPWS had cleaned up the thousands of dead fish around the mouth of the estuary, ‘and by Saturday morning they had been replaced by thousands more’.

‘The fish kill now appears to be complete,’ he told Echonetdaily on Saturday, ‘with little signs of life left in the estuary.

‘There are no longer a multitude of fish gasping for breath around the edges of the estuary as they all appear to have died. A solitary mud crab has taken to the shore, apparently the water was even too toxic for it. A few live fish survive in the outflow channel.

‘Many thousands of fish have been killed, and the countless multitudes of fingerlings gone’ he said.

‘It is a complete ecological disaster. The estuary will need to start from scratch to rebuild its ecosystem.

‘This is the price for reducing flooding of a few people’s gardens that were planted in the estuary’s wetlands.’

Mr Pugh said there needed to be an emergency response protocol in place in ‘for next time people initiate a fish kill’.

‘We need to know what action, if any, we can take to reduce the slaughter.

‘In the meantime there needs to be a concerted effort to find those responsible and bring them to justice, to stop them doing it again.’

How fish kill happened

Byron Shire Council’s flood and drainage engineer, James Flockton, said the fish kill was the result of the dramatic drop in the level of the estuary combined with deoxygenated swamp water flowing into it from upstream.

‘In this case the fast flow of water out of the creek quickly removed the oxygenated water from the system and appears to have caused the fish kill,’ he said.

‘Water with low oxygen levels is often called “black water” and is a common cause of fish kills.

‘Council has engaged Australian Wetlands Consulting to conduct water sampling in Tallow Creek over the next six days and staff will also be downloading water quality data at the footbridge to better understand how the water quality changed during the opening process.’

Anyone with information on how the estuary came to be opened is urged to contact Mr Flockton on (02) 6626 7300 or the Cape Byron office of the National Parks and Wildlife Service.

5 responses to “Could residents have caused Tallow Creek fish kill?”

  1. Gareth Smith says:

    Thank you Dailan Pugh for your consistent and long-standing work to preserve our fragile environment. Your detective work in identifying the cause of this massive fish kill should result in the prosecution of all those responsible for the illegal opening of the estuary.

  2. Len Heggarty says:

    There has been a massive fish kill at Tallow Creek and no one is sure what caused it. Sounds a bit fishy?
    This is a case for Ghostbusters.

  3. Josephine Beams says:

    Thank you again Dailan for being so diligent. These people are obviously ignorant and badly need educating in “the Old Ways”. From what I recall of the teachings of my Auntie this was traditional fishing grounds.
    Greed , Ignorance and short sight are problems. We could really so with much more education and greater respect and protection of this fragile area.May this disaster be a lesson to all in how better to care for this beautiful paradise. Thank you once again for all that you do.

  4. Paul Tischler says:

    It’s obvious residents caused the opening of Tallow creek, and probably fairly recent residents as well, who don’t appreciate the value of the wetland environment for fish reproduction and habitat.

    It should be pretty simple to see who would benefit fro the opening and investigate them further.

    They will probably be besieged by vastly more mosquito attacks in this summer period as the predators of the mosquito larvae (the fish that died senselessly) are not around to curtail the burgeoning hatchings in the creek.
    Personally I hope this Karma will be intense!

  5. Bob Smith says:

    Looks like Byron Bay has been infiltrated by imbeciles. How sad. But it isn’t just Byron Bay. Take a drive out into the western hinterland and see how our forests are big devastated by private logging contractors. Erosion and land degradation seems to be the Nationals and Liberals stock in trade. How is it the Premier State is in the hands of premier idiots?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Become a supporter of The Echo

A note from the editorial team

Some of The Echo’s editorial team: journalists Paul Bibby and Aslan Shand, editor Hans Lovejoy, photographer Jeff Dawson and Mandy Nolan

The Echo has never underestimated the intelligence and passion of its readers. In a world of corporate banality and predictability, The Echo has worked hard for more than 30 years to help keep Byron and the north coast unique with quality local journalism and creative ideas. We think this area needs more voices, reasoned analysis and ideas than just those provided by News Corp, lifestyle mags, Facebook groups and corporate newsletters.

The Echo is one hundred per cent locally owned and one hundred per cent independent. As you have probably gathered from what is happening in the media industry, it is not cheap to produce a weekly newspaper and a daily online news service of any quality.

We have always relied entirely on advertising to fund our operations, but often loyal readers who value our local, independent journalism have asked how they could help ensure our survival.

Any support you can provide to The Echo will make an enormous difference. You can make a one-off contribution or a monthly one. With your help, we can continue to support a better informed local community and a healthier democracy for another 30 years.”

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers and is brought to you by this week's sponsors Vast Furniture & Homewares Ballina and Falls Festival Byron Bay.