21.7 C
Byron Shire
January 26, 2022

Thus Spake Mungo: ScoMo’s medium is his massage

Latest News

Byron Shire 2022 Citizen of the Year

Jacqui Boyett, founder of the not-for-profit Global Ripple charity and op shop, is the Byron Shire 2022 Citizen of the Year.

Other News

First Byron Shire Council meeting postponed

Byron Shire Council’s first meeting of newly minted councillors was to take place today, 20 January, however, the storm of COVID-19 that is taking place across the country led to it being postponed.

COVID strategy

Our PM and premier have decided to fall back on the old ‘Dunkirk Strategy’: Retreat, withdraw and claim a...

Sneaky Eats

Sandra Haslam There are times when the fullness of living life squeezes our ability to create our own nutritious and...

Greens Mandy Nolan to hold community forum in support of nurses and paramedics

Locally and across the state nurses, and paramedics are struggling in the face of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic as they are being asked to do double shifts and manage effectively in health system that is struggling to cope. This has led to an increasing number of nurses and paramedics resigning.

The Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha’apai eruption: what comes next?

The powerful volcanic eruption was captured in amazing detail, yet remains shrouded in mystery. The eruption of the Hunga Tonga-Hunga...

Lennox Head forge ahead across four grades in local cricket

Local cricket is approaching the midway point of the 2021–22 season and sees Lennox Head playing strongly across all four senior grades.

Scott Morrison nursing his much-loved lump of coal. Photo Green Left

We are now more than six weeks into the ScoMo regime, but most of us – and that includes some of our most recent Prime Minister’s close colleagues as well as a tentative opposition – are still trying to figure out just who the man really is trying to be.

Admirers have suggested the down-to-earth, supreme ordinariness of John Howard is the revamped model; others go back to the paternal style of Bob Menzies, or perhaps the easy familiarity of Ben Chifley. Those of a more historical bent invoke the avuncular ghost of Joe Lyons.

I could almost hear the corrupt old peanut farmer mouthing his mantra ‘Don’t you worry about that’ as Morrison deftly avoided the subject with a homily on the need for lower electricity prices.

But last week, when I heard Morrison answer questions about the IPCC report warning of imminent disaster if climate change was not addressed, the reality dawned: our leader is channelling Joh Bjelke-Petersen.

I could almost hear the corrupt old peanut farmer mouthing his mantra ‘Don’t you worry about that’ as Morrison deftly avoided the subject with a homily on the need for lower electricity prices. And the chooks having been fed, he moved on something more important – how Bill Shorten was going to raise taxes on absolutely everything in his manic desire to wreck the Australian economy.

Morrison’s shtick is smoother and less demented than that of the hillbilly dictator – he is, after all, a professional, having honed his craft in both the Tourist Commission and the New South Wales Liberal Party, both organisations which required constant cosseting. But once again the medium is the massage.

Morrison’s easy rejection of the science rests easily in his party room, although there are signs that some of the Nationals are getting the word from their rural constituents that the current policy of complacent negligence is no longer completely appropriate – it may be a wild idea, but what if climate change is real?

Don’t worry, be happy. Forget about those distinguished international scientists – UnAustralian almost all of them, by definition. We are an independent, sovereign nation: we will decide how much carbon we emit, and the circumstances in which we emit it. Stop the world, we want to get off.

Morrison’s easy rejection of the science rests easily in his party room, although there are signs that some of the Nationals are getting the word from their rural constituents that the current policy of complacent negligence is no longer completely appropriate – it may be a wild idea, but what if climate change is real? What if it is actually happening as we watch our traditional livelihood drift away in drought, fire and dust storm?

Morrison’s glib answer is, don’t you worry about that: pray for rain and if that doesn’t work we’ll send you more money – not to fix the problem,  but to keep you hanging on until something else turns up. His close ally Craig Kelly has an even better idea: mine more coal, because you can use it to make electricity to pay for air conditioning when the rising temperatures become unbearable.

Of course burning the coal will produce more emissions, which will make the planet hotter, so we will have to mine more coal for more electricity for more air conditioning, a perpetual cycle which keeps everybody happy, don’t you worry about that.

Okay, these are politicians, we can’t expect them to be logical, straightforward or even rational. But surely the expert commentators can be relied on? Come in The Australian’s Judith Sloan, who wiped out the entire scientific establishment with the devastating put down: ‘Scientists make appalling economists’.

Well some might; after all, economics is hardly their day job. But it might be added that some economists don’t make the grade as scientists either. Sloan correctly cites the scientific method: start with a credible hypothesis and then test it with evidence. But unfortunately, she seldom practises what she preaches.

She has constantly insisted that company tax cuts benefit for the whole economy – that what is popularly called the trickle-down effect means that eventually the workers get some of the dosh as well as the employers and shareholders. This, as Malcolm Turnbull liked to declare, is Economics101 And indeed it used to be – solid theory based on the laws of supply and demand.

But recent evidence clearly shows that it hasn’t worked lately: big corporate tax cuts in Britain, Canada and even the United States have been squirrelled away in share buy-backs, in increased profits, in executive bonuses. Where there has been something for the workers, it has often been in the form of a one-off payment, an act of charity with no long-term advantage.

Sloan’s claims to the contrary have more to do with ideology than science – or even to economics. This is even more apparent in her endless campaign against industry superannuation funds … because they have union leaders among their directors. They also have employers in the same role, but that is apparently okay: the unionists must be expunged because – well, because they are unionists. This will free up the distortions of the system and give members an immediate bonanza.

Except that it won’t, because it doesn’t: most of the industry funds consistently and regularly produce bigger returns to their members than do their retail rivals. But why let the facts spoil a good polemic?

Sloan argues that the hypotheses and models developed over many years of research on climate change have not always led up to their predictions, which is true: but it does not mean they have been useless or misguided. Global warming is now generally accepted even by most of the sceptics: it is patchier than might be expected, but the base temperature is going up and will go up further.

And while some of the doomsday scenarios have been premature, the trend is clear: it is too late to stop a rise of 1.5 degrees, and 2 is more likely. There will be severe consequences, both foreseeable and unforeseen. Sloan calls this astrology: but it is far more reliable than most of the predictions proclaimed by her and her fellow economists. Even the federal Treasury seldom gets it right – think debt and deficit prognostications.

I used to say that examining the entrails of a chicken made as much sense as listening to economists – more, in fact because you can eat the chicken afterwards. But the economists and the politicians have their own agendas. The Energy Minister, Angus Taylor, said climate change has nothing to do with his portfolio, which is to flog more coal. And the so-called Environment Minister, Melissa Price, said she hadn’t got around to reading the IPCC report, but it didn’t really matter – it was a long bow to suggest getting rid of coal so there was no point in going into the details. The environment will just have to look after itself. Don’t you worry about that.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

12 COMMENTS

  1. You noticed that Mungo, that he needs some acting lessons as he tries to be one of us: “I’m on your side” he said pointing at us down the camera lans.

  2. Even if, dare I say it, climate change is not related to fossil fuels, polution water usage black lung disease air pollution etc etc and massive scale scarring of the planet is enough reason to move to renewables and cleaner energy Asap

  3. Economics was once the Science of Efficiency, investigating the ratio of desired output to the total input of any system. Now it is just another religion.

  4. I would cite John Howard’s injunction to be “relaxed and comfortable” as evidence that he’s not only channelling Joh.

  5. ScoMo & Joh & The Truth Fairy: Written under duress

    Those who would,
    Can’t.
    Those who won’t
    Will always
    Will it elsewhere…

    There’s a name
    For it.

  6. Really. Even if the 100 year weather forcasters are right, the question is still if we have an alternative. Forget windmills. Solar technology is smart tech but unpredictable, and now dependant on Chinese slave labour. Does anybody really want to tell us the truth, how many of these farms we need to replace fossil fuels, and then the battery complexes, and then with electric cars thrown in? And the plain stupid question, why destroy an existing infrastructure? Or how much industry will be involved in recycling all this, or how much land will need be put aside? And then consider countries like India, China, the US, where the answers have to be multiplied by 20 or 50. Nothing comes for free. Except wrong advice.

  7. As robots are lemmings
    Then pigs will fly…
    If facts become nonsense
    Then all the children will die.
    Is there a calysivirus for robots?

  8. Mango, you didn’t mention where the report was tabled, Sth Korea, and next up Poland. The IPCC mob reallly gets around: Geneva, Tokyo, Rio, Kyoto, Paris… jumbos use ten times more oil for their fuel than anything else, except spacecraft. And we’re talking officials delegates staff, NGOers, press. Three milluon cigarettes of carbon dioxide in one minute of taking off. Canoes would be lesss hypocritical. And when it comes to solar panels, what about bird poop and dust. What lucky robot has to clean them every day for maximum efficiency?

  9. The best way to lower electricity prices is to put panels on your roof then to really emphasise your disgust buy a battery and tell Morrison to stick his lump of coal where sun dont shine

  10. Dear Mungo, next we’ll see ScoMo calling for
    a ‘State of Emergency’ in all states to keep us
    in line. Was the ban ever lifted in QLD?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Man charged following pursuit – Far North Coast

A man has been charged with driving offences following a police pursuit in the state’s far north.

More government support needed for nurses

What would it take to keep our nurses and paramedics from resigning en masse as the current crisis in the NSW health care system worsens?

Aboriginal Tent Embassy 1972–2022 – the power of patience

The Aboriginal Tent Embassy was established on the lawns opposite Old Parliament House on 26 January 1972. Four First Nations men sat beneath a beach umbrella protesting the government’s attitude towards Indigenous land rights.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Listening to the truth tellers

A long time ago my husband had to attend a meeting in Redfern. He works in the health and academic sector and it was a consultation with some First Nations clinicians and community workers. He arrived a little earlier for the meeting to the centre – not your typical clinical setting but a regular house. On arrival he was greeted by an older woman who led him to a table and offered him a cup of tea. They chatted. Had a laugh. She offered him a biscuit.