18.9 C
Byron Shire
May 19, 2021

Is turning up dead the only way to get a voice?

Latest News

Police appeal for help to find missing teenagers

Police are appealing for public assistance to help locate the boy and a girl who were last seen in Alstonville on Monday.

Other News

Byron Farmers Market 

Return to Butler St Reserve hits a snag Byron Farmers Market moved from its home at Butler Street Reserve to...

Independent councillor to represent Byron’s water security

Mia Armitage Independent Byron Shire Councillor Cate Coorey says she’s excited to have won the council’s vote for a new...

How to exercise more voting rights in council elections

Being a property owner in NSW isn’t just a financial advantage, it also means you have more rights to vote than non-property owners.

MAYDAY – MAYDAY – One hundred years ago today

One hundred years ago this week, around noon on Saturday 14 May 1921, the 2,000 tonne steamship Wollongbar ran aground on Belongil beach.

Locals question placing homes in areas of inundation risk

It is where the community fought off Club Med and it is once again in the spotlight as the current owners, Elements, are seeking to have the zoning of the environmentally sensitive area in Bayshore Drive changed from tourism to residential

Development of the Belongil Spit

Jo Faith, Newtown I was gobsmacked when I read that the ‘Greens’ mayor’s parting gift was to aid privatisation of land...

Some of the fish that washed up on the banks of Belongil Creek last week. Photo Reid Waters

Duncan Dey

Byron Shire Council (BSC) staff used the phrase ‘natural event’ to describe the recent fish kill that saw thousands of fish die in Belongil Creek. How natural was it?

Belongil Estuary is an ICOLL (intermittently closing and opening lake or lagoon) that opens across a beach into the ocean. When catchment flow is low, the entrance closes.

When the entrance is closed the beach builds up, raising water levels in the estuary all the way back south of the Ewingsdale Road bridge. When levels there reach 1m AHD (just above high tide) council has permission to dig a channel through the sand berm of the beach and break the water out. As it flows, it washes a deeper cut in the berm and empties the estuary.

The community who benefit from the artificially lowered water levels includes farmers and residents who may otherwise be flooded in these extensive very low-lying areas of the catchment.

The community harmed by artificial openings are aquatic and can’t lobby except by turning their bellies up in death. We need to listen to them and to rethink the opening strategy.

Time to re-think

Luckily, Byron Council is doing that right now and should have a draft Belongil Entrance Opening Strategy on public exhibition this year.

Not only is the estuary interfered with by artificial opening, but the catchment has been interfered with by clearing, by having huge areas made impervious to water, and by its floodplain being criss-crossed with channels which drain those flat low-lying areas.

The areas that were historically drained to facilitate farming and grazing of cattle would otherwise have remained wet for long periods and therefore unusable for pasture.

Some of the layers of soil in those low areas are Acid Sulphate (AS) soils.

Acid Sulphate soils are innocuous when permanently wet – as they were for thousands of years – but become highly acidic when dried out (especially when drying is for the first time in geological history).

These days they are dried out in long hot summer periods due to the artificially low water table. A subsequent first flush of rain brings acid runoff into the estuary, along with decomposing organic material that strips the water of its oxygen.

First question

Investigation of the recent fish kill needs to ask first whether an acid or low oxygen event occurred.

If the fish were killed only by ‘iron bacteria’ as stated by BSC, this was an unusual event.

Either way, we also need to reconsider whether flushing huge volumes out of the estuary for our convenience and leaving the fish with far less water depth in which to survive is ‘best practice’.

Let’s keep an eye out for the draft Opening Strategy and ask for it to be made as fish-friendly as possible.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Duncan here.
    I was down at the local creek, Bilongil, dunking a line in to see what would bite
    and I was reading the Byron Echo. Two gram sinkers with trace and hooks were number 2 Suicide with prawn bait when something caught my eye. Byron Shire Council described the recent fish kill as a “natural event”. Thousands of fish died.
    How natural is that in one day?

  2. The immediate cause of the fish kill in the most recent instance was that Council opened the mouth of the estuary when there were no inflows of fresh oxygenated water. It is a shame that Council has muddied the waters by trying to blame other causes. Though Duncan is right about the bigger issues. I have been waiting since Council lowered the trigger for the estuary opening from 1.2m to 1.0m in 2000, thereby increasing drainage of the wetlands and Acid Sulfate Soils, for them to meet their legal obligations to assess the environmental implications of this change. The Belongil Estuary Opening Strategy is long overdue.

  3. How many years of local Greens rule? And still our beloved estuary with all it’s amazing wildlife continues down the toilet.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Keith Duncan, Pimlico Thank God this corruption-riddled Berejiklian/Barilaro government does not have a majority in the NSW upper house. Environmentalists in NSW have just breathed...

Man jailed over South Golden Beach dog shooting

A local builder who shot his neighbour’s dog with a bow and arrow in South Golden Beach has been jailed after unsuccessfully appealing his conviction in the District Court.

Greens MP calls for greater workplace safety in government

Mia Armitage Greens Member for Ballina Tamara Smith has joined calls for improved workplace safety in government after accusations against a Byron Shire resident of...

Angsts, hopes and visions

Jo Faith, Newtown I love The Echo and all of the folk that passionately contribute their angsts, hopes and visions. How do The (struggling) Echo...