Menu

Is it time to go nuclear?

The announcement by National Party leader John Barilaro last week that his party would support the development of nuclear power in NSW came as a surprise to many considering the long lead times for nuclear power development and the abundance of solar and wind power that is ready to be quickly developed.

One Nation’s Mark Latham brought the Uranium Mining and Nuclear Facilities (Prohibitions) Repeal Bill 2019 to parliamentary debate on June 6, 2019 and it’s now working its way towards a vote.

However, local Lismore MP Janelle Saffin has urged North Coast residents to help her kill off the Nationals’ plans to build nuclear power plants in places like Tweed Heads and Coffs Harbour with the same determination shown to defeat Coal Seam Gas (CSG) mining.

Ballina Greens MP Tamara Smith points out that ‘While Europe is rapidly phasing out nuclear energy the dinosaurs in the National Party in NSW want to lift the ban and distract us all in an anti-nuclear debate’.

‘The coal barons and their favourite political party are counting on us to repeat the same mistake we made with climate change. We battled to convince the dinosaurs of climate science that was well and truly settled and we lost the war on vested interests in fossil fuel for over a decade.’

Ms Saffin said Mr Barilaro had announced his nuclear policy support on the run on Sky News, blindsiding Premier Berejeklian, who during Question Time on Wednesday (March 4) could not state her government’s true position on nuclear power.

Ms Saffin accused Deputy Premier and Nationals leader John Barilaro of dangerous behaviour in supporting One Nation Leader Mark Latham’s bill in the Upper House lifting the ban on uranium mining and nuclear energy in New South Wales.

‘By joining forces with Mark Latham, and his former visit overseas to gather information and support for his nuclear cause, John Barilaro has well and truly opened the door to nuclear power plants in coastal communities on the North Coast.

‘The Nats are embracing nuclear power – they keep marching us backwards and have no plans for water protection, no plans for cheap energy that they bang on about, and no plans for country New South Wales,’ she said.

Local National MP responds

Member for Tweed Geoff Provest has responded to questions from Echonetdaily stating that, ‘I have previously stated I am against nuclear power in the Tweed and I have heard nothing during this most recent discussion to change my mind.’

Member for Page, Kevin Hogan (Nationals) and National Party MLC, Ben Franklin have not responded to questions regarding their support for nuclear power development.

Federal investigation

Last year the Federal government House of Reps held an inquiry into the pre-requisites for nuclear power in Australia.

‘The release of the report has clearly been done in such a way as to attract the absolute minimum of attention. Its media profile up to now has been zero. That is likely because were it better known, it would have been panned by NGOs Australia-wide,’ said long time anti-nuclear campaigner John Hallam.

‘It’s clear from the recent Federal inquiry, that there is no case whatsoever for a pronuclear about-face in favour of reactors or uranium mining in NSW,’ he said.

‘Ten years ago, the argument would have been that nuclear power was/is uneconomic and potentially dangerous, and that it is uneconomic precisely because it is potentially dangerous. The argument now would be exactly the same, with the added one that in order to be of any relevance to combatting the climate emergency, a source of power must be cheap, problem-free and quickly and easily deployable and nuclear power is the opposite of all those things.

Nuclear power, far from solving the climate emergency, diverts needed resources from the real solutions – the deployment of cheap and quickly deployable renewables.

‘Small modular reactors look wonderful on paper but no one has actually succeeded in building even one that works satisfactorily and can be mass-produced, let alone the hundreds that would be needed.’

Local Greens MP Tamara Smith told Echonetdaily that her party requested to be included on the committee looking into nuclear but were ignored. Committee members include two Liberal party MPs, two Labor MPs, a One Nation MP, a Shooters Fishers and Farmers MP and a Nationals MP.

 


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


6 responses to “Is it time to go nuclear?”

  1. Many like me have been following the nuclear
    rubbish question for years. It’s insane to even
    think on it. Those foolish enough to think they
    know – i.e. ‘what Europe’s getting rid of’ – are
    nut case Nationals. Nuclear in Oz? Not on my
    shift. Get Nuked!

  2. Bruce McQueen says:

    There could be an upside to this insanity, though. Nuclear power plants must be built on solid, stable ground; near a plentiful supply of water for cooling; elevated enough to avoid tsunamis (Fukashima); and close to essential services in case of accidents. Obviously, then, the perfect location for a nuclear plant is Point Piper in Sydney.
    All Barilaro and Latham need to do to realise their nuclear wet dream is evict the billionaires and put compulsory acquisition orders on their mansions. Get to it boys!

  3. Ginga says:

    Thanks Mungo. I’m not saying anything. Will too esoteric & we don’t like ‘esoteria’ here. Suffice to say it’s what the universe & multi-v’s & multi-d’s are made of.. so will say ancient ancient history.. on its way to being a ground hog day moment.. except we can swap ‘earths’ briefly & by pass this whole bloody non-sense. It’s just exhausting.. bloody human non sense! Time for a different dance!

    Good to see you are focussed. Not distracted by the ‘loo affair’! Think that’s what they’re hoping for. Under the rug!

    Well written piece mate! Appreciate it!

    Love & blessings

  4. Ginga says:

    What do you call those things.. hydras.. they just keep growing more bloody heads.. give them a bowl of milk….

    Love & blessings

  5. Jeremy White says:

    John Hallam pretty well summed it up to a t. And let’s add FUKISHIMA! It will never happen in my opinion. The finance won’t be there. It’s way way too expensive and slow to build. Mixed renewables are the way forward especially with hydrogen coming into the renewables mix.

  6. Nigel Miles says:

    If you spend just half an hour reading about the new Hinkley Point C nuclear power station currently being built in the UK, you’ll soon realise what a shameful waste of money it is and how the British public will be on the hook for 60 years of overpriced nuclear power as the UK Government has locked them into a contract to buy power from Hinkley Point C (run by a French and Chinese consortium) at a price which is already – in 2020 – above the cost of wind and solar.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers.