11.5 C
Byron Shire
May 23, 2024

Planet Watch – Roadblocks to renewables

Latest News

Police appeal again to locate man missing from Mullumbimby

Police are again appealing for public assistance to locate Gage Wilson, a man missing from Mullumbimby, since Saturday, 18 May.

Other News

He’s off, has been for years! And what’s a conspiracy amongst friends?

After ten years in Mullum I’ve relocated to the middle of an extinct volcano in Murwillumbah.

Terania Street to get ‘calming’ roadworks

Repair work on Lismore’s Terania Street is to start soon, in time for it reopen end of June, after an overweight vehicle hit the over-rail-road bridge earlier this year.

Bimbo Jimbo

For Treasurer Jim Chalmers to say that it was ‘simpler’ to just give everyone the energy rebate of $75...

Feudalism alive

The increasingly restrictive parking at New Brighton shows feudalism is alive and well. It is understandable – wanting to protect...

Angels Beach Drive, East Ballina temporarily closed today

Angels Beach Drive, East Ballina has been temporarily closed due to a broken water main just north of Prospect Bridge.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Why are we so blasé about violent pornography?

Why is it a turn on to hurt us? Recent intersectional studies have shown that online misogyny and violent pornography are contributors to a sharp rise in domestic violence. In NSW alone, police attend 500 incidents every day. If there were 500 threats or incidents at banks, or to the government, we would be in a state of emergency. Instead we stop, shake our heads, we listen to good men in government speak empty words, make a few promises, and move on. If you’ve ever lived through violence, it’s pretty well what your abuser does after hitting you.

This article is made possible by the support of Byron Eco Park Holdings.

Renewable jobs threatened by lack of government support. Image David Lowe.

David Lowe

The Australian political response to the COVID-19 pandemic has proved that governments can act quickly if conditions demand it, even if that means overturning longstanding ideological obstacles.

The relative costs of action versus inaction seem to be much better understood when it comes to this coronavirus than with choices about energy sources, although the stakes are even higher. Can we walk away from fossil fuels before we follow the dinosaurs into extinction?

Political football

In recent decades, federal renewables policy has trailed in the wake of energy policy, which has become a dangerous political football. It wasn’t always like this.

In 2001 John Howard’s government introduced a modest Mandatory Renewable Energy Target (MRET) equivalent to about five per cent of all energy used in Australia. Incentives put in place by Kevin Rudd helped domestic solar uptake, and utility scale renewable energy targets continued to increase until Tony Abbott threw a spanner in the works with the Warburton Review of 2014, which led to the LRET (Large-scale Renewable Energy Target) going backwards in 2015.

Soon after, the Clean Energy Finance Corporation was ordered to stop investing in wind projects (the industry was supposedly too ‘mature’ to need help).

Scott Morrison nursing his much-loved lump of coal. Photo Green Left

Things slipped further when Treasurer Scott Morrison brought a lacquered lump of coal into parliament at the behest of the Minerals Council in 2017.

As the technology of renewable energy quickly progressed, it was left to the states and territories to find a way forward politically.

In NSW there were positive noises from the premier and her energy minister about renewables and energy efficiency before the last state election, but little action since, amid reports of private solar and wind operations collapsing in the absence of support from policymakers.

The energy deal struck between the Morrison and Berejiklian governments earlier this year turned out to be mostly about propping up coal and unconventional gas, with vague promises of hydrogen research and pumped-storage hydro in the footnotes.

States taking the initiative

Victoria, by contrast, is well on track to meets its 25 per cent renewables target for this year, and has a 50 per cent target for 2030. Of course that’s about a century in politics.

In 2019 the ACT achieved 100 per cent renewable electricity, with a mix of locally generated and imported green power. Tasmania will soon also be 100 per cent renewable. With its long history of government-subsidised hydro schemes, the island state exports power via BassLink. New wind supply is coming online, and the Gutwein government also plans to export green hydrogen.

South Australia’s forward thinking renewables policies have been falsely blamed for power outages but miraculously survived the last change of government from Labor to Liberal. Their wind-supported Tesla big battery, mocked by Scott Morrison, continues to prop up the interstate grid, return profits and spawn imitators. Geothermal energy also looks very promising for the state.

A solar thermal plant similar to the one that was going to be built near Port Augusta but has since been cancelled.

Unfortunately the massive solar thermal project planned for Port Augusta has fallen over, with stakeholders blaming each other and interstate political interference.

In the absence of meaningful signals from government, Western Australia is falling further behind in the renewables race. The only bright spots are some remote settlements and mines switching to renewables, and the Perth Wave Energy Project.

Queensland, despite its massive natural advantages, remains a laggard in terms of government renewables policy due to the distorting influence of coal on its politics. Private solar farm operators continue to struggle to survive on the margins. More positively, two major renewable hydrogen and ammonia production projects are planned for the heart of Queensland’s coal and gas country, and big batteries are being constructed elsewhere in the state with government blessing.

In the Northern Territory, unsustainable gas has compromised the energy discussion in recent years, but there has also been serious political support for the $20bn SunCable project, which will sell green power to Singapore. Hydrogen represents another major renewable energy export opportunity for the NT.

Sunset for new wind projects?

Unsustainable energy solutions

Despite current federal energy minister Angus Taylor’s claim to have ‘renewables in his blood’ (he has a family link with the Snowy scheme, and is allowing Malcolm Turnbull’s Snowy 2.0 to limp on), in practice he has been a loyal advocate for fossil fuels since taking over the portfolio, like most of the other people surrounding the Prime Minister.

Scott Morrison’s Chief Scientist Dr Alan Finkel is an advocate of nuclear energy, as well as unsustainable gas and hydrogen, making no clear distinction in his public statements about the difference between green, renewable hydrogen and its emission-intense variants. He insists that unproven carbon capture and storage technology can solve emission problems.

Of course there’s no such thing as completely green energy either. Wind farms use a lot of steel; copper and lithium need to be mined; solar panels are difficult to recycle; biomass power plants burn trees as well as sugar waste; dams destroy country, and batteries continue to rely on unsustainable and unethical supply chains. But some forms of energy are definitely less destructive than others.

The good news is that despite the profusion of electronic devices, and a growing population, Australians are using less non-renewable energy than they did in the past.

Ridiculously high prices for electricity and global warming concerns have led people to think more about what they turn on and when, while also taking control of their own power, house by house, via techniques ranging from old-fashioned economising to smart meters to e-transport to going completely off the grid.

Community energy retailers like Enova are also doing very well. Despite the mixed signals from politicians, Australians are paying a lot more attention to where their energy is coming from, and voting with their dollars.

Beyond the domestic transformation, Australia’s natural resources and national grid means that with some creative engineering, vision and capital, our country is poised to become a renewable energy superpower, replacing dirty coal and gas exports with something much more positive.

If our government is unable to get off its fossil fuel addiction and assist this process, the least it can do for the economy and climate is get out of the way.

David Lowe
David Lowe – photo Tree Faerie

Originally from Canberra, David Lowe is an award-winning film-maker, writer and photographer with particular interests in the environment and technology. He’s known for his work with Cloudcatcher Media as a campaigner against unconventional gas and coal. David has also written Australian history. Many years ago, he did work experience in Parliament House with Mungo MacCallum. David has lived off-grid in the Northern Rivers since 2008.

More Planet Watch articles

Will Morrison’s gas-led recovery delete the IPCC’s belief we need climate...

Most Australians know the news, or have had firsthand experiences themselves, of two years of floods, fires, coastal erosion, and storms, both here and overseas. In fact Australia has warmed on average by 1.44 ± 0.24 °C since national records began in 1910.


‘Unprecedented’ but not unpredicted – we are now suffering from our...

As Australians head into another election season just as many parts of the east coast are recovering from ‘unprecedented’ flooding since February, and the national psyche is still reeling from the trauma of the ‘unprecedented’ Black Summer bushfires before that, it is critical now more than ever to vote according to your environmental conscience and fear for the future.


Ethical investing goes prudential

Ethical investing is the idea of using your money to make the world a better place rather than simply chasing the greatest financial return. It seeks to account for people and planet, not just profit. 


On track to three degrees of warming

Our planet has warmed by 1.1 degrees, on average, since the Industrial Revolution, and Australia has warmed by 1.4 degrees since 1910 when records of temperature measurements began.


What’s going on with gas?

David Lowe According to the prime minister, we’re in the midst of a ‘gas-led recovery’. Until about five minutes ago, the gas in question was methane (mostly found using unconventional techniques like fracking) but now he’s also talking about hydrogen,...


Is hydrogen part of a sustainable energy future?

There’s a lot to like about hydrogen. For starters, it’s abundant. Hydrogen can store excess renewable power. When liquified, it’s more energy intense than fossil alternatives. In a fuel cell, it can generate electricity. When it’s burned, the only by-product is water.


Human activity, climate change risk more pandemics

New research has revealed climate change, environmental degradation and human activity are creating a perfect storm for more deadly pandemics like COVID-19. Scientists from the University of Western Australia (UWA) say COVID-19 has highlighted the critical need to reduce human impacts...


Planet Watch: Environmentally sound building

Globally, buildings are responsible for a massive share of energy and material consumption. Sustainable building movements are trying to change this, some by going back to the past, and some by diving head-first into the future.


Planet Watch: Are humans the disease?

Humans have told a lot of stories about how awesome we are, but there's one emerging hypothesis that casts our species in a very anti-heroic light. In terms of the planet, are we behaving like a disease?


Planet Watch – Top three environmental issues

With so many environmental crises occurring, it’s hard to focus on just three issues to provide an update to Planet Watch readers – but here's our top three...


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Well David ,
    It is always nice to see the blindingly obvious rehashed , we all know what you say is largely correct. It is also just as obvious that the status quo is hugely proffitable for those who are selling Australia’s resources for the cost of digging it up and sending it off. I believe it is also obvious that they, and their pet politicians , do not want this to change.
    While it is not hard to see this country should be the most advanced and prosperous nation on Earth, it has been decided to use this nation firstly as a natural prison, and then as a bottomless resource mine for Europe and America with a contrived low paid workforce. As successive governments have destroyed the Unions, that in the seventies provided not only negotiating power ,but more importantly a voice in the democratic process of decision making, it is now only an election that provides any input from the public and then only on topics chosen by those making the most money out of the current system , or the foreign owned media mogul, with very a definite agenda of his own.
    The government’s ability to adopt a rational approach in the face of imminent disaster has been now demonstrated. Unfortunately I can’t see any government taking action on Global Warming until their destruction is immediate , and that will be too late !
    Cheers, G”)

  2. This personally well-heeled government’s over 3/4
    full of ‘bull’ & fossil fuel addicts. Eventually they’ll
    learn that time [as they know it] waits on no-one.
    What’s needed is another Eureka 2 moment.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Causes of death

There’s been a lot of talk about an epidemic of violence against women lately, including Dr Ray Moynihan’s article in the last Echo. I like...

Flood 2022

I congratulate Lismore’s Trinity College work experience student Bella Clay on her article (Echo, April 26), relating her family’s lived experience since the 2022...


The latest information supplied from Byron Shire’s Water and Recycling on future operational plans contains the term ‘renew’ numerous times. There is no clarification...

Terania Street to get ‘calming’ roadworks

Repair work on Lismore’s Terania Street is to start soon, in time for it reopen end of June, after an overweight vehicle hit the over-rail-road bridge earlier this year.