19.4 C
Byron Shire
December 5, 2021

Anderson Vs Council’s banning order: round one

Latest News

Cadwallader, Lyon and Krieg most likely new Far North Coast mayors

With most of the votes cast, and counting over until tomorrow, the New South Wales Electoral Commission stats would suggest that there are three clear winners of the mayoral contests in Ballina, Byron and Lismore Shires.

Other News

Liberal candidate for Tweed Council James Owen seeks ‘for better outcomes for our community’

James Owen is a Liberal Party candidate from Casuarina who has served on the Tweed Shire Council for five...


I wanted to give credit where it is due and thank the editor for the preferences article, which I...

New COVID exposure site on the Gold Coast

Queensland Health says that a public health alert is being issued for contact tracing locations on the Gold Coast.

Where is agriculture going in the Northern Rivers?

As the climate emergency bites, and the population grows, farmers are becoming more innovative than ever. The passion and imagination of the Northern Rivers agricultural sector makes this a place to watch.

Evidence-based claims on Dunoon Dam

Why is it that all I hear from the pro-dammers is: ‘Save Our Dam’, ‘Build the dam’ or some...

On the ground work assists evicted women 

We know the region has some of the highest rents, and highest housing costs in Australia. We all know that this has virtually eliminated affordable housing. We hear the stories of women and children being evicted, of couch surfing and living in cars.

Christ Buck$ blesses Council as he joins the flock. Photo Jeff ‘Shepherd’ Dawson

By David Heilpern

Mayoral candidate John Anderson’s attempt to overturn Council’s banning order in the Land and Environment Court (LEC) in Sydney last Friday failed in its first round. Both parties employed Senior Counsels for the hearing.

In May 2021, police took out AVO against Anderson (also known as Fast Buck$), and charged him with intimidation. The alleged victim and person in need of protection is Greens Council candidate and current councillor, Sarah Ndaiye. 

He has since been charged with breaching that AVO, and those three matters are meandering their way through the criminal law system with a hearing set for next year. The immediate catalyst for the charges and AVO was Anderson’s conduct at a Council meeting earlier this year.

Separate to the criminal proceedings, councillors unanimously passed a motion directing the General Manager to ensure Anderson was forbidden from attending, and the General Manager issued a banning notice. The ultimate challenge to that notice is working its way through the LEC.

In Friday’s preliminary skirmish, Anderson was seeking interim orders lifting the banning direction, despite the fact that the matter is not due to be heard until well into next year. This means that Anderson bore the onus of satisfying the court that there was a serious issue to be tried, and that the “balance of convenience” favoured lifting the prohibition from attending meetings in the meantime.

There was agreement all round that there was a serious issue to be tried. This is because section 10 of the Local Government Act provides that council meetings shall be open to the public, and that “everyone is entitled to attend”. But there are exceptions, such as expulsion, and there is other relevant legislation in favour of Council, including the Inclosed Lands Protection Act, the AVO legislation and work health and safety provisions. No doubt those issues will be fleshed out in exquisite detail in the final hearing.

However, Anderson faltered on the balance of convenience test, where Justice Nicola Pain accepted Council’s arguments that he could attend meetings by remote access, and could view all business papers by arrangement at his solicitors office. The court also accepted that the criminal matters, AVO and bail issues mitigated against lifting the order on an interim basis. Further, the court found that there was insufficient prejudice or hardship against Mr Anderson in all those circumstances and the application for interim relief was dismissed.

The court made a costs order against Mr Anderson, meaning he has to pay Council’s and his own costs. Given the firepower on both sides, his bill would total many tens of thousands of dollars. Fast bucks indeed for round one in what could be lengthy and expensive proceedings.

A final observation – if Cr Ndaiye is re-elected and a final apprehended violence order is made in the Local Court, it is hard to see how the Land and Environment Court proceedings will remain relevant regarding Council meetings. The banning order would be usurped by the AVO. I was asked the other day what would happen if they were both elected. Well, that can be answered in just three simple words. I don’t know.

David Heilpern has described himself as a ‘trainee legal reporter’ but in fact is a retired magistrate.  

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Witch hunt ! Bucks has done more for this Shire in the past than all the pretenders filling the chamber currently. If people took the time to read, listen and truly understand his grievances they may have a better knowledge base from which to make a legitimate opinion. But, like the image in photo the Echo keeps using, he will be crucified at the hands of weak men and women. I have known Bucks for 40 years. He is not a physical threat tp anyone. Shame on those who paint this disgraceful image of him as though other Councillors are somehow in danger. The only danger ho poses is telling the truth and exposing some of you who hound him. Again, shame!

  2. If Sarah Ndiaye finds a rumbustious interchange with Anderson leaves her “in need of protection”, she’s not the resilient councillor I thought she was.

  3. Rossco’s right. Fast Bucks ought to have a statue in his honour outside the Council Chambers. Kept the bastards honest as best he could.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Growing number of dogs

Thanks to Alison Drover for her informative article in last week’s Echo regarding the growing number of dogs in the Shire to be managed...

Responsible dog owner

I read with interest Alison Drover’s article on dog management and the follow up letters last week, and I couldn’t agree more. I am indifferent...

Dogs need control

I agree with Alison Drover’s recent article and her final line ‘wildlife needs more love, and our dog owners need a tighter lead’. But the...

COVID update December 3: One new case and advice for international travellers

One new case of COVID-19 was reported for Northern NSW Local Health District (NNSWLHD) in the 24 hours to 8pm 2 December. Northern NSW Local...