13.8 C
Byron Shire
July 6, 2022

Tweed Council rejects BMX track development

Latest News

Road workers strike first time in decades

Road workers, construction crews and other Transport for NSW workers will walk off the job for the first time in decades on Thursday, as frustrations over the NSW Government's effective pay cut boil over.

Other News

Will Byron become the Malibu of the antipodes?

Here’s another reason for millennials to be marching on the street. We found out last week that on census day 2021, 15 per cent of the dwellings in the Byron Shire were unoccupied (2,348 places to be precise). That figure was 30 per cent in Byron Bay itself, three times the national average. 

After two-year delay Byron Shire gets to host the NSW junior golf championships

For the first time in almost 20 years, the NSW Junior Championships and JNJG State Age Championships are being...

Australian-first Surf Series and workshops ends in Lennox Head on Sunday

It might be cold outside but that's not stopping women who love to surf and over 100 women and girls will participate in the first female event series in Australia on Sunday at Lennox Head.

Commonwealth needs to step in to save endangered wildlife

According to the North East Forest Alliance (NEFA) the Commonwealth must intervene to save greater glider, the koala and the yellow-bellied glider from extinction.

Bike path? 

Byron Councillors please note: A painted line on the side of the road is NOT a (safe) bike path. Paul...

Destruction of Brunswick Heads mahogany

The foulest crime against the planet was committed secretly in the heart of Brunswick Heads during the pandemic lockdown....

The concept plan for the proposed BMX track and accompanying developments.

Councillor Warren Polglase gave a rousing speech in support of the Oasis Park BMX track and recreational facility in Tweed, but the numerous failings of the development application (DA21/0989), and already unprecedented pressure on council staff processing DAs, led the majority of councillors to reject the proposal. 

The proposal was for 271 Carool Road, Carool which is adjacent to a high conservation area with a zoning that doesn’t support the indoor aspect of the DA and was recommended for rejection by council staff. 

Initially, a motion was put forward by councillor Warren Polglase (Conservative), seconded by Cr James Owen (Liberal), to defer the DA and seek further information. Even so Cr Owen was clear that he had ‘big reservations in supporting option 2 [deferral] because of how deficient the application is’.

‘The big issue we have got at the moment is the huge backlog [of DAs] so just by supporting this it goes against what we have been fighting for and talking about for quite some time in council about trying to get the development applications down. 

‘By utilising staff time on this, something that is so far off what is required, the director just [said] that they didn’t issue an RFI (request of further information) because they felt it was so far away from what was required,’ he said.

‘I am happy to support this if this gets up… I don’t think there is anyone is denying that something like this would be fantastic for Tweed, you might get a few close neighbours who might not like it, you generally get that…’

Dr Nola Firth headed The Greens ticket in the Tweed Shire Council elections.

Reject DA says Firth

Councilllor Nola Firth (Greens) was clear that she did not support the DA and that it should be refused. 

‘I do not want to defer this,’ she told the meeting. 

‘I think what we have to do is reject it. To accept what the staff have said. There’s just contraventions of so many controls across various areas. And the scale of the proposal is something that doesn’t fit into the rural character of the area. 

‘I don’t see any serious attempt to address that fact it is sitting adjacent to an area of high conservation value with an endangered ecological community of lowland rainforest, there is threatened flora in it. 

‘There’s really significant issues such as bushfire… The areas that have not been addressed are so broad, there is: water management, storm water management, erosion, noise, traffic, Aboriginal cultural heritage, environment… its across a broad, broad range,’ she explained. 

The staff report also identified the: ‘Unsuitable road network; Ambiance & character impacts; Permissibility; Amenity impacts including noise / light; Scenic / visual impacts; Cumulative impacts; Flooding / rain events not considered; Lack of positive economic & social impact; Inadequate septic system proposed; Inadequate car parking; Inconsistent use of DA12/0524; Internet access impacts; Notification and consultation process; Concern regarding future mountain trails; and Inadequate information in general’ as other concerns with the DA.

Mayor Chris Cherry.

Fails zoning

Mayor Chris Cherry (Independent) then moved an amendment to refuse the DA seconded by Cr Nola Firth (Greens). 

‘I agree with a lot of what Cr Polglase said in terms of this is a fantastic facility and a fantastic idea. It would certainly be a great thing for our shire,’ said Cr Cherry. 

‘What I don’t agree with, and where I think our staff have taken a strong line and I really support it, is that the permissibility of this proposal is not clear. I don’t agree that it is best defined as a recreation facility development outdoor. I think it probably is a mixed development and we do need to consider that there’s a large area of this development that is much more closely aligned to an indoor facility, which is not permissible. 

Reports required

‘Whether we agree with it or not, whether it should be permissible, that is what the permissibility is. So I think we do need to consider that, we do need to think about that, in terms of what Cr Polgalse has suggested, that there may be aspects that we can support, and aspects that we can’t, that is obviously the crux of the matter,’ she said.

‘I think that rather than having our staff having to spend a lot of time assessing an application where there is definitely parts of it where there are aspects that we can’t support; I believe it would be better for the proponents to go back to the drawing board and put forward a proposal that is permissible in all its components. And include all of those reports that are very much a part of it. 

Planning consultants – provide the info 

‘I certainly did not agree with the idea that a traffic and a noise assessment aren’t required or aren’t thought to be needed. There is quite a potential for noise generation by this activity, and for that to be quite disturbing for the neighbours. I think it is very important that a proper acoustic assessment is done for this land use and that we need some consideration of how it would interplay with the existing approval of the site. 

‘There is much said about how things would work but not tin tacks of how those – the accommodation is only available for only those attending the health facility, but how that works with the recreation facility as well. 

‘On balance I don’t think this is a fair use of our staff’s time and I don’t think it is a fair expectation at this point to expect a request for further information. I think we need to change they thinking in our planning consultancy, in the industry, to put forward all the information at the beginning and not wait for an RFI, so we can assess it on the information when it comes in.’

Cr Rhiannon Brinsmead (Liberal) Tweed Shire Council.

Councillor Rhiannon Brinsmead agreed telling the meeting that while she was ‘in principle in favour of something like this‘ she was ‘in support of your [Cr Cherry’s] amendment. I think the application was deficient, that is why an RFI wasn’t given.’

Both Crs Polglase and Owen voted against the amendment becoming the motion. But Owen then voted with the other councillors in favour of the amendment to reject the DA once it became the motion. Cr Polglase voted against.

The proposed development included:

1. Concrete skate park;

2. Asphalt pump track;

3. Dirt jumps zone;

4. BMX competition jumps;

5. Slopestyle course;

6. Shed 1 – Comprising an indoor trampoline park and gym;

7. Shed 2 – Comprising an all-weather BMX track and amenities, offices, storeroom and repair shop;

8. Site access road;

9. 38 space car park; and

10. Events held on site (four times a year).


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

11 COMMENTS

  1. Generally speaking, teenagers are awful. However, they do need to be occupied for the safety of community.

    • “Safety of the community” Are you for real? Teenagers are a PART of the community. Nice of you to tar ALL teenagers with the same brush. Why don’t you crawl back into your hole and be quiet.

  2. There is nothing like this at all in the area, we NEED THIS!!
    Not for the TEENAGERS but more so the young kids who want to get out and ride their bike in safety and off the roads.
    It would have been great for the community and the younger generation. What a shame the council won’t push through with it… 🙄

  3. Notwithstanding any shortcomings that may or may not be present with the DA, the Tweed Council appear to have developed a novel way to reduce the backlog of DAs awaiting Council approval/action – not to defer any applications “to get the development applications down”.

  4. I agree with the council, tree rat are more important than our children’s health and well-being.

  5. Did anyone factor in how many people were likely to have a fatal vehicle accidents going to and from this “Project”? The road is a nightmare and almost everyone using it will have to travel that road to get there. We were up there a few months back, prior to the monsoon rains we just had and the road was frightening then. And yes, I know that road well, my children went to school there?

  6. Perhaps some flood prone housing area in Murwillumbah should be removed and the BMX track placed there instead? Or is that to simple an idea for our pro developer Liberal/”National Independent” councillors to process?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Extreme fire weather days in Australia have doubled

Extreme fire weather days in Australia have doubled, yet according to new research from an international team of scientists, including the CSIRO, extreme fire weather days have increased in Australia by 56 per cent over the last four decades.

Entertainment in the Byron Shire for the week beginning 6 July, 2022

Now showing at HOTA (Home of the Arts), Come From Away tells the remarkable true story of thousands of stranded passengers and the small town in Newfoundland, Canada, that welcomed them all.

Developer fees and charges cut

Council fees for construction and development in Byron were the equivalent of paying $160 for a coffee, making it ‘entirely unviable’ to invest here, industry representatives told the Council last week.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: To Hall and Back

There is something magical about a country hall. These small wooden buildings dot the landscape. They have a frugal modesty and an old fashioned generosity. If they had names they’d be called Thelma or Rose or Alan. They’re a pungent olfactory mix of last week’s wedding enmeshed with yesterday’s committee meeting. Curry and Jatz, tea and beer, tears and laughter.