9.7 C
Byron Shire
August 14, 2022

Iron Gates development in Evans Head ‘not good planning’ says independent assessor

Latest News

Criminalising protest

In another Sstate government descent into criminalising protest, to protect their own government’s sabotage of a liveable planet, last...

Other News

Recognising history

I arrived in Mullum from Sydney in 1976 – I loved the town and the people and felt like...

Tragedy of the commons

The tragedy of the commons refers to a situation in which individuals with access to a public resource (also...

Lismore Council votes against supporting Assange

At Tuesday's Council meeting Councillor Guise proposed a motion that Council writes to the Federal Government, Prime Minister and relevant Ministers denouncing the extradition of Julian Assange from the UK and urging the Prime Minister to make a public statement denouncing the extradition.

OS Community Garden launches food stall

Members of the Shara Community Gardens gathered on July 31 to launch their new food exchange stall on Shara...

Beekeepers can get a permit to move hives away from flood water

With so many challenges currently surrounding the bee industry, it comes as a relief to many that NSW Department of Primary Industries will issue a special group permit for beekeepers in flood warning areas to move their hives to higher ground.

A long and chequered career in cooking

When she was just 16, Elizabeth Jackson was kicked out of a home economics class – not because she burnt a pot or had a collapsed sponge, but because she made a black wedding cake.

Blue Pool Road clearing, June 2014. Photo supplied

A proposal for the Iron Gates site near Evans Head has been pushed by developers for over 30 years in one form or another. The local community has continued to fight against a development they have tirelessly pointed out was at risk of bushfire, floods, and damaged Indigenous cultural heritage and the environment. 

Flooding on the Iron Gates where building and infrastructure will be. And they say it doesn’t flood! Photo supplied

The current development application (DA2015/0096) is set to be decided on by the Northern Regional Planning Panel (NRPP) in the coming weeks and the panel did a site inspection last Friday, 22 July. The DA is for the ‘Subdivision of land to create 186 lots being: 178 residential lots, 3 public reserves, 2 fire trail lots and 3 residential parcels, associated works, infrastructure and the demolition of existing buildings’. 

The current DA has been running for more than seven and a half years and has been publicly advertised five times (2014, 2015, 2019, 2021, 2022) with 656 public submissions,  947 petition signatures and 23 postcards against the proposal and 249 supportive, many of the latter a form letter.

An aerial photo showing further clearing at the Iron Gates site in April this year. The state government has announced it could not find enough evidence to show the clearing was illegal. (supplied)

Independent consultant 

The Richmond Valley Council (RVC) had engaged independent town planning consultant Malcolm Scott to assess the DA who concluded in his report that ‘in his opinion the proposed development is not a good planning outcome having regard to the environmental sensitivity of the land and locality. The design of the subdivision is not of a contemporary standard and does not reflect or embrace accepted urban design principles which seek to generate a high-quality living environment’.

Mr Scott briefed the NRPP ‘on the recommendations of his assessment report of the Iron Gates development proposal and led the Panel to key locations in relation to the proposal on the site and its access’.

Site inspection

The site inspection was attended by four NRPP Panel Members: Paul Mitchell (chair), Stephen Gow, Penny Holloway and Peter Jeuken (with connections to Lismore City Council), a new addition to the Panel, and Stuart Withington, of the Planning Panels Secretariat. The Site Inspection was also attended by RVC assessment staff Angela Jones, Andy Edwards and Travis Eggins but not long-time council planner for this particular development Tony McAteer who gave an apology.

Protest at the time Iron Gates Drive was being bulldozed through Crown Land circa 1991, 30 years ago. Photo supplied

The developer Graeme Ingles was not at the inspection. Mr Ingles was director of a previous company Iron Gates Pty Ltd, now liquidated, which had outstanding Land and Environment Court Remediation Orders against it for previous work on the Iron Gates site. Mr Ingles had his existing DA removed in 1997 due to unauthorised clearing of the site and was ordered ‘to restore the land at a cost of $2m’. According to legal advice provided to Richmond Valley Council those Court Orders are still outstanding. 

Iron Gates property from the air showing Evans River in the background, and extensive wetlands, cleared land and regrowth of the Iron Gates. The bright green in the upper left with dug drain running along the left side is part of the original development of the 1990s which is under Court Orders for remediation. Foreground shows extensive wetland country. Photo supplied

Not fire safe

Mr Scott’s independent report also highlights the high risk of bushfire as a key issue and does not agree with the Rural Fire Service (RFS) assessment in relation to bushfire safety or the Heritage NSW assessment of the impact on Indigenous cultural heritage at the site.

‘I am particularly concerned about the high bushfire risk of the land and of adjoining land zoned for environmental protection (in particular for Iron Gates Dr) and that the alternate measures proposed to mitigate the risk and threat are not adequate,’ stated Mr Scott’s report. 

‘It is my opinion that many of the key issues raised in the objections to the DA and Concept DA cannot be addressed by conditions of consent and the submissions should be given weight in the determination of the Concept DA.

‘Having regard and consideration to the key issues relating to the Concept DA and my assessment of the proposal it is my opinion that the Concept DA fails to satisfactorily achieve relevant planning and environmental merit considerations and statutory planning controls.

Native Title Bandjalang People #3 30 April 2021 Determination. Lands surround the Iron Gates on north, south and east.

‘Having regard to the consideration to the key issues relating to the Concept DA and my assessment of the proposal and issues raised by submitters in objections I do not concur with the recommendations of approval by:

  • NSW Rural Fire Service regarding bushfire safety and
  • NSW Dept of Premier and Cabinet, Heritage NSW, Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Regulation, regarding impact on Aboriginal cultural history.’

Flood plain flows for Iron Gates from Six Maps.

RVC failed to support report

At last Tuesday’s (19 July) RVC meeting Mr Scotts report (Item 19.7) was ‘received and noted’ but no councillor moved that the report be ‘endorsed’. 

Long-term opponent of the Iron Gates development Dr Richard Gates who attended and spoke at Council’s meeting against the proposal along with other Evans Head residents said today that Council’s failure to support the assessment of the independent town planner and to note it only was a ‘Pontius Pilate’ moment. 

Evans Head residents objecting to the Iron Gates development. Photo supplied

‘Councillors could easily have taken a position on the independent town planning assessment and endorsed it but failed to do so leaving the community wondering why councillors had washed their hands of the DA,’ Dr Gates, who is an Executive Member of the Evans Head Residents for Sustainable Development Inc, told The Echo.

Iron Gates wetlands January 2005. Image supplied

‘We know that council refused to consider rezoning of the land to a more appropriate environmental zoning when it was developing its Local Environment Plan (2012). Not only did council refuse a Hearing on the matter which it was entitled to ask for, but declined to come to a well-attended meeting on the matter organised by the community. 

‘It would appear that despite wide-spread community opposition to the development reflected in the number of comprehensive objections to the current DA, successful Court cases in the 1990’s objecting to the development, and now a powerful independent planning assessment recommending refusal of the DA that Council is captive of the State government’s push for development without regard to consequences for the community and its wishes,’ he said. 

‘Council does not appear to be listening and seems prepared to support a development which puts people in ‘Harm’s Way’ in an isolated location subject to very high bushfire risk and flood and high impact aircraft noise. Has council learned nothing from the bushfires and floods which have so badly affected this community?! We certainly know that it has learned nothing about aircraft noise and safety.’

Dr Gates noted that those who are seeking further advice about the proposal will find very little current information about the development on council’s DA Tracker.  There is no mention of the independent consultant’s report and the disposition of the DA with the NRPP.  Council continues to fail to keep ratepayers informed about important major development matters.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. What do you do when many more people want to move to Evans Head and revitalise this resort/retirement village – but there is no more land available now due to the swingeing National Parks political decisions made nearly 30 years ago ?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Mullum pods

First, Hans Lovejoy’s article ‘emergency wedged’ was educational, factual and provided valuable information to the community. Michele Grant’s letter (27 July) was emotive overgeneralisations...

Flood residents get $650 from Lismore Council

Lismore City Mayor Steve Krieg today announced that 1,558 residents will receive a grant of $650 from the Lismore Flood Appeal.

Barilaro begs off today’s Upper House committee inquiry

Today's scheduled hearing for the Upper House committee inquiry into the appointment of Mr John Barilaro as Senior Trade and Investment Commissioner to the Americas has been cancelled.

The COVID-19 Booster: Latest news from the pandemic

The COVID-19 Booster is Cosmos Magazine’s weekly shot of the latest research, news and data from the pandemic.