What a dilemma Albo and Labor are in with Australia’s aspiration for ‘net zero’ while remaining one of the world’s major exporters of coal and gas (doubling output since 2006).
Albo copped a really hard time at COP 31. In his speech he reasoned that only the country that ‘burns’ fossil fuels is responsible for the CO₂ produced, and NOT the country that profits from selling them – otherwise you are counting the CO₂ twice.
This logic may have worked in the past, but with extreme climate battering the planet, there is an increasingly desperate doomsday tone to COP 31, and attendees are calling Australia to account.
Australia’s moral position is ‘if we don’t sell them our fossil fuels – another country will’. This is ‘the tragedy of the commons’. The atmosphere belongs to everyone, therefore no-one takes responsibility for it. The tragedy is this is half true (the other truth is that greenhouse gases go on polluting our atmosphere at ever-increasing levels).
Australia produces $139 billion worth of coal and gas, which after costs comes down to a gross domestic product (GDP) contribution of between $90 and $100 billion. This may seem like a shit-load of national income, but is ONLY between 3.5 and 4 per cent of GDP. Can Australia become a better global citizen by stopping the export of fossil fuels? I think so.
With One Nation’s Hanson and The Nationals’ Canavan, both climate change-deniers, and the Liberal’s Taylor stridently opposing anything Labor does or doesn’t do, the opposition will have a field day if Australia stops mining coal and gas. It is hard to imagine Labor would survive politically if they cut $100 billion off the budget – and all those ‘jobs’. We wouldn’t hear the end of it!
We Homo sapiens tinker with climate change at the margins but seem incapable of truly addressing the gravity of the unfolding crisis. Climate change is going to make the extremes of AI seem like a walk in the park.


For four decades The Echo has printed the stories some people loved, some people hated, and some pretended not to read. If you want us to keep telling the truth, the real truth, not the sugar-coated version. We’ll need your support to keep the presses rolling.