19.4 C
Byron Shire
October 28, 2021

Wasted prosecution over Bruns park action

Latest News

Concerns raised over the impact of opening up to tourists

The North Coast has seen a significant rise in vaccination however, spokesperson for the Cross Border Task Force and Tweed Shire Mayor Chris Cherry has told The Echo that there are significant concerns over the impacts as people start arriving from Sydney.

Other News

Editorial: Jabby jab jab jabb

As of this week, NSW reached the double vaccination target of 80 per cent!

Can businesses ask for your vax status?

Currently, throughout the business community, we are witnessing uncertainty with respect to business owners asking the question – should...

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: ‘What’s that, Skip?’

I love Kangaroos. Like most people my age I grew up eating my dinner off a Skippy plate. Seeing Sonny and Skip was a real incentive to finish my dinner. I wanted a kangaroo friend too. I wanted to say ‘What’s that, Skip?’ And Skip would tell me ‘There was a murder down at the gorge’...

10 point grumble

Hear hear to David Heilpern’s recent 10 point grumble, particularly points 7, 8 and 9. If the primary objective...

Mary’s Place receives welcome boost in Ballina

One of the major recipients of Ballina RSL's latest round of ClubGRANTS is Mary's Place, a drop-in centre and support service for homeless people and travellers in the area, supported by Vinnies.

Six new local COVID cases reported

Six new cases of COVID-19 have been reported for Northern NSW Local Health District to 8pm last night.

Readers are now aware that a district court judge has over turned a conviction for ‘disposing of stolen goods’ found against community activist Michele Grant.

This result was always a good bet considering the sheer incongruity of the charge but the process itself has proved both expensive and stressful and you don’t get your money back for being innocent.

One is left to ponder the ‘who’ and ‘why’ of the prosecutorial process?

The original action was initiated by local police three months after the actual event but the origin of any complaint remains obscure.

Ms Grant’s counter-request that police pursue an action against the caravan park operators for blocking a public road was ignored.

Considering that the charge was ‘disposing’ the question has always been who actually ‘stole’ the barriers to make them available for ‘disposal’- presumably none of the dozen or so activists of which Ms Grant was the only one to enjoy police attention.

The answer perhaps lies in the nature of the charge of ‘stealing’ where it is necessary to prove ‘intent to permanently deprive’.

This was obviously not going to fly considering that the goods in question were some scruffy road barriers which were relocated to the council chambers with explanatory notes left at both ends and in the accepted belief that they actually belonged to the council.

Accordingly, the police prosecutor came up with the ‘disposal’ option.

The magistrate then spent the best part of 1.5 days of court time going through a convoluted legal rationale to to find the charge proven – $750 and a criminal record, march out Ms Grant.

In the course of the case hearing multiple witnesses appeared, mainly for the prosecution.

The van park manager and park inmates testified to the fearsome demeanour (my interpretation) of the demonstrators, especially the six-stone Ms Grant.

A senior council officer had memory lapses as to correspondence and conversations pertaining to the ownership of the barriers.

Mr Bolger of North Coast Holiday Parks sat on the court veranda with prosecution witnesses for a whole day , he did not give evidence himself.

The matter of ownership of the goods was an issue as they needed to belong to the park to sustain the charge.

With most including the council staff  (another witness remembered a relevant conversation on ownership) thinking they belonged to council, there was a problem.

Rather fortuitously the caravan park manager recalled a driver who he said had delivered them to the park from a northern company destination – the magistrate adopted this version despite the driver not being called to testify.

Months later Judge Wells of the District Court took three minutes to say ‘wrong charge, conviction overturned’.

Tom Tabart. Bangalow


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

1 COMMENT

  1. well said Tom Tabart. It did appear there was a conspiracy to shut Michele up. Strange the police didn’t follow up on her complaint about the road closure.Best of all though..the charge and fine were dropped.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Should the Northern Rivers be opening up to mines?

The question of whether or not mining should be allowed in the Northern Rivers has once again been raised and the issue is being brought to the table in the NSW Parliament.

Paid parking review on the table for Byron Shire Council

Touted as their ‘first detailed policy position ahead of the Council elections’, the Byron Independents have announced their plans to expand pay parking in ‘other towns’ like Brunswick Heads and Mullumbimby.

Community sport warms up as restrictions recede

Amid the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the winding back of public health restrictions, summer sporting codes are doing what they can to get their season underway.

Freedoms and rights

Whilst I agree with most of Adrian Gattenhoff’s assertions in Letters (13 October: Perrotet and Opus Dei) I urge him not to be fooled...