12.1 C
Byron Shire
July 5, 2022

The Zeitgeist Machine cometh

Latest News

Celebrating 40 years of Fig Tree Restaurant

It all started with a simple dream, to convert its original farmhouse in Ewingsdale into a restaurant in which...

Other News

Attempt to manage Byron’s fragile coastline impeded by State Government, report finds

Insufficient funding and guidance from the State Government is inhibiting Byron Council's attempt to effectively manage its famous but fragile coastline, a Council report has revealed.

Active Fest and Olympics heading to Byron

Want a fun day of netball, rugby league, soccer, skateboarding, BMX, baseball 5, or tennis? The Active Fest is coming to the Cavanbah Centre in Byron on July 14.

Community members needed for health advisory groups

Northern NSW Local Health District (NNSWLHD) is seeking expressions of interest from community members to join health advisory groups.

Decades of volunteering earn prestigious NSW Sports Award

Brenda Zakaras and John Beasley from Lennox Head were two of 19 sports volunteers from a wide cross-section of...

Australian-first Surf Series and workshops ends in Lennox Head on Sunday

It might be cold outside but that's not stopping women who love to surf and over 100 women and girls will participate in the first female event series in Australia on Sunday at Lennox Head.

Lake Ainsworth

The heavy rain on 28–30 March 2022 resulted in flooding of Lake Ainsworth at Lennox Head to about 2m...

Photo Hernán Piñera flickr.com/photos/hernanpc
Photo Hernán Piñera flickr.com/photos/hernanpc

Online democracy is just a bit away, and not a nanosecond too soon

Phillip Frazer

In 1964, in first-year Politics at Monash Uni, I had to write an essay titled ‘Is a direct democracy possible?’ Our professors wanted us to prove we’d read Plato, Mill, Marx, Burke, maybe Arendt or Jefferson –or at least skimmed the study guides – and to conclude that giving every citizen equal access to decision making was so impossible that only tiny tinkerings were required to make our present system of representative government more perfect.

The future

But, being 19, I took the question seriously. Most of my learning back then took place in the student newspaper office listening to Damien Broderick, one of the editors, who was a voracious reader on the emerging topic of computers. He told me that, soon, we would be able to collect limitless data and compute it every way imaginable, and it occurred to me that if all voters could answer the day’s questions, a central computer would be able to spit out an endless series of consensus answers to questions like ‘Who should be allowed to marry whom?’ or ‘Should Australia generate electricity with nukes?’

We could also propose the next day’s questions, since asking is as essential as answering. I called the big computer in Canberra ‘the Zeitgeist Machine’, and suggested we could all have electronic keys to prevent cheating. Small screens with keyboards would be all over the place, like phone booths.

My tutor was wrinkle-browed by all this, which I assumed was because she still didn’t know if I’d read Burke or Arendt. ‘I don’t know what to give you so I’m making it a B+,’ she said with a nervous smile. Her name, I recall, was Michelle Grattan.

The zeitgeist

Today we have all the hardware and software that Damien said we would, and mostly we use it to facebook and twitter – but we also consume and produce massive amounts of political thought, news, and gobbledegook online.

Some believe we could now deploy the Zeitgeist Machine, though they mostly argue for gradual adoption of online voting, campaigning, and policy formation. The Online Direct Democracy Party is already up and running candidates Australia-wide, and like the more nerdy group calling themselves, somewhat unfelicitously, the Flux Party, they aim to be elected to parliament in order to then vote according to decisions reached by their party members online. (Observation: the leaders and staff of both these Australian parties are almost all men.)

I called my invention the Zeitgeist Machine ironically, to suggest the inherent flaw in my utopia, namely, that while the spirit of the times, or zeitgeist, might be digested by a machine, power would remain with those who own the machine.

Things have changed since 1965, existentially. Now we have Bitcoin, built on blockchain technology, which spreads control and content among so many players that none can usurp the currency, or in the political version, the power. I remain sceptical, but I’m more sceptical about the future of representative democracy.

Since Thatcher and Reagan launched the corporate-sponsored campaign to disempower labour (the workers, not the parties) and all social and economic groups other than profit-driven corporations, western democracies have devolved from being severely flawed arbitrators of power to become enforcers of the will of whichever warlords of capitalism are ascendant.

Parallel govt

So – rather than create new parties to challenge the warlords, how about we build a platform on which our citizens create a parallel government? Start with writing the rules for raising issues and resolving them, then build toward the constant formulation of policies. And even though this online mob would initially have no power to implement its decisions, it could announce them, challenging the inhabitants of the ‘real’ power system to take notice, whether the issue be enormous like global warming, pretty big like the Trans Pacific Partnership, or small but fun, such as writing a national anthem that doesn’t make everyone cringe.

The point of building a parallel system is to progressively subvert and subsume the present dysfunctional one, and seeds are sprouting in Spain via the Podemus party, in Argentina inspired by Pia Mancini, and by dozens of groups in the USA such as the Personal Democracy Forum, and its blog techPresident.

But I reckon we should get out in front of all these initiatives and start a real, living example of online democracy. Where better than in the Byron Shire? The council is almost all devoted to a people-run democracy, and thousands of our citizenry love gabbing on about every issue from Trump to potholes, so why don’t we do it here and now? Actually, local Flux Party nerd James Wright is already working on it, and, for what it’s worth so am I. Watch this space for further news…

By the way, if you’re thinking this is way-off-in-the-future stuff, consider where Bitcoin is right now: the central bank of Denmark is planning to issue a blockchain-based digital currency called e-krone as its reserve currency – and Ernst & Young (EY), one of the world’s Big Four accounting corporations, gives secure digital wallet applications to all its employees at their headquarters, and accepts Bitcoin payments for all of their consulting services, amounting to around $7.8 billion in 2016. It’s happening in finance now – politics tomorrow.

Phillip Frazer shares online political chatter on Facebook and at coorabellridge.com.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. I have a deep ingrained fear of being ruled by the masses. I think it would be a very unpleasant place for fringe dwellers and minorities.

  2. Thanks Philip, and the Echo, Switzerland has had direct democracy for more than half a century.
    They seem to do well with it.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Crabbes Creek Woodfired

By V. Cosford There’s a contingent of Europeans who don’t mind travelling a considerable distance in order to stock up on Jon and Gina Hutton’s...

Stone & Wood’s Brewery Festival Returns

Stone & Wood are opening the gates to their Murwillumbah brewery with the return of their ‘Murbah Open Day’, on Saturday 6 August. Welcoming the...

Decades of volunteering earn prestigious NSW Sports Award

Brenda Zakaras and John Beasley from Lennox Head were two of 19 sports volunteers from a wide cross-section of sports who received a Distinguished...

Happy New Year!

We all know we can help the planet by reducing our single-use footprint, so why not make a new (financial) year resolution that’s an...