17.2 C
Byron Shire
April 21, 2024

The strategic myth of the job snob

Latest News

Infrastructure for east end of Mullum

Mullumbimby was founded 135 years ago. In the 1960s sewerage was introduced, as was I suppose drainage infrastructure. Are...

Other News

Wallum urban development back in court

The company behind the Wallum housing development in Brunswick Heads is once again taking Byron Council to court, this time for allegedly holding up its planned earthworks at the site in an unlawful manner.

Wallum showdown unfolds in Brunswick Heads

Around eight people have been arrested so far, since almost fifty police arrived at the Wallum development in Brunswick Heads this morning to escort machinery and other work vehicles on to the site. Police include local officers, members of the NSW Public Order and Riot Squad, and Police Rescue.

Invitation to get to know the real Nimbin

The MardiGrass Organising Body (MOB) say Nimbin's annual festival will kick off with the launch of a very special audiovisual book on Friday 3 May, 'Out There: a potted history of a revolution called Nimbin'.

Reclaiming childhood in the ‘device age’

A century and a half ago, the visionary Henry David Thoreau declared people had become ‘the tool of their tools.’  In this device-driven age of smartphones, social media, and artificial intelligence, few observations could be seen as more prescient. 

Third village for Alstonville Plateau?

A proposal to assess the viability of a third village on the Alstonville Plateau was discussed at Ballina Shire Council's last meeting.

Local grom takes national tube-riding prize

Local grom takes national tube-riding prize. Broken Head surfer Leihani Zoric has taken out first place in the U/14 girls and best barrel (girl) categories of the Australian Junior Online Surf Championships.

Andrew Street

Why do MPs keep telling the unemployed to move to the regions? Because they know they can’t.

Whenever a coalition government wants to avoid awkward questions about why so very, very, very many people are without work, or why they’re removing support for those at the bottom of society’s pile, you can bet that they’ll immediately deploy their classic comeback: it’s the unemployed’s fault for selfishly remaining unemployed.

Former Employment Minister Michaelia Cash insisted that there were jobs ‘for those who wanted them’

Warren Entsch invented the term ‘job snobs’ back in the Abbott era, and it’s been the favourite go-to bad-faith lie of the federal government ever since. Former Employment Minister Michaelia Cash insisted that there were jobs ‘for those who wanted them’ back in 2019, even as unemployment soared and retail shed workers like sprinkles atop an unaffordable cake.

And in July last year, when much of the country was still in lockdown, ex-Liberal MP, Craig Laundy, did a lap of the Murdochracy to talk about how the real problem was employee laziness and not [checks notes] that incurable global pandemic which was really starting to hit its stride.

‘…and you’re offering proper wages for that, right?’

The rhetoric has ramped up ever since, especially with the regular coverage of noble farmers loudly bemoaning today’s lazy jobless refusing to leave the city to pick fruit, and then going very very quiet when asked ‘…and you’re offering proper wages for that, right?’

In fact, any time some lefty socialist troublemaker, like the unions, the Bureau of Statistics (ABS), or someone with eyes and a window notices that the jobless are doing it tough, the Liberals immediately dispatch someone to prissily declare that the problem isn’t poor economic management or deliberately punitive government policy, but that the unemployed are all feckless and indolent sluggards who simply won’t give those bootstraps an adequate pulling.

Trade Minister Simon Birmingham was trotted out last week to respond to criticisms about his government’s decision to remove JobKeeper and slash JobSeeker next month

And thus, like clockwork, Trade Minister Simon Birmingham was trotted out last week to respond to criticisms about his government’s decision to remove JobKeeper and slash JobSeeker next month, at a time when there are 129,000 job vacancies to be shared, loaves and fishes-like, between 1.3 million unemployed people. And his contention? That ‘there’s plenty of jobs in the bush’.

Specifically, Birmingham gave a speech (conveniently dropped to the Australian Financial Review) in which he declared that people could just move to regional Australia where jobs are appearing like cane toads after a rain – in agriculture, but also ‘mining and drilling companies who can’t find workers for drill rigs, or parts of the construction industry… Vacancies also exist in those tourism regions that have seen a resurgence in domestic tourism. Cleaning companies have openings that may previously have been filled by international workers, while demand continues to grow in the crucial care sectors’.


The thing is that even if that was not a remarkably optimistic overstatement of the case, there are plenty of reasons why the ‘just move to the bush’ argument is not a serious suggestion – starting with the fact that today’s unemployed are not in fact loveable cartoon hobos cheerfully riding the rails with a bindle over their shoulder and a pocket full of dreams.

It’s not that people might have family obligations, or local support networks upon which they rely to survive, or have medical conditions that require specialist services hard to access outside of a metropolitan centre

And it’s not that people might have family obligations, or local support networks upon which they rely to survive, or have medical conditions that require specialist services hard to access outside of a metropolitan centre  – although those are all great reasons which are incredibly common.

Neither is it the obvious, yet never-mentioned, fact that moving is incredibly expensive and would require finding new accomodation – and Anglicare’s 2020 Housing Affordability survey concluded that even with the increased pandemic rates, a single person on JobSeeker could afford a grand total of nine rentals in the entire country, so best of luck with finding cool new digs.


No, the reason that MPs suggesting the jobless should go bush is deliberate victim-blaming horseshit is simple: a person on JobSeeker will be kicked off benefits if they up and move to the regions.

You can read all about it at Centrelink’s webpage: ‘Moving to an area of lower employment prospects’, where the very first sentence runs as follows: ‘If you move to an area with less jobs, a 26 week non-payment period may apply’.


There are exceptions, like if you have a job offer, or can prove to Centrelink’s satisfaction that there are better prospects where you’re moving – but the idea that an enthusiastic seeker of work could simply up stumps from a state capital and lob into Geraldton to see what’s shaking is a transparent and cynical lie.

And MPs know this, obviously. It isn’t a serious recommendation so much as the federal government dodging responsibility for its handling of the economy.

Creating full employment is hard, and building a robust social safety net is expensive. But blaming unemployed people for their own predicament? That’s always cheap and easy – and for this government, apparently, it’s fun too!


Andrew P Street. Photo Daniel Boud.

Andrew P Street is a Sydney-based, Adelaide-built journalist, columnist, author, editor and broadcaster.

Apart from his monthly Echo column, he pens a regular column in the Sydney Morning Herald.

Mr Street is also the author of the acclaimed The Short and Excruciatingly Embarrassing Reign of Captain Abbott, and The Curious Story of Malcolm Turnbull: the Incredible Shrinking Man in the Top Hat. For more info, visit www.andrewpstreet.com.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. WOW! A journo who completely understands the rough along with the ready. Won’t take prisoners
    no-how… & I’ve read him in The Herald. Very pleased to learn he’s climbed aboard.

    • Yes dear Andrew also writes his own column on Patreon. You can sign up for lots more insight as above for $4.50 per month. Andrew also wrote the marvelously funny The Short and Excruciatingly Embarrassing Reign of Captain Abbott. If you love politics and also enjoy a good belly aching laugh, Andrew P Street is da man.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Save Wallum now

The Save Wallum campaign has been ongoing and a strong presence of concerned conservationists are on site at Brunswick Heads. How the state planning...

Can Council’s overturn their decisions?

NSW Labor planning minister, Paul Scully, when asked about the Wallum estate by local MP Tamara Smith (Greens)  in parliament on March 20, said,...

The bridges of Ballina Council

Ballina Shire Council has started preliminary investigation works at Fishery Creek Bridge, on River Street, and Canal Bridge, on Tamarind Drive, as part of their plan to duplicate both bridges.

Tweed Council wants your ideas on future sports facilities

Tweed Council is looking for feedback from residents about future plans for sport and recreation in the area.