18.3 C
Byron Shire
September 28, 2022

The psychology of COVID compliance

Latest News

This league of pets are super

The best things about the school holidays are the awesome films created for kids, and a great film for...

Other News

Lots happening at Lismore Regional Gallery

Holiday break workshops for young people, temporary public art and cultural landscaping are some of the arty attractions coming to Lismore and beyond in the near future.

Class action against Optus being considered

With an increasing number of Australians discovering they have been caught up in the Optus data breach, law firm Slater and Gordon is investigating a possible class action against the telecommunications company on behalf of current and former customers.

The Irukandjis sting in USA

Australia's national surfing team the Irukandjis have won a silver medal overall at the International Surfing Association World Surfing Games which just wrapped up at Huntington Beach, California.

Have your say on housing and growth

Lismore City Council is seeking community feedback on two draft plans intended to guide the location and type of housing to support recovery in coming decades.

Party with a conscience

Nudge Nudge Wink Wink – the party with a conscience, is on this weekend at the Billi Pub. DJs...

Unions meet with Norco over staff stand down

With flood-ravaged Norco in Lismore under scrutiny, the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union, the Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union, and the Electrical Trades Union met with management on Thursday to discuss the company’s plans for its Lismore ice cream factory.

Brought to you by The Echo and Cosmos Magazine


COVID-19 testing station at Byron Central Hospital. Photo Jeff Dawson.

A study by Australian and Canadian researchers has identified some common psychological features of people who don’t follow COVID-19 restrictions or advice. It’s a diverse bunch, but in general, the COVID non-compliant are less likely to be cooperative and considerate, less willing to learn new information, but more extroverted.

They’re also more likely to be male, and less likely to get their news from official sources.

Published in PLOS One, the study analysed results from an online survey of 1,575 people in Australia, Canada, the UK and the US, taken in April and May 2020. Participants each spent 30–40 minutes answering questions relating to COVID attitudes and beliefs, as well as questions around personality, cognitive ability, and demographic information.

‘It was very interesting to see that people openly talked about planning for the next week, going to visit a friend or family – something which was strongly discouraged,’ says Associate Professor Sabina Kleitman, lead author on the paper and researcher in psychology at the University of Sydney.

QR code check in

Overall, around 90 per cent of the participants were compliant with their current COVID restrictions. This varied very slightly from country to country – with 82 per cent compliance among US residents, 88 per cent in Australia and 94 per cent in both Canada and the UK.

‘It was a quite a remarkable consistency at the time,’ says Kleitman.

‘Now it could have changed completely, because that was during the first wave of the pandemic and the nations were very similar [in COVID restrictions]. Now they’re wildly apart.’

The researchers divided results into groups based on attitudes towards COVID, and compliance.

‘It was a surprise to us to see that the non-compliant, they’re not the youngest,’ says Kleitman.

The least compliant group had a mean age of 29.1 – with a wide variation across the sample. They were cognitively similar to the compliant, but had a few personality differences – including being more self-interested, and less open to new information.

‘We did not find any differences between groups in actual metrics of intelligence and decision making we employed in the study, but we found the differences in intellect: the openness to new experiences personality dimension,’ says Kleitman.

The non-compliant were less worried about COVID, but not less worried in general – they were just as likely to be anxious about non-COVID things as their compliant counterparts.

‘We also thought neuroticism would play a role,’ says Kleitman. ‘We thought people who are more predisposed to general worries and anxieties might be driving the compliance.

‘In our study [it] did not. Instead, it was just worries about COVID which separated these two groups.’

Kleitman says that while lots has happened between April 2020 and now, the research has potential implications for messaging around COVID restrictions – particularly the tight rules currently in place in Greater Sydney, which aim to keep the Delta outbreak in check.

‘At the moment, our message is beautiful: we are all in it together,’ she says. ‘It’s absolutely right, but is it reaching a non-compliant group who prioritize self-interest? I don’t think so.’

The non-compliant are also less likely to use official sources and traditional media for their information, so Kleitman suggests other methods need to be used to get the word out.

‘I’m not saying that the message needs to change, but we need some additional messages, and perhaps we need additional mechanisms for delivering them.

‘Perhaps through a trusted family doctor talking on community radio stations, and other community leaders discussing the dangers of being infected and spreading it to their loved ones, and benefits of compliance, including vaccination; perhaps through the creative use of social media.’

She adds that financial support is critical for increasing compliance. ‘Business and people affected by lockdown need the government’s support not to lose their livelihoods.’

This article was written by Ellen Phiddian. Read the original article.

Published by The Echo in conjunction with Cosmos Magazine.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

1 COMMENT

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Venice: Infinitely Avante-Garde

Come on your own Grand Tour of Venice next Wednesday at Byron Theatre. Explore the historic city and its openness to the world, and...

Byron Music Society’s Big Sing

Byron Music Society presents ‘A German Requiem by Johannes Brahms’ (Ein Deutsches Requiem), recognised as one of the greatest choral works ever written, at...

Wahlburgers in Byron

Walking into Wahlburgers on Sunday arvo, the sun was shining, the staff were smiling, there was a nice vibe and from our table we...

Caper Byron – it’s going to be food bliss!

Caper Byron Bay; Our Food and Culture Festival has launched their first program, inclusive of more than 30 diverse events and experiences.  Across a four-day...