19.3 C
Byron Shire
March 27, 2023

Controversial Iron Gates development open for comment on 24 September

Latest News

Janelle Saffin holds the seat of Lismore

Janelle Saffin is in the lead for the seat of Lismore after yesterday's state election. Although preroll and postal votes are yet to be counted, it’s hard to imagine Saffin’s position changing.

Other News

Election 2023 – Tweed: Ronald McDonald

Ronald McDonald is running for the seat of Tweed on behalf of the Sustainable Australia Party – Stop Overdevelopment / Corruption. The key element to their campaign is to reduce immigration to Australia from 200,000 back to 70,000 per annum. 

Election 2023: Crystal ball gazing and hot tips

In a tight election, with many predicting a hung parliament, all eyes are on Sydney seats to see if any Teals can wrest seats from Liberals – and can Labor regain an inner Sydney seat from the Greens?

Full Moon natural wine festival!

Full Moon Festival by Luna Wine Store welcomes 30 of Australia’s most exciting winemakers and natural wine importers to...

Homeless koala house hunting in Manly

As the trees continue to fall at the hands of the NSW government's Forestry Corporation in Yarret State Forest Blinky the koala has had to abandon his home.

We all live in a magic submarine…

Several commentators have remarked that, while the mainstream media is locked in furious agreement with the government over AUKUS and the trillion dollar submarines (a guess at the final price tag), social and independent media are telling quite a different tale.

Could Tweed Hospital see the first patient cannabis consumption room?

Marc Selan of the Legalise Cannabis Party is keen to keep the old Tweed Hospital open and says he would like to see the first patient cannabis consumption room at that site. 

The sensitive site of the controversial planned Iron Gates development, which the state government has refused to consider without a masterplan. Photo Supplied

It’s been going on for around 25 years, the developer Graeme Ingles, most recently of Queensland based GoldCoral Pty Ltd, has been pushing to develop the Iron Gates site near Evans Head since the 1990s while the community has pushed back. Now the community has 30 days to comment on the latest amended DA for the site before it goes before the Northern Rivers Planning Panel (NRPP) once again.

This follows a recent decision by the NRPP to allow an amended plan for the development under Clause 55 of the Environment Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000.

An approved development application (DA) was challenged and removed by the Land and Environment Court (L&EC) in 1997 after the developer took did unauthorised works at the site. The L&EC ordered around $2m of remediation for the site that has never been completed. This has been followed by repeat applications for a DA at the site with the current one being put in in 2014 for a 175 lot subdivision.

The decision to allow the amendment to the DA ‘came as a surprise to many because of the strength of the NO recommendation,’ said the president of the Evans Head Residents for Sustainable Development Dr Richard Gates.

The decision appears to have been influenced by the letter from the developers solicitor, Mills Oakley’s Aaron Gadiel which said that ‘…the applicant has determined that it will commence a Land and Environment Court appeal’ and that ‘The applicant proposes to use this process to progress the development application through to determination. The applicant’s hope is that this matter will be able to be resolved by a “section 34” agreement in the early stages of the proceedings’. Section 34 agreements are made through a Land & Environment Court Commissioner rather than through a full Court hearing.

The amended plan has gone back to Richmond Valley Council (RVC) for assessment and will go on exhibition on 24 September till 24 October.

‘That is just 30 days in which to digest the current material and prepare a response,’ Dr Gates told The Echo.

‘Because the amended plan is an amended plan it should share many similarities with the original plan, or at least you might think so. However, it remains to be seen how similar the new material is to the old.’

Dr Gates said he had received advice that ‘the amended plan should not have been accepted under Clause 55 because there are major changes to the plan. An example is the development being separated into two components, an initial plan requiring a DA and a second component requiring a separate DA approval, a ‘concept development’, at a later date. This is not a minor change to details which would fall under the rubric of an amendment but a major change with the requirement for a Master Plan apparently ‘disappearing’. I remain to be convinced that it is a not a new proposal.’

Evans River is currently in ‘poor’ health and locals are concerned that the proposed Iron Gates development will push the river into further decline. Image supplied.

Are taxpayers footing the bill?

The extent of the advice provided by the State government on the development considering the detailed advice provided by the State Government Architect (GA) in October 2020.

‘In a six page letter to the developer the GA states that “presentation to the Panel lacked detail on a range of matters” and “on the basis of the information provided” “a number of significant issues remain unresolved.” The letter then provided extensive advice about what needed to be done at this “sensitive coastal site of regional significance”,’ explained Dr Gates.

Dr Gates said he ‘wondered how many other developers received extensive advice of this kind and what precedent it would set for the future. But more than that who was paying for the advice? Was this coming out of the taxpayer and ratepayer pockets yet again.

‘This developer has racked up a substantial bill for us all given that this matter has been in effect running for almost a quarter of a century. It would be interesting to total up the real cost of this project to the public. We know that in legal costs alone the bill has gone past the million dollar mark. That is coming out of our pockets.

Dr Gates said he also had a problem with the fact that because the government was providing extensive advice for the development that it would be much more difficult to knock the development back.

‘The government is hardly likely to refuse an application where it has been providing advice even if the developer only goes part way to meeting the requirements of that advice,’ he told The Echo.

‘Yes, the NRPP is an independent panel and it has demonstrated that it doesn’t take the advice of the Department of Planning, Industry and the Environment in its recent decision to allow an amendment to the plan but ‘sunk costs’ can play a role in decision-making of which the decision-makers may not be fully aware. And other decision-making biases may creep into preparation of reports. There is extensive literature on decision-making in uncertain circumstances and certainly, the current proposal is not exempt from those psychological processes in decision-making. The current proposal is not just about black letter law but involves some degree of interpretation and dependence on others for advice.’

The back entrance to Iron Gates property from the Blue Pool Road at Evans Head. Photo Dr Richard Gates

Fire danger

Highlighting the fact that around half of the RVC LGA had been badly affected in the recent Black Summer fire Dr Gates said ‘Putting people in a harm’s way in a satellite development would seem to be a very unwise decision.’


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Will Provest win the Tweed seat over Elliot?

It appears that Tweed MP Geoff Provest will retain the seat of Tweed but there are still plenty of votes to be counted.

Tamara Smith returned to Ballina’s Greens seat

Last night a packed Suffolk Park Hotel exploded with cheers at around 8pm when the ABC broadcast computer popped up a Green result for Ballina and the return of Tamara Smith to the seat she has held for the last eight years.

Rosebank’s Rainbow Temple referred to the Land & Environment Court

Lismore City Council say they have referred the Rainbow Temple in Rosebank to the Land & Environment Court after the owner repeatedly declined to submit a Development Application and associated documentation for the development.  

Solé’s on a mission to help local dingoes

A local advocate wants to tear down the myths about dingoes, and stop their treatment as wild dogs, which she says they are not.