32.1 C
Byron Shire
February 26, 2024

RAT effectiveness: does it wane with each new COVID-19 variant?

Latest News

The Art of Woman highlights the upcoming Lismore Women’s Festival 

Friday evening saw a bountiful display of art at Lismore’s Serpentine Gallery celebrating the feminine and preluding the 2024 Lismore Women’s Festival. 

Other News

‘Key workers’ removed from Ballina Council’s housing project as Mayor seeks full market rents

Essential workers were the losers at the recent Ballina Council meeting when councillors actively removed the category for ‘key workers’ from their development of rental housing on land it owns in Wollongbar.

Wallum update: protectors at the ready

The fight to save the Wallum heathland in Brunswick Heads has gone into overdrive, with dozens of locals staunchly holding the line on-site, while thousands more lobby state and federal politicians in pursuit of permanent protection.

Pushing Up the Tempo

Paving her way in the music scene, Yazmin has played alongside some of the biggest artists in the world at venues throughout Australia, Bali and the UK. She has spent her time in the industry supporting the likes of Kaskade, Futuristic Polar Bears, Savage, The Potbelleez, Stafford Brothers, Joel Fletcher, Hilton Caswell and many more!

Editorial – Prosecuting publishers

WikiLeaks founder and Australian citizen, Julian Assange, will soon face possibly his final court hearing in the UK High Court of Justice over whether he should be extradited to the US to face spying charges. 

Mullum2Bruns Paddle returns

Exciting news for the 1,000 or so enthusiastic paddlers who come for competition, the dress-up fun, a family outing or showcasing their individual craft – the Mullum2Bruns Paddle returns !

Cartoon of the week – 21 February, 2024

Send to Letters Editor Aslan Shand, email: [email protected], fax: 6684 1719 or mail to The Letters Editor, The Echo, 6 Village Way, Mullumbimby, 2482, NSW, Australia.

Rapid Antigen Test.

Brought to you by Cosmos Magazine and The Echo

Regulator review underway, but rapid antigen testing is probably as good as ever.

Rapid Antigen Tests – or RATs – are probably as effective as they’ve ever been, even when it comes to new COVID-19 variants.

That’s because these tests seek out parts of the virus that aren’t inclined to change.

While the spike protein on the SARS-CoV-2 virus is the site of most immunity-evading mutations, RATs instead search for the nucleocapsid proteins below the virus surface.

The nucleocapsid – or N protein – is where the virus’s genetic material is contained.

A chemical reaction between this protein and the solution used to perform the test is what generates a positive marker on the RAT cassette.

Rapid antigen testing provides a quicker testing option to the more accurate polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests that are conducted in labs, but the sacrifice is precision.

During the early stages of the Omicron outbreak, Cochrane, a global health not-for-profit based in the UK, found antigen testing accurately correctly identified an average of 73% of symptomatic positive cases, and just 55% of asymptomatic cases.

Right now, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) is reviewing the performance of all “COVID-19-specific” tests. That includes lab-based PCR testing and all rapid antigen tests.

The review is being undertaken “as quickly as possible” in conjunction with the Doherty Institute and national Serology Reference Laboratory. In its announcement, the TGA noted that “[Test] manufacturers are required to undertake proactive monitoring to ensure their tests are not impacted by the variants of the virus.”

More on RAT effectiveness: How do Rapid Antigen Tests work, and are we using them wrong

Professor Deborah Williamson is a clinical biologist at the Doherty Institute, which is helping run the evaluations for the TGA.

So far, only one RAT – a CovClear product – has failed to meet the TGA’s minimum standard, and only when identifying wild type and Delta strains (it passed the Omicron identification threshold). Over 70 product evaluations are yet to be reported.

Williamson explains that even though these evaluations are highly systematic and specialised, they are lab-based. What they can’t account for is the biology of the person undertaking the test, which also influences how a person sheds a virus.

Prior vaccination can also alter viral shedding patterns.

“The nucleocapsid protein is under less selection pressure than the spike protein, so we see far fewer mutations [there], and certainly all the work we’ve done to date hasn’t shown any difference between variants in a laboratory setting and this is an important point for the [RAT] kits,” Williamson says.

“Having said that, each of the variants may have different kinetics in different people, they may shed differently.

“It’s not as simple as saying that the kits may or may not work, there are so many other factors that come into play.”

That partly explains why viral testing can lack precision: even highly accurate PCR falls short of a 100% strike rate for virus detection.

Paul Griffin, an associate professor in medicine at Queensland University and the director of infectious diseases at Mater Research, says a person experiencing any symptoms should see them as an important marker of illness.

Given that rapid antigen testing can “miss” infection, Griffin says a person with COVID-like symptoms who tests negative on a RAT should follow up either with another test, or a trip to a testing clinic to undergo a PCR.

“People need to understand they [RATs] come with some limitations, as does any test to be honest. They’re not necessarily infallible,” Griffin says.

“We need people to understand that COVID is going to remain a risk in our population, so we do need to look for it.”

This article was originally published on Cosmos Magazine and was written by Matthew Agius. Matthew Agius is a science writer for Cosmos Magazine.

Published by The Echo in conjunction with Cosmos Magazine.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. “We need people to understand that COVID is going to remain a risk in our population, so we do need to look for it.”
    We wouldn’t need to do so much ‘looking’ if we all kept taking Covid seriously like still wearing the mask in closed spaces – masks are still to be worn when visiting aged care settings,medical and hospital settings.

    Each week scores of Aussies are still dying from the Covid but no one in authority seems to take Covid seriously anymore.
    It’s all been dumbed down to “living with Covid”, so move on nothing to see here anymore.
    “Living with Covid”; tell that to the survivors of their loved ones that are Covid deceased; tell that to Looooooong Covid sufferers; tell that to our continuing over stretched health system workers and hospitals.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Union joins fundraiser to feed reporters in Gaza

Photos, footage, audio and news reports from the middle east show nearly everyone in the Gaza is struggling to find food and essential medical supplies, including reporters.

Man missing more than two weeks

Tweed Byron police are asking the public for help finding a man reported missing for more than two weeks.

Woman missing from Evans Head

Police are asking the public for help finding a woman reported missing from the Evans Head area but also known to frequent the Ballina area.

Teenager in Tenterfield crash dies in hospital

Police say they’re investigating a crash that killed a teenager in Tenterfield last week.