18.5 C
Byron Shire
May 27, 2024

Case of former Byron police officer accused of teen assault back in court

Latest News

Nearly 700 new EV stations for NSW

Nearly 700 new public kerbside electric vehicle charging stations are to be installed across NSW, in what the government says is the largest rollout in the country.

Other News

Homelessness service funded – but only for a year

With 2024 Street Count data indicating a 16 per-cent increase in rough sleepers in Byron Shire, the NSW government has responded to say that the previously-announced Assertive Outreach team will receive $1.3m in funding for a year.


The latest information supplied from Byron Shire’s Water and Recycling on future operational plans contains the term ‘renew’ numerous...

New attractions for Mullum2Bruns Paddle

There’s new free activities to enjoy at Banner Park in Brunswick Heads after this year’s Mullum2Bruns Paddle, which will be held this Sunday, May 26, from 9.30am till 2.30pm.

Shambolic roads

With regards to the Echo article, ‘Let’s dive deep into potholes’ (May 15), I am appalled at the attitude...

Trains on roads

Soon we will have electric self-driving cars. The number of cars around the world could drop to ten per...

A long story

I see that Israel supporters take exception to the expression ‘from the river to the sea’ as meaning that...

The NSW Supreme Court found that a local magistrate’s decision to dismiss assault charges for Michial Greenhalgh was an ‘error of law’. Photo supplied.

UPDATE: Magistrate Dakin has twice delayed today’s re-hearing of the youth assault case involving a former Byron police officer.
Lismore Local Court this morning heard the magistrate was still reviewing evidence and court would reconvene at 2pm.
Youth advocate and support person for the family of the former teenager, now a young man, Nicqui Yazdi told The Echo the ongoing delays were frustrating.
The young man, who cannot be named legally named here, was flanked by family and other supporters including Ms Yazdi, and appeared peaceful.
He said it was an emotional experience seeing the former police officer who beat him eighteen times with a baton, again in the court house but he otherwise felt calm and ready for whatever today’s outcome would be.
‘Things haven’t gone our way in the past so it’s not like we’re not used to it,’ the young man said.

The case of a former Byron Bay police officer found not guilty of assaulting a teenager five years ago in a CBD laneway is to be reheard in Lismore today.

Footage of the violent incident made national headlines in early 2018, leading to a Law Enforcement Conduct Commission investigation.

The viral video showed four officers deployed at the time at Byron Bay Police Station working to restrain a naked sixteen-year-old boy.

The state’s police watchdog later recommended the state consider charging one of the officers with common assault.

Michial Luke Greenhalgh was found to have hit the boy with his baton eighteen times of a total nineteen strikes delivered.

It was the final six blows that played a crucial role for Magistrate Michael Dakin in determining the former senior constable’s use of reasonable force.

Magistrate Dakin found the former senior constable not guilty after a prolonged trial in Lismore Local Court two years ago with pandemic restrictions still in place and public access curtailed.

But the NSW Supreme Court has since found an error of judgment in Magistrate Dakin’s verdict concerning the law around reasonable force and objectivity, leading to today’s rehearing.

It’s understood Magistrate Dakin, also a former police officer, has the option of recusing himself from the case and that the parties involved can also object.

Either scenario could lead to the case being trialled again.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Parents of teenagers need to be aware it could be their son an out of control “”courageous custodian of the peace ” beats up next

  2. Classic case of jail the magistrate for being complicit in the makeover arent these people ever accountable? Cops trying the cops…classic colonialism riddled with rum corps corruption.

  3. Hardly surprised by this police behaviour in Byron after having been almostvrun down by a speeding Bay policeman in an unmarked car and subsequently been violently threatened for verbally objecting to his reckless driving….amongst other unsavpury incidents from that crowd.

  4. “What error of judgment” did the Supreme Court find in Magistrate Dakin’s verdict for why the Byron Bay Police Officers were all found to be not guilty for what was seen on the video evidence of the beating ?

    • Thanks Neville: the DPP appealed to the NSW Supreme Court against Magistrate Dakin’s original decision, and the Supreme Court found that Dakin’s original judgment contained an ‘error of law’ (so it was an error in the legal reasoning contained in the judgment – more strictly speaking it was an error ‘in the judgment’, rather than an error ‘of’ judgment). As I understand it, Dakin in his judgment merely considered whether the police officer Greenhalgh considered his own actions necessary, whereas the correct legal test was that Dakin should have considered whether a ‘reasonable person’ would have considered Greenhalgh’s actions necessary. We’ve updated the story now to make that issue clearer.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

New community meeting room in Lismore

A new community meeting room, free for non-profit organisations and community groups to hire, has been launched at the Lismore Library.

New doco explores ‘God molecule’ found in toads

Are you ready to explore the secrets of the universe through the use of the most powerful psychedelic known to humankind?

Knitting Nannas off to Canberra

The prolific anti-fossil fuel campaigners are to meet with Federal Energy and Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen to raise concerns over Labor’s Future Gas Strategy.

Dutton doubles down on nuclear

Despite clear evidence that the Coalition's nuclear power policy is untenable, Peter Dutton and friends are sticking with this industrial-level distraction, forcing us all to talk about it instead of focusing on real solutions to Australia's energy needs.