27.1 C
Byron Shire
March 25, 2023

STRA campaigners gaslighting locals

Latest News

Rosebank’s Rainbow Temple referred to the Land & Environment Court

Lismore City Council say they have referred the Rainbow Temple in Rosebank to the Land & Environment Court after the owner repeatedly declined to submit a Development Application and associated documentation for the development.  

Other News

Nicola Levi supports a ban on mining in the Clarence

Independent Nicola Levi supports banning mining in The Clarance catchment and does not support a thermal waste incinerator at...

Adam’s second bite at the Lismore apple

The Greens candidate for the seat of Lismore, Adam Guise has run this race once before in 2015, where he gained a notable swing toward the Greens in the primary vote.

Election 2023: Crystal ball gazing and hot tips

In a tight election, with many predicting a hung parliament, all eyes are on Sydney seats to see if any Teals can wrest seats from Liberals – and can Labor regain an inner Sydney seat from the Greens?

Green support SSF and free parking at Tweed Valley Hospital

Protecting State Significant Farmland (SSF) and committing to free parking at the new Tweed Valley Hospital are issues Green...

Appeal to locate woman missing from Tweed Heads

Police are appealing for public assistance to locate a woman, Kara Symington, missing from Tweed Heads since Tuesday.

Could Tweed Hospital see the first patient cannabis consumption room?

Marc Selan of the Legalise Cannabis Party is keen to keep the old Tweed Hospital open and says he would like to see the first patient cannabis consumption room at that site. 

Main Beach, Byron Bay. Echo file photo.

The latest action from the short-term rental accommodation (STRA) campaigners is an alarmist email exhorting recipients to ‘Join the fight to protect your right to stay in a holiday home in Byron Bay’. This somewhat misleading headline from Byron Bay Holiday Rentals (supporters of the ‘Byron Deserves Better’ campaign) targets previous or potential visitors to Byron Shire.

Email sent out by holiday rental company seeking support against the 90-day cap.

On 2 March, just a week after the community consultation by the Independent Planning Commission (IPC), the holiday rental agency sent an email out maintaining the 90-day cap on STRA would ‘diminish your enjoyment of Byron’s beauty and hospitality’ and ‘your feedback would help us ensure that your next holiday in this breathtaking town remains affordable and accessible’.

Reading it made me angry. What about the rights of locals who purchased in a residential area? The right to long-term rent, the right to live where we work, the right to a peaceful night’s sleep, the right to have neighbours and the right to feel safe? What about those rights? Surely a place to live and work is a higher priority than ‘The right to stay in a holiday home’?

Sitting through the public hearing of the IPC (held in Byron on 21/22 February) with many other concerned residents I witnessed our community speaking up for itself. There have been many intelligent and passionate arguments from residents about conserving the very essence of this community, and a fair amount of fiction from the STRA lobby about the impact of lowering the recently legislated 180-day cap to 90-days, as proposed by Byron Shire Council.

Byron Shire Cr Sarah Ndiaye speaking at the IPC public hearing in Byron Bay. Photo supplied

Byron showed up

The public hearing was an opportunity to hear the voices and see the supporters of the 90-day cap and for the half-truths of those against the proposal to be publicly aired. The Council didn’t have the money or the fancy barrister that Airbnb used to bolster its arguments. Byron showed up. Everybody in favour of the cap or requiring some balance in the STRA sector spoke with a belief in the greater good of our community.

Firefighters, feisty CWA women, architects, town planners, anthropologists, medical professionals, politicians, and developers spoke in support of Council’s proposal and about the impacts of unhosted STRA on different sections of the community. What struck me as I sat nervously waiting for my turn to speak was that the supporters of the 90-day cap were concerned about the broader interests of neighbourhoods and the wellbeing of our people.

Many speakers against the 90-day cap in residential areas chose to phone in. The crux of their arguments was that reducing the cap would ‘kill tourism’ and put cleaners, gardeners, and waste collectors out of work. Non-resident STRA owners were worried they would lose part of the income stream their ‘trustworthy’ real estate agent had promised them. One commissioner posed the question to several interstate property owners – ‘Why did they believe that buying a house in a residential area would be available to holiday let?’ The common answer was ‘Well, because the real estate agent told me so’.

Main Beach, Byron Bay. Echo file photo.

Won’t ‘kill tourism’

Think about that for a moment. Unhosted STRA in residential areas only became legal in Byron Shire when the planning minister’s SEPP amendment came into force in January 2022. Most of the absentee landlords purchased when holiday letting was a prohibited activity in residential zones.

The 90-day cap is not stopping STRA in the Byron Shire. No one is trying to ‘kill’ tourism. Studies predict there will be sufficient visitor accommodation if a 90-day cap is introduced in June 2024. Approved accommodation providers (who pay business rates) such as hotels, guest houses and hostels have occupancy rates of around 65 per cent which is low for tourism hotspots. Four more hotels/apartment blocks are currently being built in Byron’s CBD.

Furthermore, under Council’s proposal, hosted STRAs anywhere, and all unhosted STRAs in 365-day proposed precincts, will have no restrictions. The hysteria being drummed up by STRA campaigners that the 90-day cap is anti-tourism is simply a beat-up designed to gas-light residents and visitors.

After listening to all the arguments against the 90-day cap, I’m still waiting for some cold hard facts. To the objectors to the proposal, please ‘own’ the simple truth that it is about money, money, money (as ABBA says) and do not pretend the focus is about Byron’s community, a family’s ‘right to an affordable holiday in Byron’, or that it will kill tourism. 

University researcher Dr Sabine Muschter has extensively studied the impacts of STRA in Byron Shire and other communities. Numerous studies show a significant impact on a community’s well-being in tourism hotspots. The negative effects of STRA platforms include an increase in rent and property values, the reduction of long-term rental accommodation resulting in worker shortages and extensive mental stress for locals (particularly families), and the disruption for residents through the noise, traffic congestion, overcrowding, and loss of amenity.

Based on 2019 visitor numbers, Byron Shire has one of the highest visitor-per-resident per-year ratios’ in the world. Approximately 65–70 visitors per resident per year, and a high ratio of STRA to residential dwellings. To put this in context, the average of the most visited cities in Europe is between four to six visitors per resident.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Great article Sabine – so impressed by you and so many of our commnity who made presentations at the IPC hearings.
    The holiday let industry is a disgrace.

  2. STRA should only be in a House both owned and occupied by the Host.

    Any other holiday accommodation should be under Council regulations, ie Motels, Hostels, or Hotels.

    • What if the renters spend half the year in Byron and half the year somewhere else. That’s not a holiday, that’s traveling with the seasons, as elderly people often do for their health. If you are getting young people breaking laws, that’s a law enforcement issue. Why are you not hassling the Police for refusing to do their job?

        • You seem to have misunderstood. I’m not saying they own the house, they rent in one location half the year and another location half the year. Some older people are very sensitive to seasonal change. They get stuck in side for six months of the year if they sit still. Has anybody done the stats on how many quite old people short term rent in Byron. What percentage of short term renters are actually a problem? I’d suggest most aren’t even noticed.

  3. Wonderful article. This is an incredibly important inflection point for the area, indeed the country as a whole as locals stand up to powerful lobbies shouting “that’s enough!”… The arguments proposed by the self-interested STRA are little more than insulting to the intelligence of locals. ‘what-aboutism’ doesn’t quite stack up when you’re trying to balance the needs of ultra-wealthy investors capitalising further while hard working people can’t find a place to rent for a reasonable price within an hour’s drive, yet the STRA wants to say it’ll devastate the community? Sounds like integrity has a price when it comes to the STRA lobby – hard to tell if they’re evil, naive or a bit of both.

  4. Very interesting that the email came from Byron Bay Holiday Rentals. This business changed its name to A Perfect Stay many years ago. The two main individuals who lobbied Planning Minister Anthony Roberts for an IPC inquiry into Council’s 90-day cap proposal were former co-owner of A Perfect Stay, Colin Hussey and employee Sarah Workman.
    The IPC publishes all submissions online. There have been a only few submissions already as a result of this email, all basically saying the same thing which has been highlighted in yellow by IPC staff.
    The commissioners made it clear that they did not like form letters or more commonly called astroturfing.

  5. Let’s ask the question the other way. If I spend 3 months of the year living in Byron, am I a local? 6 Months of each year? 9 month? What if I take a 1 month holiday each year and am only there 11 months a year? Are you complaining about the amount of time they don’t live there each year, or are you complaining about the type of people and their behaviour? Would the people of Byron have the same reaction if I was to start renting these places and giving free 90 day holidays to hood rats from Mullum? If people from Noosa were doing the renting, you wouldn’t even notice, cause they’re just like you guys, and act pretty much the same.

  6. Byron Bay has truly turned into an awful place due to this excessive push for tourism industry that took over the town. We simply dont go there anymore even though we dont live far away . Kids grew up going to Byron Markets as stallholders and being able to swim at Clarks beach


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Solé’s on a mission to help local dingoes

A local advocate wants to tear down the myths about dingoes, and stop their treatment as wild dogs, which she says they are not.

‘After Disaster’ film and live concert, March 27 

Working with kids from both The Pocket Primary and Upper Main Arm Primary in the aftermath of the 2022 floods, Janet Swain saw a need to support these kids, many of whom had experienced the full force of the floods and landslips, not once, but twice. 

Adam’s second bite at the Lismore apple

The Greens candidate for the seat of Lismore, Adam Guise has run this race once before in 2015, where he gained a notable swing toward the Greens in the primary vote.

Brunswick Heads off-ramp blocked at Gulgan Road by rolled B-double – driver dies at scene

Live Traffic reports that the M1 Pacific Motorway at Gulgan Road off-ramp at Brunswick Heads has been blocked since 6.10am this morning by a crash involving a B-Double where there has been a person trapped.