I listened to the CSIRO proposal and feel it might have been politically driven. I feel that scientists asked to perform miracles can be inclined to suggest ideas that are far from feasible. The dams proposed would be far beyond economic feasibility. It might even be cheaper to open the channel through Lismore (moving mountains…)!
The reality is that Lismore was built in the wrong place. Unfortunately, it is unlikely to be moved now, so there must be alternative solutions. I feel eventually, Lismore should be moved off the floodplain.
As buildings are replaced, the replacements should be built above the 16m flood height (i.e. off the floodplain). The flooding can be reduced in Lismore, but by using natural controls such as revegetation which slows floods, reducing maximum flood height. I feel Lismore will always be at serious risk from floods such as the 2022 flood, but the minor floods can be reduced in a cost-effective way.
Hopefully, the NSW government will understand the real costs of proceeding with the CSIRO proposal, then cancel the project completely. I feel it is not a project that can be completed one dam at a time: which means the project total cost could be in the trillions (i.e. far from feasible).
Even a conservative government would not allocate that sort of funding! What local residents do need is a definitive future plan that is economically feasible. Anything outside economic feasibility (such as the CSIRO proposal) should be permanently abandoned so local landholders are aware of future commitments.


For four decades The Echo has printed the stories some people loved, some people hated, and some pretended not to read. If you want us to keep telling the truth, the real truth, not the sugar-coated version. We’ll need your support to keep the presses rolling.