7.8 C
Byron Shire
June 13, 2021

Suspicious preferencing in the senate race

Latest News

Sailor rescued from ocean in overnight operation

In a dramatic overnight rescue far offshore North-East of Yamba, Marine Rescue IIuka Yamba volunteers were able to bring to safety a woman who fell overboard from a dismasted catamaran in the dark.

Other News

Ballina refuge fundraising campaign launched

Politicians from across the spectrum joined Ballina Women's Refuge campaign ambassador Mandy Nolan recently at The Cove Restaurant to launch a fundraising campaign for Momentum Collective's Woman's and Children's Refuge.

Independent Ballina councillor determined to reduce 4WD beach impacts

Independent Ballina Shire Councillor Jeff Johnson says he isn’t giving up hope for reduced 4WD access to Seven Mile Beach.

Cartoon of the week – 8 June, 2021

We love to receive letters, but not every letter will be published; the publication of letters is at the discretion of the online and print letters editors.

Bruns massive development

Russell Eldridge, Brunswick Heads Brunswick Heads is about to be hit with its biggest development upheaval in decades, with the re-emergence...

Free advertising

S Darling, Mullumbimby I think Dan Murphy’s put their vans outside schools and skate parks to elicit some free advertising. It’s...

Activists disrupt Land Forces Expo in Brisbane

Last week the Land Forces Arms Expo was held in the Brisbane Exhibition Centre in the heart of Southbank. Most people in Brisbane would have gone about their daily lives, unaware of what was taking place there.

famfirstweb 1200
Cartoon: Alex Mankiewicz


David Lovejoy

A record number of candidates and parties will contest senate seats on September 7.

However, voters should approach the plethora of so-called ‘micro-parties’ with caution: many are false entities devised by the hard right to game the election, and some are naïve outfits that have been manipulated into giving preferences to the right.

So if you wish to avoid supporting reactionary parties, only the Greens and the ALP can be trusted with an above-the-line vote.

The 110 candidates vying for the six NSW senate places available are divided into 44 groups. This is a lot of columns to squeeze across a ballot paper, no matter how wide, so the booths will be equipped with magnifying glasses for the tiny type.

You can vote with a number 1 above the line or numbers 1–110 below the line (and if you choose this method you must number all 110 boxes). Voting above the line with a single 1 (and it must be just 1 and no further numbers) obviously saves serious writer’s cramp, and the Australian Electoral Commission confirms that over 95 per cent of people vote this way.

This means that the preferences of 95 per cent of votes for the senate will be determined by the parties, not the individual voter.

When a ballot paper shows a 1 above the line for a particular party, the vote is distributed according to the preferences lodged by that party with the AEC. Most of the time those preferences would be roughly in line with the voter’s own. If you vote above the line for a left-wing party, for example, you will expect that party to preference other left-wing groups. Similarly with a vote for a right-wing party.

However, the need to keep one’s candidates in play and avoid having them eliminated in the early stages of counting often leads party managers to make preference deals with groups promoting utterly incompatible policies. Ends justify the means, they say: if teaming up with the Nazis helps keep us in the running, well the bleeding hearts can sod off, this is realpolitik.

Events last week within the new WikiLeaks party show this attitude clearly. Against the wishes of the rank and file, and indeed against the decision of the party’s own council, a little core group secretly changed the official preferences so that in most states hard-right parties, like the Shooters and Fishers and even the Nazi-style Australia First, were placed above the Greens ­– faithful supporters of Assange and WikiLeaks. In WA the National Party candidates appear on the WikiLeaks preference list above the Greens candidate Scott Ludlam, making him unlikely to retain his seat.

Apart from the question of principle – not the first consideration of a party apparatchik – there are two practical reasons why striking complicated preference deals with the enemy is not a good idea.

In the first place a preferential election with 110 candidates is extremely difficult to model. Knowing when the various candidates will be eliminated and hence when their preferences will come into play is the essence of this strategy. It can very easily be miscalculated.

In the second place, not everything is as it seems. There are hard-right political operators who have personally registered several parties essentially as fronts for syphoning votes away from progressive groups. They approach other micro-parties with preference-exchanging proposals which they say will be mutually beneficial, but whose only purpose is to open a serpentine voting path for, say, the Shooters and Fishers Party to get a candidate elected.

There is evidence to believe that the WikiLeaks core group who fatally damaged their party last week were acting under the influence of one such manipulator. But it’s not just WikiLeaks. Look at the preference lists of Stop CSG and HEMP, groups with admirable objectives. They both place right-wing shonks above genuinely progressive parties. There are only six NSW seats to be decided in the senate; five will go to some combination of Labor and coalition and the sixth will most probably go to either the Greens or the Shooters and Fishers. Which is why it is disastrous that Stop CSG and HEMP have preferenced the Greens so low:  if you vote above the line for either of them your vote will finish up on the pile of the gun-worshipping cretins.

If the official preferences of your otherwise favourite group are suspect, why not vote below the line so you can give them the number one spot without accepting their choice of preferences?

The difficulty is knowing what all the groups stand for. Apart from the mainstream parties and one or two single-issue mobs, there’s no telling from the names who they are. There’s a lot of Google time ahead of you if you take this route. Start with the helpful lists at www.gov.au and good luck. At least you’ll explore some very dark places in the Australian political psyche. Having done the research for this article myself, I’m voting below the line, putting the Pirate Party first and the Shooters and Fishers last.

But if you haven’t got the time, vote 1 above the line, either Greens or ALP. Each party preferences the other (the Greens after a short detour through some harmless micro-groups) and with each you know what you are going to get.

See the Echo’s full election coverage on the page Election 2013




Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. You don’t need to worry about looking up all the parties. If you vote below the line for say the Greens, number those candidates 1-3, then say the Sex Party 4-6 then number say the Labor candidates 7-9. Once that is done simply go through and number the rest 10-110. The preferences will have been used up by then.

    Also remember to vote above the line too; if you make a mistake below the line the above the line vote counts


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Three men stabbed in Goonellabah

Police say a man has been charged and will face court, while three men remain in hospital following an alleged stabbing yesterday.

Running out of time

Chibo Mertineit, Lillian Rock I just returned from the ‘Festival of Resistance’, which happened outside of the weapon expo at the Brisbane Exhibition and Convention Centre....

Three stabbed, man arrested – Lismore

Three men remain in hospital and a man’s been arrested following a stabbing in Lismore this afternoon.

Celebrating 35 years of The Echo

The Echo Awards, held every five years, was a great success on Wednesday night as it celebrated 35 years of local independent journalism in the Northern Rivers and the community that have supported it throughout those times.