11.5 C
Byron Shire
May 15, 2021

Metgasco shareholder bites back

Latest News

Bluesfest announces October dates for 2021 festival

After two disappointing cancelations of their event, Bluesfest has announced that they will hold the 2021 festival over the...

Other News

Locals call for automatic revocation of speeding fines on Hinterland Way in first half of April

When local man Nathan Hicks saw posts on Facebook about locals who had received fines they believed were incorrect he decided to look into challenging his own fine. 

Doing it right

How do you know you’re doing hummus right? When the international visitors tell you it’s some of the best...

Save Broken Head

Jan Barham, Broken Head Broken Head is precious but fragile. Again, it’s under threat and it’s urgent to act now....


Jillian Spring, Billinudgel In the article –  At a gathering of trainspotters, 21/4/21 by David Lisle, re Tweed Council Rail...

Father and son win first sailing race

Sixteen boats competed in the Tweed Valley Sailing Club’s race day earlier this month in a 10-12 knot breeze that suited newcomers to the sport well.

Water and the dam

Dr Roslyn Irwin, Caniaba An organisation called ‘Our Future NR’ is distributing and promoting information intended to put the Dunoon...

To those readers given the impression by the story Activists target Metgasco shareholders that I had somehow threatened an anti-CSG campaigner, nothing could be further from the truth.

I am a great believer in the democratic process, in the right to free speech and the right to campaign and protest lawfully. That’s why I live in Byron Bay and not Cairo or Moscow.

Regular Echo readers would recognise that I’m always happy to debate a point with others, take issue with misinformation, fear-mongering and blatant bullshit, whether the topic is CSG, coastal science or rail economics, and I don’t do personalities.

In this case, the gentleman in question, Michael Qualmann of Lismore, went to extraordinary lengths to obtain the names and addresses of shareholders in Metgasco, a company in which my super fund has held shares.

The fund like many other Metgasco shareholders purchased shares some years ago, back in the days when the anti-coal Greens were advocating gas as the low carbon ‘transition’ fuel.

Mr Qualmann then wrote a letter to shareholders advocating that we abandon our shareholdings in the company because of the actions that he and his fellow activists were about to inflict on the company.

Readers in The Echo were not informed that the tactics employed by Mr Qualmann are essentially those publicly advocated by the academic lawyers leading this protest out of Southern Cross University.

They are on record advocating that if they can destroy shareholder value in Metgasco by such tactics, then banks and other institutions will withdraw financial backing to the company and bring it to its knees. The same group have invaded the Hot Copper discussion site with similar tactics.

When you get an unsolicited letter via post, containing what is essentially a threatening and intimidatory message, even if couched in apparently friendly language, it’s not an unusual reaction to first of all look up the phone directory to see if the person really exists and secondly ring them up to see if they actually penned the letter sent in their name.

In this case I did both. In the subsequent telephone discussion, I made the very valid point to Mr Qualmann that those using such tactics have to be extremely careful not to seek the influence the stock market by unlawful means.

The quaint legal term I believe is the publication of ‘injurious falsehoods’. In relation to the authors of the letter, the law has particular relevance to individuals in competing businesses.

The recent fictitious ANZ press release purportedly emailed to the ASX by a young penniless man living in the forest is a case in point.

As a result of Jonathan Moylan’s ill-conceived prank, over $314 million of shareholder value was lost that day by shareholders around the country.

His anti-coal activism against the Whitehaven coal company has led to him facing trial in the Federal Court and some very severe penalties.

That’s why we have the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) to patrol the ASX, to prevent fictional and other mischief-makers and spivs causing chaos on the stock market where the vast majority of Australia’s superannuation is invested.

The fines and penalties for this type of behaviour are massive. In that case the young man is penniless and without property and a fine pointless.

In Mr Qualmann’s case, he appears to be a man of means, a Lismore energy business owner and probably a property owner. I simply made the point to him that indulging in such tactics was dangerous for a man of his background and he was in effect throwing caution to the winds.

Like all shareholders in a pension fund who hold shares in a variety of companies, I have no rights against the likes of Mr Qualmann and I can’t threaten him in any shape or form. I wouldn’t and I didn’t. Only the company, the target of the injurious falsehoods and ASIC have rights in these situations.

I do note that Mr Qualmann had contacted a sympathetic Byron Echo editor with a ready press release and handy photo to trumpet his story within hours of our conversation and he obviously hadn’t suffered any ill-effects from our conversation.

To those sitting in the comfort of university-tenured positions who are running around advocating these high risk tactics to well-meaning but ill-informed campaigners, you should be ashamed of yourselves. It’s cowardly, full stop.

Sign the letters yourselves and take all the risks on your own head. By the way, I learnt just today that a second round of letters has gone out to other Metgasco shareholders and guess what, they are unsigned. It looks like Mr Qualmann and his friends have heeded my advice!

To those directing their coward punches at Metgasco: it is a local company with almost 7,000 shareholders, many local. It’s worth a measly $45 million on today’s value and obviously vulnerable to a multinational with an eye on their large, proven gas reserves.

Metgasco simply wishes to supply much-anticipated power and gas to local industry, in the Casino and SE Queensland area, today’s state government REF approval is another step along the way.

I would guess that 90 per cent of super funds representing the bulk of all Australian employees are shareholders in BHP, AGL, Santos, Woodside and Origin, with probably $500 billion of production gas assets for domestic and export use.

Start writing to all these shareholders, boys and girls, it’s going to take a few decades.

John Vaughan, Byron Bay

Editor’s note: Mr Qualmann did not ‘contact a sympathetic Byron Echo editor with a ready press release and handy photo to trumpet his story’ as you assert. He did contact us and we interviewed him. The picture was taken by us from his website.

We also note that you were contacted for comment at the time but declined, presumably preferring to write almost 1,000 of your own words on the subject.



Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Well John. You make sense with your legal argument but the bottom line is I have little sympathy for those who continue to hold shares in any company that is drilling for coal seam gas. It is very much a short cut to nowhere as far as energy futures go and along the way it is going to compromise many aquifers and water supplies and adversely effect the health of thousands of farmers and residents in close proximity to the gas fields. That is the science. Your argument is legal only.
    So I suggest you stop antagonizing greenies just for the sake of your age old gripe about your beach front issues and look at the science and morality of each issue in a clear light.
    Find the reasonable person you once were before the endless war you have got yourself involved in destroys your integrity.

    • Thanks Mac for your comments, a few truths.
      I should always start will the obvious most overlooked unreported fact – There is no CSG gas or any other gas potential in any of our coastal areas Tweed, Byron or Ballina! Local coastal politicians and LTG’s drills in backyards fear campaign has all been blatant fear mongering and bullshit.

      Metgasco are not currently contemplating drilling for any coal seam gas CSG.

      Metgasco currently propose only drilling for conventional gas at Bentley [ the Rosella well ] just as they did a few years back with their Kingfisher exploration well further south of Casino!

      Metgasco suspended all CSG exploration drilling a few years ago and they are still waiting for a clear NSW regulatory regime for CSG.

      This may come when the NSW chief scientist delivers her long awaited final report on CSG harvesting.

      RE CSG: You said CSG will, “compromise many aquifers and water supplies and adversely effect the health of thousands of farmers and residents in close proximity to the gas fields. That is the science.” Have your bothered to watch the readily available doco “FrackNation” which has a totally contrary view?

      I would say that your statement is pure emotive nonsense not to be debate here. Let’s just see what the NSW Chief Scientist has to say her final report on the issue.
      I note the recent Victorian final inquiry’s report findings on your CSG harvesting concerns are totally contrary to your emphatic statement.

      CSG “short cut to nowhere”? With $billions of State royalties to come, your concerns don’t seem evident in Queensland where 30,000 people are now employed in the gas industry and there are over 4000 voluntary farmer agreements are in place. Qld agriculture is also lapping up the treated water by-product of the CSG harvesting process for irrigation etc.

  2. I have to agree with John! I’m from rural qld and I can say, csg has changed our lives for the better!

    We don’t know what drugs you lot in nsw are on but we don’t care. QLD is clearly leading the way and will reap the rewards. You lot have no idea how hard we are laughing at nsw ignorance.

    Do people marry their cousins down there or what?

    What is with Barry O’F ?? He destroys your industry and sends nsw back to the dark ages?? lol

    Anyhow, NSW will just become a playground for us rich QLD’rs and the wierdos down there will be observed from the comfort of our cars just as we observe wildlife in their natural habitat in Yellowstone park in the U.S

    Just be yourselves especially when I pull out my video camera and record you acting up in your natural environment!

    Good luck.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Power outage in Byron Shire

Power supply company Essential Energy says that approximately 1,780 homes and businesses were without supply this morning.

Filming of Byron Baes begins with no indigenous consultation

Filming of the Netflix series Byron Baes has reportedly commenced without any effort made by the show's production company – Eureka Productions – to consult with local indigenous groups or the local Council.

Byron Comedy Festival launched with a laugh

At a hilarious sold-out launch of the Byron Comedy Festival, Dr Karl Kruszelnicki had the entire Byron Bay Surf Club giggling last night

School Strike for Climate next Friday

Next Friday from 10am Byron Shire students will be demanding political action on the climate emergency in what they and their supporters say is our present, future and reality.