16.5 C
Byron Shire
May 25, 2022

Commercialising the digger myth

Latest News

Up to five times the average rainfall in some areas says BOM

The formal record of the extreme rainfall and flooding was released today by the Bureau of Meteorology with some areas of south-east Queensland and north-east New South Wales having five times their monthly average of rain. 

Other News

Temporary Protection Visas

As part of their pre-election strategy, Ballina Region for Refugees (BR4R) has been working to raise awareness of the...

Climate-related disasters influenced the election, Climate Council says

There was a clear connection between climate change-related disasters and voting in the Federal Election, according to the Climate Council.

Easy equation

In terms of the economy. Billions of dollars spent on armaments and the supporting structures, at the expense, the...

Fugly Design Award

I would like to second Nick Buckley’s idea for the Fugly Architectural Design Award (in last week’s Echo). Perhaps...

The postal vote that never arrived

At 91, there are many things that you can no longer do, but one of the things you still can do is have your voice heard in an election – but not for at least one Byron Shire resident.

Vote Green

In response to John Jennings, Numinbah (12 May), ‘Who shall I vote for?’ Simple answer – The Greens. From...


Review by Russell Eldridge

It’s about time a book like this came along, as a counterweight to the bronzed Anzac hero-worship culture that engenders a lop-sided, jingoistic view of Australia’s armed forces.

Anzac’s Long Shadow is not an anti-military book. Far from it. Brown is a former Army officer who has served in Iraq and Afghanistan and he believes in an alert, well-trained and, above all, well-informed military that continually re-evaluates itself.

But the original Anzacs have been ’Disneyfied’, he writes, to the point where those men who scrambled up the slopes of Gallipoli in 1915 would not recognise themselves.

Anzac has been ’bottled, stamped and sold’ reaching a commercial fever-pitch with next year’s centenary celebrations, which will cost Australia close to three-quarters of a billion dollars.

And here we come to his point: The Anzac hero status has been baton-passed to anyone who pulls on an Australian uniform. Our armed forces are untouchables, above criticism or self-reflection.

The result is ignorance and a dangerous complacency. Brown says no-one one knows how competent our generals are because there is no analysis, no political interest, and a ’chasm’ between the military and the public.

The ’Digger myth’ assumes we’re the best. This has implications for the frontline, too, where soldiers sometimes behave as though they’re bulletproof simply because of their forefathers’ reputation. On the flipside, many young soldiers feel inadequate because they can’t live up to the legend.

The outdated notion of battlefield success is storming positions in the teeth of withering gunfire and leaving the ground littered with enemy dead. But in modern conflict, Brown writes, a succesful day is one without violence.

Part of the problem is a culture of secrecy and control. Australian military personnel are hidebound by regulations that prevent or make it extremely difficult to write about their experiences. Fifteen years after the East Timor conflict, there is still no official history. Neither are there any for the Solomons, Iraq or Afghanistan. Contrast this with World War I, where Charles Bean’s history came out within three years.

And contrast this with Britain, Canada, and the US, where debate and military writings are encouraged with a view to learning from mistakes of the past.

There’s a lot more in this tightly packed, well-argued book, but it’s our military future that really worries Brown. He wraps up by arguing that because politicians, academics and military refuse to debate and study our past and present engagements, we are ill-prepared to plan for possible future conflicts. He goes into some detail, for example, showing how our military hardware purchases reflect outmoded thinking.

Brown acknowledges growing regional uncertainty as Asian powers flex their muscles and reposition themselves, but he decries century-old political and military thinking that doesn’t evaluate strategy, or put simply, what’s worth fighting for and how.

All Writers Festival Articles

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recognising 50 years of police service

When John 'Jack' Keough moved to Byron Bay police station in 1982 there was still a station sheep that kept the grass down and goats still roamed Cape Byron. Sargent Keough began his career in policing in 1972 when he walked into the Redfern Academy to join the police force. 

The postal vote that never arrived

At 91, there are many things that you can no longer do, but one of the things you still can do is have your voice heard in an election – but not for at least one Byron Shire resident.

Vale big Jez, Mullum troubadour

The Mullumbimby community lost one of the founding fathers of its counter culture last Thursday, when Graham Chambers, better known as Jerry De Munga, passed away at his home with the love and care of wife Chrissy, family and close friends.

Kashmir Miller: ‘the Green wave will expand’

Taking her first but definitely not her last steps into federal politics, the election campaign for Greens candidate for Page, Kashmir Miller, was exciting and tricky.