19.9 C
Byron Shire
June 7, 2023

Anzac myth promotes war

Latest News

The secret nature of the Iron Gates case

Despite a comprehensive refusal of the development application for residential development at the Iron Gates at Evans Head last year the DA is still ‘live’ in the NSW Land & Environment Court as the developer pushes back.

Other News

Playground at Clarkes?

Wondering what happened to the money raised to build a playground near Clarkes Beach in the early 2000s? Did Byron...

Keep the homeless in Tweed warm

It’s no secret that the Far North Coast has some of the highest homelessness figures in the country and...

Israel’s formation

In his apologia for Israel, what Danny Wakil failed to mention about Israel’s formation is significant.  From his description you’d...

Developer quietly revises large Suffolk DA

The company behind a controversial mixed-use development in the heart of Suffolk Park has quietly submitted revised plans for the proposal as part of the ongoing court battle over the matter.

Mad Hatter’s tea party saves koalas for one more day

This morning at the entrance to the Yarratt State Forest, near Taree, a Mad Hatter’s tea party celebrating World Environment Day on a logging road, stopped a truck heading into the forest.

Reconciliation and connection for brekky at Ballina Public School

National Reconciliation Week may be over but community connection efforts are to continue indefinitely at Ballina Public School, with Friday morning family breakfast a new weekly triumph.

The study of history is not about massaging our ego.

It should never incline us to romanticise our past so that we feel good about ourselves. Rather it should be an honest and balanced account of what actually went down – warts and all; and while this honestly may hurt, the discomfort it causes can help us to learn from past mistakes.

History is about learning from the past.

We cannot learn from the past however, if we focus on one aspect of our history only and ignore the context in which events took place. This incomplete and narrow perspective is how many Australians view of the Anzac tradition, that is, by focusing exclusively on honouring the individuals who took part in disasters like Gallipoli.

In their desire to make sense of the senseless, some Australians have created a legend populated entirely by heroes. Questions like why the Anzacs went and what they achieved by going to Gallipoli are ignored, while contemplating what we can learn from such disasters to create a more peaceful future is just too difficult!

Rather than seeing the Anzac tradition as confirming the importance of peace, some prefer instead the ritualised myth that offers solace and comfort in place of logic or emotional ownership.

Consequently, Anzac has become a sacred, semi-religious institution whose followers react with indignation when challenged about their dogma.

This situation does not encourage reason or learning, but arouses a strong pride in our military exploits and a willingness to keep repeating such experiences.

Unwittingly or not, the Anzac tradition encourages us to fight – again and again and again.

R J Poole, Lismore

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. As I see it, ANZAC day is a tribute to the brave Australian soldiers who suffered and lost their lives in combat so that their sacrifice is not forgotten, just that. There are 364 days left in the year to study and analyse the consequences of the conflict from every possible angle which, needless to say, is important too. In my opinion, one thing doesn’t exclude the other.

  2. Hello Juan – you seem to be suggesting that Anzac Day itself is sacrosanct and that analysis and comment about our history should not be made on that day. Is this correct?

    My point is that while Anzac occupies only a 24 hour period, the tradition itself has wide ranging influences on our cultural identity and foreign policy attitudes. What better time to challenge and confront these but on the day itself?

    The Anzac tradition does not represent, nor is agreed to by a very significant proportion of the Australian population. Each and everyone of us (regardless of our views) has a right to express ourselves on any day of the year and none of our cultural traditions extinguishes that right.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Vaping and young people – what can be done to reduce the impact?

Two community forums are being held to look at the issue of youth vaping. The first is taking place today in Coffs Harbour and a second forum will be held in Ballina on 20 June.

Man charged following shooting in Ballina 

A man has been charged following a public place shooting in Ballina.

Army depot construction starts in Chinderah 

Federal Labor have announced local Indigenous companies in Tweed Heads are starting construction of new facilities, which will benefit the Australian Army’s A Company, 41st Battalion, Royal NSW Regiment and 225 Army Cadet Unit.

Developer quietly revises large Suffolk DA

The company behind a controversial mixed-use development in the heart of Suffolk Park has quietly submitted revised plans for the proposal as part of the ongoing court battle over the matter.