16.5 C
Byron Shire
May 26, 2024

Big Rob fails to front court for AVO appeal judgement

Latest News

Surfing on the spectrum – free fun for everyone at Lennox and Byron this Sunday

Ocean Heroes will be giving children who are on the autism spectrum the chance to experience what it is like to be in the ocean on a surfboard this Saturday at Lennox Head and Sunday in Byron Bay.

Other News

Fastest billycart clocked at over 40km/h at Bangalow Billycart Derby

Sunday saw around 5,000 people head to Bangalow to enjoy the Bangalow Billycart Derby with Greg Nash, Bangalow Lions Club President, telling The Echo that it was a ‘glorious autumn day'.

First Nations job seekers in Casino foot in the door to career

Trying to find something you might be interested in doing is always a challenge and local Casino barber Michael Day has come on board to help Aboriginal job seekers the chance to kick start a career in the hair and beauty industry.

Only three flood buybacks done in Byron Shire

The most recent data from the Resilient Homes Program (buybacks, house raising and retrofits), administered by the SW Reconstruction Authority (RA), shows Byron Shire has just three buyback purchases completed, as of May 10, 2024.

NSW gears up for humpback migration with expanded disentanglement team

An expanded team of specialised rescuers are poised and ready to launch as tens of thousands of majestic humpback whales begin their annual migration along the NSW coastline.

Trains on roads

Soon we will have electric self-driving cars. The number of cars around the world could drop to ten per...

Lost in pronunciaton

Ivan Aristeguieta is ridiculously funny. What’s better is watching people try and pronounce his name – and then of course, it’s his deep dive into Aussie culture. Ivan has lived in Australia for ten years – as he says ‘living amongst you, observing you, learning about you’ – and now he makes a very good living taking the piss out of you. ‘I am a true blue, dinky-di Venez-stralian. Nah, she’ll be right! (Who is she by the way?).’

Former Lismore mayoral candidate Big Rob.
Former Lismore mayoral candidate Big Rob.

Big Rob was posting on Facebook on Thursday instead of appearing in the Lismore District Court to hear the judgement that dismissed his appeal against an interim apprehended personal violence order involving the Lismore Mayor.

Cr Isaac Smith applied for the apprehended personal violence order APVO against Mr Rob on February 8, claiming he was the victim of five years of harassment and intimidation on Facebook, which he said had escalated since he became mayor.

He previously told the court he and his wife felt harassed and intimidated by Mr Rob and feared for the safety of their family.

Supporting the application was a 24 minute video Mr Rob filmed and posted on Facebook, the day he got the APVO from police, showing Mr Smith’s house in the background, and screenshots of Facebook photos of the mayoral car outside the house displaying L plates.

An appeal against the APVO was lodged with court by Mr Rob on the same day he was informed by police of the application being lodged.

District Court started as scheduled at 10 am on Thursday, but when Mr Rob hadn’t shown up, Judge Laura Wells adjourned proceedings until 11 am to give him a chance to arrive.

By 11.15 am, Judge Wells wasn’t waiting any along and confirmed with Mr Smith’s barrister Michael McCall they could proceed without Mr Rob present.

‘The court is informed from various sources that posts are being made on his Facebook page,’ Judge Wells said.

‘It’s been an hour and he’s posting on Facebook and it would appear that no misadventure has occurred.’

‘The date this matter was put over to was made clear to him.’

Under the Crimes review and Appeal Act, section 28, subsection two, the District Court can perform any function the Local Court does, permitting the oral judgement, Judge Wells and Mr McCall agreed.

In making her judgement, Judge Wells considered Mr Rob’s 86 paragraph affidavit containing legal submissions, evidence and statements against the APVO and Mr Smith’s submissions showing screen shot evidence of posts, videos and statements.

Mr Rob claimed the interim APVO should be invalid due to Local Court Magistrate David Heilpern’s actual and apprehended bias which was evident from his previous dealings with him.

Judge Wells described Mr Rob’s conduct on Facebook as both intimidating and harassing.

‘It was intimidation by technologically assisted means, namely his Facebook account, that falls within the guidelines of intimidation within the act,’ she said.

‘(His posts were) an implicit invitation to others to make intimidating or harassing comments.’

Judge Wells ruled that Mr Rob’s submissions identified no actual or apprehended bias.

‘There is a degree of contradiction and confusion in the written submissions he made,’ she said.

‘No specific evidence is advanced beyond the bold and general assertions.’

‘There can simply be no conclusion of bias on the part of the magistrate, whether or not matters heard by this magistrate have been overturned on appeal.’

In dismissing the appeal, Judge Wells said Mr Smith had satisfied the onus of proof and the APVO was to be made in the same terms as ordered by magistrate Heilpern.

An application for costs was then lodged by Mr McCabe, with Judge Wells granting Mr Rob three weeks to file written submissions to the application.

Her finding on costs will be handed down after reviewing the submissions.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Message to the editor. Will you please stop pandering to this individual’s desire for attention. The best course is to ignore him totally and he will disappear. This is hopefully the last story. Surely you don’t have readers who only subscribe to Echonet for news of he who should not be named.

    No further comment.

  2. I have today applied for a copy of Judge Well’s application. I intend to retain it and should Robert Boo Hoo Hamdan AKA Big Rob ever apply to the Solicitors or Barristers Admission Board for admission to practice, then I will submit this as clear evidence of his total inability to be considered a fit and proper person to be admitted to practice.

    Boo Hoo has completely shot himself in the foot. I really hope that Isaac Smith wins the costs hearing and if he does I hope indemnity costs are awarded. Then the Mayor can bankrupt this clown. This will mean that for 5 years he won’t be able to run for any elected office.

    The end game is near. I can feel it.

    • Have a look at this goose online, claiming there is no South Lismore levee bank,
      “Big Rob The bank or the floor level may have been raised in a few spots but there is no levee bank. South Lismore is one of the first areas to go under.”
      “Big Rob The ‘wall’ runs along the eastern side of the Wilsons River and keeps water out of the CBD with the assistance of pumps getting rid of what is coming in from the east of the CBD.

      Everything else around South Lismore and North Lismore just attempts to direct water away from the CBD and down past the airport. It does not prevent flooding in South Lismore which starts to get inundated very early, long before overtopping of the CBD levee.”

      He has no idea…


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Wardell landowners asked to support fire ant eradication

Nearly 900 Wardell properties require treatment for fire ants, but the eradication team needs permission from each landowner.

The Darling Muffs of May need your help to reach fundraising target

Raising money to support frontline services for women who are homeless or at risk of homelessness has been the driving force behind the Darling Muffs of May’s fundraising this year.

Why does Iron Gates developer get another bite at the DA?

Locals, concerned residents and other parties were left in the dark for the first 15 minutes of the Iron Gates (Goldcoral Pty Ltd) Land...

Death and Dying expo May 25

On Saturday May 25, a free Death and Dying expo will be held at the Mullumbimby Civic Hall from 10am-2pm.