Tweed’s mega-hospital site ‘will kill off prime farmland’

A Glossy Black Cockatoo. Several of the endangered birds have been recently photographed in bushland near the site for the new mega hospital. The photos of the sightings and other data have been uploaded to the Atlas of Living Australia.

By Luis Feliu

A Tweed shire councillor says the NSW government’s preferred site for a half-billion dollar Tweed Valley Hospital will pave the way for the destruction on prime agricultural land at Cudgen west of Kingscliff.

Local vegetable farmers working the prized red soils of Cudgen are also said to be incensed about the decision by Tweed MP Geoff Provest and state health minister Brad Hazzard (see our story at

It is also a concern to local wildlife watchers who say endangered koalas and glossy black cockatoos frequent the area, just west of Kingscliff township.

While Mr Provest says the decision will bring a ‘jobs bonanza’, Kingscliff-based Cr Ron Cooper calls it a ‘a disgrace’ as it means losing prime agricultural land which many wanted to preserve.

The site, at the corner of Turnock Street and Cudgen Road opposite Kingscliff TAFE, would also be locked in during major floods in the area.

Rumours that the site is believed to be owned or controlled by local National Party ‘royalty’, Don and Lynne Beck (both former state MP and Tweed mayor respectively) have been denied by the office of National Party member for Tweed, Geoff Provest.

A spokesperson for Mr Provest stated that ‘Don Beck has never held any interest in this land, his family owns a separate and distinct portion of land in Cudgen and is not involved in this project.’

‘The site has mixed zoning including residential, agricultural and a nature reserve,’ the spokesperson said.

‘Development of this site will not fragment the Cudgen Plateau and its size allows for future hospital expansion and health and education developments without encroaching on surrounding farmland.’

When Echonetdaily asked if the Beck’s land would benefit from any re-zoning of the are in relation to the hospital Mr Provest’s office stated that ‘The Beck’s land is not involved with the hospital development in any way.’

Former MP for Murwillumbah, the Nationals Don Beck on the family land at Cudgen.

A blow to Cudgen plateau

The decision is seen as a blow in the hard-fought saga to save Cudgen plateau’s unique agricultural status, since the Anglican Church lost a court battle to build a school on another nearby parcel of prime farming land about 15 years ago.

A former longstanding Tweed mayor Max Boyd, who fought for years to stop the rezoning of the land, was not surprised by the decision to site the hospital there (see our previous story at

Cr Cooper told Echonetdaily that it was ‘a disgrace to lose prime agricultural land and ‘sad to lose the much-loved rural entry to Kingscliff’.

He said a survey of 1,200 people attending the Kingscliff market recently showed that 97 per cent wanted to preserve the Cudgen farmlands from development.

‘It’s important that the state government release the reasons other sites were not acceptable,’ Cr Cooper said.

‘It is essential that if the hospital is built on the prominent Cudgen farmlands, that Kingscliff’s three-storey height limit is respected.

He said it was believed the government changed the designation of the land from Land of State Significance to Land of State Importance, which was a ‘a bit like changing Lot 490 from Crown Land to Government Property.’

Endangered Tweed Coast koalas roam through the Cudgen area near the new hospital site.

Cr Cooper said it was changed ‘In both instances without consultation. In the first instance it was done to remove the protection from development secured by the Prime Agricultural Land zoning.

‘In the second it was to allow Lot 490 to be sold in freehold.

‘If the state government has changed the designation (to be confirmed) on the south side of Cudgen Road it would benefit the Becks.

‘That would pave the way for the total destruction of the prime agricultural lands of Cudgen,’ Cr Cooper said.

4 responses to “Tweed’s mega-hospital site ‘will kill off prime farmland’”

  1. Denis West says:

    As predicted the Greens have arrived on cue The point is hospitals and other essential services have to be built somewhere and there will always be dissenters whatever area is proposed. Every skerrick of land is habitat to some form of wild life wherever it is and proposals like this always miraculously just happen to be the home of some form of endangered fauna or flora.

  2. Ann says:

    My family also has spotted the Glossy Black Cockatoo – an amazing bird – in Kingscliff. There is an ongoing coordinated effort to protect the Stone Curlews which also get around Kingscliff. Personally, we have spotted echidnas in the park near the creek. We believe the wildlife, like the kids of Kingscliff and Cudgen, are relatively safe roaming our suburbs because there is a quiet, friendly atmosphere here with less traffic compared with other suburbs of the coast. Furthermore, after years of dedication by the surf and bowls clubs to encourage family-friendly patronage with renown surf contests, triathlons and life-saving events, the decision by so-called National Provest to provide zero consultation and ignore farming families and the clubs of this little seaside town is disgusting. Kingscliff has also built a national reputation for laid-back cafes and top quality restaurants that use local produce. Placing a mega hospital so close (within metres) of the tiny town crammed along the beach will turn the twin towns of Cudgen and Kingscliff into a concrete jungle and the shores into a needle-infested, rubbish dump. Where will the current Tweed hospital drug rehab clients – where there is no secret of violent offenders being dropped off – and the most recalcitrant clients needing cash for their next fix – go? between the cottage gardens of the elderly for some fast money?

  3. Geoff Hardman says:

    It should be noted that this piece of land is designated by the NSW Dept of Primary Industries as “Biophysical Strategic Agricultural Land (BSAL). Therefore protected by law. If they can change this they can change anything ….

  4. Neville says:

    Preferred site, not actual site chosen yet and seeing Cops couldn’t build their headquarters in that soil what chance do you think a hospital that takes up so much more space ?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Become a supporter of The Echo

A note from the editorial team

Some of The Echo’s editorial team: journalists Paul Bibby and Aslan Shand, editor Hans Lovejoy, photographer Jeff Dawson and Mandy Nolan

The Echo has never underestimated the intelligence and passion of its readers. In a world of corporate banality and predictability, The Echo has worked hard for more than 30 years to help keep Byron and the north coast unique with quality local journalism and creative ideas. We think this area needs more voices, reasoned analysis and ideas than just those provided by News Corp, lifestyle mags, Facebook groups and corporate newsletters.

The Echo is one hundred per cent locally owned and one hundred per cent independent. As you have probably gathered from what is happening in the media industry, it is not cheap to produce a weekly newspaper and a daily online news service of any quality.

We have always relied entirely on advertising to fund our operations, but often loyal readers who value our local, independent journalism have asked how they could help ensure our survival.

Any support you can provide to The Echo will make an enormous difference. You can make a one-off contribution or a monthly one. With your help, we can continue to support a better informed local community and a healthier democracy for another 30 years.”

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers.